17- karimi-farhad 11 - دانشگاه...
TRANSCRIPT
����� ���� �������� ���� ��
����� ���� ��! " #
��������� � � ��� ������ ������� ���� ����� ��� �� ! ���"#�� ����� $��%� &' �� ��#��()! � ��*�+� �� � ,-�* .�/��0
1!��� 2�� 3�4 ���� ����� ����
�� �� �����
���� ���������� �����
���� ����� ���� �� ����� �� ��������� ��� �� �� ��� �� !"#� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� � +, - �'
�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� ��$%&� /'2 3 * ��'��� �.��45� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� �"-�'6* �� �� 7�� *8� � .:�� � ;4* �� �<=4* �.��"&� �=� "* >���* ��?- �� �� ��� �� �� ��'�@A�� '� ����* +� �7��B�
�. (.�.�� 7'�* �� CD� ��1 E'5".� �F�'G� ���� ��F�'G� ���H�� E'5".� �� I��J �� 78 K� ��'� 7�� *8LL �6�'*�8 ��� � MN'$ �� �#. )�� M-�* ��� ���PQ��� �� !"#� ��#. �� M-�* �+, - �'PR�#. (
�� � ���)�� M-�* ��.��45� ��PA�#. (�4"F�� ���$ .:B���� ���T� U�J �� I�<�� �����7 *�8VC�7 *�8�1 ��'#"�� �� � ��� '� .�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �T4� � ;4* ����� �� 7�� *8C� 7 *�8 W��)� 7 *�8 �� �7 *�8
X�'Y*)DIT ( :F�� ���$ ����� �� * 78 ��'�'� Z&'1 �1 ��'#"��)AR/\=α.(��� ����� �� C� �?&��* �7 *�8�1� *8��� �� !"#� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� X*'1 �.��45� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� +, - �'
/�* �� �$%&� /'2 3 * ��'��� ^?)*@P��� �� M���� �� �Y?� ��� �� !"#� ���� ��� �' +, - �'�1 �_��� �.��45� .����7 *�8 �� ��'#"�� '� ' �'t��� X�?�� ��`�� ���� 7 Y-'- X� 7 *�8 �C.'��� - X�?�� �C.'�'
�'- �HT* ��1 ���H� :*%2)� �& (�- �1 ���� 7'6. �1 X�?�� :��� �� !"#� �� � +, - �' ���� ���������4)* :`b* �.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �1� �� �����"1�� 7�� *8 �.��45� �� �.������ �"1��. �
�� �:�������� �� !"#� �� �.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �1� �� +, - �' �� �7�� *8����� �"6�� ��� ��� �� ��� �� !"#� ��� ��� ��� � '02� �:�� �� � �� ��$%&� /'0$ ��d'� �?e�* �� '<��� �;. �� �+, - �'�"1�� ��"B� ��f?(2 ��.��45� ��� '02� '� �Y�'<*�.��4)* ��'*8 �;. �� �- � � ��� .C.'��� - X�?�� �4g(
��� ��� ��� � '02� �$%&� /'0$ �� ��1 �'T�� :`b* /����h� �- ��� 7'6.��� �� !"#� �+, - �'��� ����� �� �1'. 7 *�8DIT��� �� :-�1 �f?� �:�� �� .̀ 7 *�8 �� * '� ��'418 �''<��� M`� �6�'*�8 �
:�� ��1 'B.8 �$%&� /'0$.����! "�#$��:��$%&� /'0$ �1��'()* !"#� ���� ��� ��$%&� ��� �� �� �� +, - �'
�"-�'6*�.��45� �.
1i���� �� *8 /')N'=* �'!6�� �(?2 /'� 02 ��"���� ��'46.�� ���"-�)c jY* ��4Y� .(Email:[email protected] 2i7��B� �'!6.�� �'"�� 3i>��* :���� �'!6.�� �'�6.��
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
196
&'�(' �$%&� :����@�.�� �$%&� �1� �� +(- ��*� �� �'���� �� 7�� *8K';. �( �.'*�8 �'
���� �"1�� ���$ �"���� .k M?l�Me' ��$%&� :���� �- �.�<")* :���� ^�?)� 7��;. ���� �:�� ���3 ��*�»:����P:�� �$%&� n'��o ��*� «)��"�� :��Q�@qL@ �
��(��- �(���@QAq (�� �:�� �$%&� � *� ^�'#* �� ?(* ��� ( �����* r��* ��'�� �� �$%&� :���� � ���� ����� :���� �' �'(1�*��8)s���t�@qAA u
v'`46��� ���w�@qqt .(��� :�(� x�. ��'46.�� �� e �� �$%&� :�������� �� .��c'�� +* �;.R)@q\A�#�1 �� X<. �� uL�@qAq(��2'("�� ��'46.�� ��'�4� �N'Y* �
'02� 7��- �$%&��:�� �)*'� .�� �$%&� �1� ��$%&� :���� ^B* �')�� �� �f�:.���;.K B#* �W?"5* �'��'����� :�� �� �$%&� �1� �� ��'#"* �'�.� .M?l� �����;. /'0$ ��!. ��'"F� ��;. /'�$%&� �� ��')�� ���'(- �')cd�"�� (�� � �� *
�"F�� ���$ �.�)��#�1@qAq .(���;.��1� �'V�"&'41 A�y'�� ���;. ��;. �qz�`?- @\ 41 �� �"6��� :&'��* ��- �44-)�� '* � �x_��'. �:�� ��@@ �P\\\ (�- �.�<")* ���� MY- ^�<"Y* H&� Xk'e ��.�� { . � �$%&� �'����� c'<".� '� �=��* /�
�.��� r��* '� o c')F X*')� �� �1'. �f?� �:Y�. ��F �.�� K';. �� �.��� �*�Y* �� �.��� �'T4 7�1 �.�� :��:&'� Kx?" �.��� �'T4 ��'�� ��'�
:&'� � & ��'�� ��'�V�* EH� �� ���'& �*� �- �* �;. �� ��4- �H!� �� �- �.����.�� �4���F ���'�@P �"&'41 �'�'"&'� �� :�)$�)U�J���'@Q (�.�� ��'�@t
U�J������� '� ' /')$ � '�* /� k :�)$����� .�� ������ ��'���� �'� cd�"�� K';. �� �?f1 ��$%&�i��� |�� ���r��i �- :�� �2'("i:&'41 '� K'!(
2- education 4- Duric 6-Mc Dougal 8- Cognitive- Developmental 10- Kohlberg 12- assimilation 14- accomodation
1- Moral education 3- Hirst and Peters 5- Oser and Rieshenbach 7- Shaffer 9- Piaget 11- Rest, Narvaez, Thoma & Beabeu 13- Schema
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
197
�* c �� �.�� �1� Xe��* MYe�� ��'�.���;. �' �� ������'� �'� �� �"&'41 7�1'4�@�`4� ��-�� :�)$� ��'T4 �'�*�44-)����@qqL (�* }�F �- �44-
� ��'�� I��J �� |� -:&' ^;4* �4���F �� �.d')F ��2'("�� ^;. ��'4���� �2� $ ��'��* :-�'6* ���'*�8 ��3�F�* X�'. 7 *���� �'�.� |�� �� �4- � 1)�.'.V��?f4�
@qqt .(���;. ����1� �'V/�'`2 �$%&� �1� ��"&'41 ��� :�:»�.�� ���xF����� 7�1��'�4� �!4�F �' «'�»Xf1�'�)* ���� c�"4- ���� �.�� �'�'"F� «
)�z�`?-@qRA ('�»�4�� �- ��F �f#� � !N� �#�- ��'�� ��.'*�'��' �� �?k'e ^6, �� �� �$%&� �1� �?`$ Xe��*���"Y� ���.��* �,�'Df� ����4- «)�`N -P�
x!�� �z�`?-Q *�`�N t�@qAQ .(
7� 42 '� �y'�� +��%- �)N'=* - �$%&� /'0$ |�)@qQP(�� ��'�Y� �'4`* ����7�� �'�� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� e �� �"&'41�* �'(1 ��) x4��� -W���w�@qLt7 ".� C��- uR�P\\w (���;. �� � �� * ^ � 4 � /��;. 7������
:�� �$%&� c ��)�, .@L �@qqL .( K';. �Nx4* �� �� �$%&� /'0$ �1� ��y'�������* ���F� �� r��� ':&'� c G�* �� 78 :Y.�� r��* '� o X*')� ��'�
�2'("��)7��!�� '� �=��� (�* �;. �� '� K'!( ��$%&� /'0$ �- � � �<")* :F���* c �� �"&'41 �.�� �1� ��'�) (F'A�@qLq .( �;. �� ~%&� ��y'�� �;. ��:2'J� �4)* �� c'���& 7'-� -q�� �g� �N :�� 7d'Y��x� z�x� �' �� �� 78 ��
:-�'6* ��'f( �Nx4*@\ �* �;. �� � & 7d'Y( '��.��� .�- ��� 7'6. ��$%&� �2� $ �� 7'-� - ��'#"�� �!. !,@@�* ���� �N �� �4�8�F �2 . �� ��4- .
�� |� -t�N� w�$%&� ��� ��� �� �!N'� @P �* �� �� �� :`Y. ���� ��'� �2� $�'�8 �� 'B.8 '� ����. �(. :�'2��4- .�'"F� ��'6* I��J �� ��� �� �'B".� ��7'�� �
2- Colby 4- Lieberman 6- Krebs & Denton 8- Hoffman 10- Cooperation 12- premorel
1- construction 3- Biggs 5- Kurtines and Grief 7- Nucci 9- obedience 11- moral rule
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
198
c'Y��x� 7'-� -��2'$ �'"F� �� ��?<� �� ���� �2� $ �� :`Y. ��"6�� �'�8 �'B.8 �4*�* �4�)��#�1@qAq .(������ ~%&� ��$%&� �1� �?e�* �N� ��y'�� �;. ��@:�� .
7'-� -@\ �4"Y �.��� I?=* ���� ����� ��'� �2� $ �- �.� � �<")* �N'� �(.� ���� ���h� �� 'B.8 7.:�� ��?e�* �� �� |� -����� :�� c'Y��x� ���"$�
�����* ��k � � �- �. !.'( �� '�* �4- �4�2 ��'". �� � �$%&� /'0$ ���H� ����. �.��4, �� � :�. �� :�� x-�("* �'"F� �� �1'.)�.'.V��?f4� @qqt .( �� |� -
'� �!.����� X*')� I��J �� ��"6�� �"&'41 :�F�� MY- �� �� K��"e� �7d'Y( K� �?e�*)��� � & ~%&�P(�* :����'� .�*� �� ��'� �2� $ ��?e�* �� �� |� -�(. I?=*�* �� 'B.8 �- :�� �<")* �.�� �X(2 �4�2 �*'�� �� �%2 ��� ���h� 7� �
���� K'T.� �� X(2 �- ���F �4o :N'e :�. ���* �� � x�. �4- .�1� ����'4�&�i� �T�". ��y'�� �;. �� �$%iX*')���F �� �'Q:�� .X*')� �� I��J �� ��F �'���Xe�* ��N � ��'�* �;. �� �.'#G4* �- �4-�4�� .
z�`?-)@qRq (��� ��"Y� U%k� �� �y'�� ���;. .�- � � �<")* �y'�� 7 g( ���T� I��J �� |� -i�F �� �� & �'i1 �� �$%&� ^�'#* |�� 7��- �fiXf
�*X*'- �� �y'�� �;. �� * �$%&� �1� �4� Xe��* '*� ��� �4�8�F �-��� 7'6. ��- ���* � G� �y'�� �- �x�, 78 �� �"6�� �?�& ��$%&� c ���* c J ��-�6- .�;. ��
/�'B* �1� ����$%&� cd�"�� x�. �f#� �' /'#"* Xe��* �� ��F �H� Kx?"Y* � �1 ��)* :�� �N� "* �"6�� �4"Y �$%&� /'2 3 * ��'��� �f#� �� �k'&
7'Y.��� �� Xe��* �� '�* �J �� )k � J �44-)��#�1@qAq:wQ\ .( z�`?-)�`N - �z�`?- @qAL (�=� �� ����� �$%&� �f#� �- ��� 7'6.t����� �=� � P
*�?e�w*i��1'� .c� �=�)�F�2 ��� ~%&�R(cd�"�� �1� K� c� Xe��* X*'1:�� �$%&� .�$%&� cd�"�� ��=� �� �� � ��Fi* ���* � I�%2 �i� � 1:��
2- Autonomous 4- Level 6- Pre-Conventional
1- Heteronomous 3- Interpersonal 5- Stage
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
199
������� /��$ �* ��`4� �� �:�� 7��! ��'"F� �� �$%&� :��� �'"F� �x����*�.���1'� ��F �F'4* :*�& �� �- .K� �=�)�F�2 ~%&�@(Xe��* X*'1 �Qt�* �1'�
�* :B� ���h� 7��!�� '� �=��� :(� �� ���F I�%2 �� �$%&� cd�"���� .�'"F�& �;. �� E & �'"F� �� :�)`� ��$%&�:�� 7d'Y( ��� .' .�� �� �=� �� �� ��F
� MY- /��';".� ��2'("�� �2� $ :�'2��:�� 7��!�� ��_ .�$%&� cd�"�� K � �=�)�F�2��F ~%&�P�N k� '� Q(:�� ^61 ^T4� Xe��* X*'1 .�'�'� �=� �� ��
�* X��`� �$%&� cd�"�� 7 .'- �� ���F �G51� ��$%&� �'"F� �� 1 �~ <e �� �� �'����.'Y.� c k� '� 'i�.'!( �)�.'B� (* W��)�i��"�� & �)*'� ��F �� � 1�* �44- :�)`� 'B.8 �� � 1)W�=Nt�P\\\ .(
:�� ��� U�1 �� �#N * �� ��.������� �$%&� �1� �� z�`?- ��f��)����@qAR :( �$%&� /'0$ �T4� W�k �)�z�`?�@qwA �`N -u �z�`?- @qAL(��f�� �
�<=4* {'("��w)����@qqL (�� '� �$%&� :���� ����� �- ��$%&� /'0$ �1� �� �* � ��* ��� �� { 3 * ��� 1 ./%�R)@qRq (�;. ��� �- � & ��"-� �N'�� ��
��� ��� I��J �� �- ��� 7'6. ���� K'T.� z�`?-L�'<".� �$%&� �''()* ��'����* ���1 :����.�� 7� � �� ���d'� Xe��* �� �� 7�� *8�.'�� �$%&� /'0$ .�
7'"��� MN'$ �� �� �$%&� �''()*�.� *�8 �� �3�F �''�_��� ��'��� ��'� 'B.8 ����* /'0$ 7'"��� 7'*�B$ �'"F� 7� � �$%&��.��- .�.� *�8 �2 . }�)* �� '
* ���$ �$%&� cd�"���'� +� �.� � ��1 �e��J �"&'41 }�')� '<N� ���� �- �4"F���?e�* �� ��d'� �?e�* �:1�� ���$ 78 �� �$%&� �1� �;. �� �.� *�8 �- �.� � �� .
�� { . �� �� 7��� � � �- ��� 7'6. Xk'e ��'".icd�"1� ���xF� M`� 'i��.� *�8 �$%&�cd�"�� ��F �1 'X(2 �� ��'�*�.� � ��d'� �?e�* +� �- ��8
)�z�`?- /%� �� ��4- �'!. x�.@qLw.(
2- Post- Conventional 4- Latif 6- Blatt
1- Conventional 3- Principled 5- Just Community 7- Group Disscussion
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
200
Xk� �� ��� ��� �� �e��J �� z�`?-�"&'41 }�')�@�- :Y� � � �� 78 �� �f��2 3 * c k�P�� �$%&� /'0$ �1��* �'(1��8 .^B* �Xk� �� ���
c�')� ^�'#* ��"Y� �"&'41 �1� �'-�'��� �Q�� �1� ���;. �� �"&'41 �N�')� �� ��d'� �-�.� �- �$%&� cd�"�� �_��� �� �$%&� c �� �78 I�'=* :�� �y'�� �4o
��F �. 4- �1� �=��* �1'. :��� 1 .�T4* �4� ��N � �� ��?k'e �"&'41 }�')��*�* �"5�!.��� 78 ��� �� ��F �- � 1�4- Xe �� }�')� '� � 1 .�'T�� ���� z�`?-
}�')� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �� ��$%&� c �� '<��� �"&'41 }�')� x�*8��- ��'#"�� .I��J �� ��$%&� �''()* �� * �� ����"&'41 �!4'('. �'T��t�
�* ^��F �� �$%&� cd�"�� ��d'� �?e�* �� '<��� /'`� * �4-)�!4�"YF �� ��4- �'!.w�@qwL .(�* 78 I��J �� ��F �- :�� �4o }�')� �2 . ��"&'41 �!4'('. �1 -
��!. ���4- ���$�� �!4'( ���'"F� ' .�d'� Xe��* �� c'<".� �� ����� �� ��;. ���* X(2 �x�N'�'-�4- .���$ ��F �'�"&� �� ����4*��. �'��x�� ���d'� �$%&� Xe��*
�*78 '� '� ���4- :��� �� �N'Y* Xe (3 �� � & �'"F� ' .:-�1 ��� �� 7'��44-�* ��� * ��d'� �=� �$%&� cd�"�� '� �- �.'*� ��$%&� �''()* �� * �� �� ��. 1
78 � ��* EH��'���� �. 1�* ���$ ���� �� * �� � & �?`$ �' �4�)��4- �'!. ��N'� ��� �N� �W?� ��R�@qqA �W�=N uP\\\.(
��� ��'��� ��1 K'T.� ���T� �'����� �$%&� �''()* �� * �� ��� ��� � 7��'f( z�`?- �?�� �� �$%&� cd�"�� ��)�/%� ��;.@qRq%� u /
�z�`?-@qLw7 "4F �z�`?- ��`N - uE �WN� L�g�D�� �V ���� A� *�`�N @qLL (��'e��� �- :�� 78 ��q�* �$%&� �''()* ��'��� �.� ������ �$%&� cd�"�� �� �"`b*
.��i�� 7�� *8i� �'� �ii���H! .* ��'��� ��� �� ��i&� �''()i.�� ��$%i�7�� *8
2- postulate 4- Cognitive dissonancae 6- Self, Olivarez and Baldwin 8- Speacher- Dabbin
1- Cognitive conflict 3- Equilibration 5- Festinger 7- Fenton 9- Discussion
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
201
�* ���$ ��� �� * �� �$%&� �''()* /'2 3 *�* �4� �41 -cd�"�� � & �'��� ��4� ��3 � ���44- ��� � �� 78 �44- ���� '()* ���� �?e .^?)* �� �� ��
)�!1� *8 (�* �)� �- :�� �Nd�"�� �� ��d'� �?e�* +� �- �4- �_��� �Nd�"�� �4-�.���* �_��� ��� '� � *8�44- .� +� ~'`=.� �� ����%2@�* ���*'. � 1)|d�P�@qLA/�. 1 uVX6���Q�P\\t<. �� u �� �� Xt�P\\t .( /')N'=* �� �� ��
� ?�� 7� �N'� �+�)@qLP(z�`?- /%� �)@qLw( *�`�N �)@qLw(�#�1 �)@qLt (...�"F�� ���$ ��'#"�� �� * � |d �.�)@qLA (�(� �"Y5. �� �f� ����4� ��* '
7'6. ���- ����� �� 'B.8 ��$%&� :���� /')N'=* ��'<".� n'* (2 ��� �� �- �����4)* �1� ���* �T4* �$%&� cd�"�� �� ���� 1 .���* /')N'=* ��=��� �( ��
� N �?Y�d �:���.� r� � ��!��w)@qAQ(�4�(N �R)@qA@(C.�d �L)@qA\ (:��)@qLq (:�� ��1 K'T.� .�� �-'e ~ F �'��* �� ��1 ����� /')N'=* M?l�
� �- :�� 78$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��i�4)* �1� �� �� �T4* �$%&� cd�"�� ����* � 1)�'* � :�� �� ��4- �'!.@qAR.(
'* � :�� ��?F%f��A)@qAw (X�?����F �� C�qww ��'#"�� '� �- ���T� �)N'=* ��X_'Y* W��)� 7 *�8)DIT(@\ �- ��')N'=* M?l� �- �4"F�� �T�". �� � ��1 K'T.� ��
���- ��'#"�� :�G51 �"&'46.�� �1� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� �$%&� cd�"�� '<��� �� ��.� �������4)* �� �- ��')N'=* �- �N'e �� ��4"1�� ����
.'Y.� K ?2 ��2'("�� K ?2 >��i. �� * �.� � x-�("* �/'���� �i�.� ` .����� /��?&��*� ��� �� �4"`* �' �� �-�.� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��������*'.�� /� �1� �'
�.d J /%&��* �� � �"6�� :�G51 �1� �"&'46.�� �� ��@P'� �Y�'<* �� ��"# /%&��*@PVQ�"# ��������. ��"6�� i�4"1�� .�X�?����F �� ��Pq�?&��* �� �� * '
2- lockwood 4- Vezzuto 6- Leming 8- Schlaefli, Rest and Thoma 10- Defining Issues Test
1- Plus- one matching 3- Schonert- Reichl 5- Enright, Lapsley & Levy 7- Lawrence 9- Meta Analysis
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
202
�� �� ��i$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �i.� � ���- ��'#"�� �i��@q�� ��� * �*'.��7�� �1� �' �"&'41 :�G51 L�*'.�� �� �� * ��2'("�� K ?2 >�� �'
�.� � �"F�� ��B� .'� � � ����� M���� �� �~ F /')N'=* ���� ��� ����.� r� "*t@/\�QR/\\q/\7�� �1� ��� ��� �� � 7� � �� * �� �-'e �- �:�� �"&'41 .
'* � :��)@qAR (�4"F'� :�� �B�'6* ��'". �� x�. .x4�!�@)@qA\ (��* ����� ���� �*'.�� { . �� �� ��$%&� ���� �')�''()* ��'��� ��� X*'1
7�� ���� �$%&� ���� M�-�� ��$%&� �*'.�� ���T4� �"&'41 ���� �'�2'("�� /')N'=* ���� �*'.�� 7�� �� �$%&�(��� �- ��� 7'6. �1 X�'$ x�'(� �
'()* ��'����� ��'� �� �"B� �$%&� �'�* �T4* �$%&� �1� �� '� 1 .
��1 K'T.� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �� �� ��'#"�� '� ��!�� /')N'=*�.� .7��!�� �`N -)@qLL (�$%&� cd�"�� �� ��*8 � � �� /����h� �( �- �.��� 7'6.
� �1 :�� �� � :`b* ���� ��� �� :-�1 ��� ����� �_��� �� ^?)* �?�� � '�.�� I��J��R@P�.� � ���h� ^B* X*� 2 �� ��J��<� .�� �Q)@qLR (�- ��� 7'6.�* �. !,�.�� 7� � �?e�* �� �� 7�� *8t�?e�* �� �$%&� /'0$ w'�R��'(4��
��- .�?&��* /')N'=* �� �f�7 "F��� x`�� �x"� -�� �?�� � �� * ��t)@qA\ (��1 K'T.�:�� x-�("* �?e�* ���h� �� n'(�<"Y* .�$%&� cd�"�� �1� ��"6�� �)N'=* �� ��
�.� *�8 ���� 'B4� �- �*8 :��� ��'Q/@ ��'� �?e�* �.� � � & �'"( �� �� . �w
)@qq\ (�#N * ^�<"Y* C���� I��J �� �- ��� 7'6./�'B* �' ��$%&� cd�"�� �')/�'B*4* �'�<. �I=����R:N��2 (�.�� ��f?(2 ��$%&� cd�"�� �� 7�� *8
�4)* ���h�� � ���- ���� .�4�NL)P\\Q ��4�N �� X<. �� uP\\R (��� �- ��� 7'6.��� ����.� ����� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ���A:�� �B� � X�'$)t\/\=r(��
�* �"5��:F'� 78 ���� �#4* ��� ����.� 7� ���� �� x�. �65���� �� W?"5* �4� �'
2- Probing 4- Berkowitz, Gibbs and Broughton 6- Role- taking 8- effect size
1- Higgins 3- Boyd 5- Penn 7- Lind
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
203
���"Y� �'����'- :�� ���� &�� ��'�� K ?2 ���� /'2 3 * �� ���2'("��V���� �.'Y.� .�'* � x!4�*'-�. (g�� > .'��%� �C�@)P\@\ (�_��� �- �.��� 7'6.
�� *8 ��'��� ��� /'Y?� �� :-�1 �$%&� c �� ��$%&� cd�"�� �� � ��* �'r&�� /� k �� �$%&� �''()*P�=� "* ����"�� ^?)* :���� �"1� 7'� T6.�� �� �
)C.'Y�N ���(�4)* '<��� M`� ��$%&� cd�"�� ��(. ���� �'B.8i���� .�.��"Y*�8Q
)@qqQ ('<��� M`� ������'Ye ~%&� >�� �� �����'Ye 7'� T6.�� :-�1 �- ��� 7'6. �4)*�1 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �=� ��� .��� �N� ��N'� �W?�)@qqQ (�- �.��� 7'6.
^?�F �� * �� �$%&� ��� /'Y?� �� �f1x� 7'� T6.�� :-�1 � ��* �1� *8 �' ���1 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �=� '<��� M`� ��f1x� C���� .W�=N)@qqq (����� ���
��- ����� �� ��'���� K� c'� 7'� T6.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �� �$%&� �''()* �� * �� �� 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �- ��� 7'6. �4)* � J:�� �"F'� ���xF� ���� .�)N'=* �� �
��!��)�W�=NP\\\(������ ��'���� �� � ��* �$%&� �''()* �� * �� ��� ���$%&� cd�"��qRcd�"�� �=� �- ��� 7'6. ��- ����� �� ��'���� � T6.��
C� �� 'B.8 �$%&��� 7 *�8 ��� �� :`Y. �7 *�8�4)* � J:�� �"F'� ���xF� ���� .
��'��� z�`?- ���;. �� �- '�'<".� �&�� �� �;4F�k :�� ��1 ��� �$%&� �1�)7'!�?�� �� ��4- �'!. ��* ����t�@qAP �7 ".� C��- uP\\w �X�� � u@qAQ :�� u
�7��!�� @qqq^�� :�' �K'��� uV (F'- w�P\\A(��� �� /%� z�`?- �� �:�� ��1 �$� �'<".� �� * 7��!6�� �&�� � � �� x�. �$%&� .x"� -��)@qAP(�
-�� 7��!�� x"�)@qA\(�� �?k� I=4* �"~'`=.�@"+���� ���$ �'<".� �� * ���.� .���* �"�� & ^?)* �� �/%� ���.�� � 1 ��d'� �?e�* +� �$%&� cd�"�� '� �� 7�� *8
�4- ��� * .�� ��f?� :�� �� 1� �"�� & �� :�'�� 'B4� �. �7��'f( x"� -�� �;. ���* �;. �� ���7�1 �2'("�� �"4� ���;. '� �"6�� ��.� R���� I�'=�1� ���;. '� i��
2- Online 4- Gilligan 6- Socialization
1- Commings, Maddux, Cladianos & ichmond 3- Armstrong 5- Graham, Haidt & Rimm- Kaufman
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
204
1i� �� n'F�k �� ^?)* �- �z�`?- �y'�� �"&'4ic�* �1� +��� I� 6� 78 ��'��*�4- .�4�N)P\\Q �4�N �� X<. �� uP\\R (�''()* ��'��� ��� ���� �4�6.'� ��
U%=k� '� �� 78 �� (. �_��� �$%&�"x.'"Y. - �� ���� ''()* ��'��� ���@"�F�)*:�� �� (. .��� ����.� �z�`?- /%� �� '� �Y�'<* �� ��� �� �- ��� 7'6. �4�N
� $�* ��N � ��� K��"e� �4)� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �?k� �#N * � ���� �4-�� �� �� � �d'� �=� �`.'��� �� &��* �'- ����)��4�N �� ��4- �'!. x�.P\\w.(
���)@qAR (�� & �� & �� ��$%&� ��� ���� z�`?- �� �- :�� �<")* :��� /'(�(G�)�.d�'2 (�k X*')� �(. �(0� �� '02� �� �� �'"F� �� �4-
���`��PC���� )^?)* �'� (4� (�(.:�� ���( ��fF �<?� '� � �� �� �'- .K B#* �� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �'� �� �"�$%&� 7'("#�"Q�* ��'#"�� �4-
��fF �<?� �� E'4"�� ���� K B#* �� �- :�� �<")*t:�� �� * )�q@q .( ��* ��'(4�� '� Xk� �� �$%&� 7'("#���'.� � �� �'("2� �- �.�� �$%&� �2'("�� �'
�* �(0� �� |� -�� �� ��� 78 c (1 �4*�� �4-:�� �!�� �' .
�''()* ��'��� ��� �� 7� � �� * �� 6- �� ��'& /')N'=* �� �f4�� ^l��?2� cd�"�� '<��� �� ��$%&��* �;. �� �:�� ��1 ���� 7'6. �$%& �6�� 7 4- '� ���
�� ��i�.�� �� * �� ��'� .� 7'*� 6- 7�� *8i:�� ��6. K'Tw �� iN� �(i��� �X�
2- strategic 4- Indoctrination
1- The Konstanz Method of Dilemma Disscussion 3- Moral Discourse
wi�� n���&� �"`N���� �&�� 7'*� 6- ��1 K'T.� 7'-� - �� �#Y?F �� *8 �*'.�� E ,�', �� �- '��� � G5� ��.� �- ��'����� �6�� {'("�� ��)Community of Inquiry (/'0$ �� �� '-�4- �<?e '��.�� �$%&� �'���- ����� 7�� *8 �.�)�� ��4- �'!.
��*�x& K�<* ��'#k ��62�*@QAq(�.��� �'`��� �3'e ��� { 3 * '� ���$ �.��'6* ��'�� ��e '� �- �6�� {'("�� �� ��7'"��� MN'$ �� �1� *8 �� * �:�� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� �� z�`?- /%� ���.�� �� �#Y?F �' �� X`$ �� �- 7�� *8
��� E ,�',�"F�� Xf1 Z56* �'�* �_��� ��.�1� .�.������ ��'��� ��� *8 (3 � � :#� I��J �� 7�� *8 �� ��1 U�=* �'7'"����* :�� ���'<2 �� ��#Y?F �'�* {'F� � & ���<2 �� ��4�'���� '� ��44-�* �N', X�'<* �'�*�� �� � & �'=& ��44- /'f. ��4�'�
�* 1� �� ^B`* /'2 3 * �"F'� �� �44-��'� �'���* :�� �4�'� .�.�� X��`� ��6�� {'("�� �?k� �� �.��!1'- �� 7�� *8�* �1� '02� :�$%& 7��6��.� � �. 'B4� �. ��6�� �'0F 7� � ^-'e M`� �� 78 �� :�� �'* X(�� ��;. �$%&� c k� ��f?� �4-
�* �)� � x�. 7��!�� �� K��"e� ����* ���k �)� �7��!����'� .2�* 7��!�� �6)@QAq ({'("�� �� �� �#Y?F �� *8 �- �.��� 7'6.�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� ��6�� ����"�� ^T4� 7�� *8�����:�� �"1�� �"`b* .
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
205
� 4 ��$%&� :���� �� e �� �� * �?&��* �Nx4* �� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ����"Y�'1 �'!�'��*'.�� �� �� � 6- �1� *8 �' X(2 �� ��� * ��'#"�� 78 �� ����. '*
�(.��8 .���� ���� /'�$%&� �� *8 ��6�� ���T� �� 1 �� �� �'� �� ' :�� �4"`* �.��45� �� �� n'* (2 >���*)��(�'� �� ��4� �'!.@QLA (�� nd'("e�
:�� K�d ��8�'- �$'F /'�$%&� �� *8 �- :�� X�N� �(.
!�� � � ����� ����� 7'6. ��*8 X(2 �� �' ���� ��� �� �%2 �- �.��"-�'6* �� *8@��� �� C���� ��'� '� �Y�'<* �� ��"-�'6* � �1 �� +, - �'
���.��45� �?(� �� �� *8 �'P���� ��"6�� ����'- �.��� �%�� �'Q
)@qqR �@qAL �@qq\ �@qq@ �@qqt (�* 7'6.� �- �� �� �"-�'6* �� *8 � �"B� ��� 7'�* r��� ��"B� �?�G�� :F�6�� �� ��.��45� �� '� �Y�'<*):��
/'#� :`b* ���H� ��!��( "1�� '(.../x2 ��� �� � �"�� { . ��"6�� C#.�����* �T4* �'`0.� ��(. ���xF� �.��d'� K��* �'� 1 .:� 7 Y.'� �7 Y.'� "��t)P\\\(��* �� C� �q\\ ��"-�'6* �����'� �� �- �.��� 7'6. ���
�� �� ���� *:�� �� � �"�'$� '� ���F �����'� �' .�"-�'6* �����'� "�"�� 78 ���� ���* ��'1� �1� *8 �'�.�� ��- �4- �� ��!��!� �����'� �� +(- ���� 7�� *8
����* �'- ^ '� +, - �'�44-) "%�� � �@qqt .( X*')� X*'1 �"-�'6* �����'��.�� �.��'f(� *8V�.���� �'& ���� { 3 * �� * �� � *8����� �5� 7� 42 ��H�'.
���F ��i:�� C���� �4)7'!�-w�@qAq �� uR�P\\t .(���'� ��i-�'6* ��i��""�.�� ��'� � & �����'� 7�.'�� �b-��e �� ���� 7'��.����'�7�� *8 ��'f( ^ '� �
�*�44- .�� :F'��� �� C� 'B.8i� �� X()N�� "i���* ^�Y<� +, - �' �� ��. 1�* �'- W�N'f�'02� K'(� '� �44-�- X*'- �� W�N'f� �4(B#� �� M?=* ��� i�44 .�)�
'02� �( �- �:�� �� 'B.8��i� �1 - �� ��i� �!��fi�.�`� � ")��4`$%2 @QLR.(
2- Recitation- Presentation 4- Johnson, Johnson and Beth Stanne 6- Vezutto
1- Cooperative instruction 3- Slavin 5- Kagan
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
206
'02���* �$'� ��� �� �'* �4, '� �"# �4, nd ()* ��� /�'B* �4.'*�'��� �� ���* �"& *8 'B.84- ��'f( 7��!�� '� �4.� "� '� � 1�4./�'B* ���� �4��'`2 ' :� �
7��!�� /��;. �� �� � ��#* /'��3 � �_��� �c')F 7���) "� �%��@qqt �'!. x�. u7 YN'� :�'F �� ��4-@�@qqA .(�� �"-�'6* �����'� �� �� ��'#"�� �Y�'<*�'
�.��45� ��;. ��"4� �� *8 ...U�J �� ��'#"�� '�'6. �6�'*�8 �'�* 7�� �-R@:�<F * �� ��"4� �� '� �Y�'<* �� ��"-�'6* �����'� �� �� ��'#"�� ��� * �� �k��
�"F'� :�� �B� � 7'�'1 �� ��.�PL��(2 /'#� ���� * �� �k�� �� � �� ��7'6. �� * +� 'B4� �6. ��'6* � � �"4� �� :�<F * ��4�)7'(.(
��"-�'6* �����'� �� * ���"F'� �)� � ��'#"* �'��f�� �.� . �%��)@qq@ (�- ���� 7'6.t�"F�� ���$ ��'#"�� �� * �"-�'6* �����'� �� �?k� �� �- �.�
�� �4��'`2 :����.�� �(�� :F�6�� �' �����'� �� ��(�� �<�'Y* :�'$� �7�� *8* �<�#?� ��'!. :_��$ �^�� �� "F�� ��'� '� ����#.��"-�'6 .�� 7'�* �� �'
��� �� �~ F�� ��(�� :F�6�� �'���"Y� � J �"F�� ���$ ����� �� * �������� :�� ����� /'`�� �� �?�G�� :F�6�� �� 'B.8 :`b* .�� M?l� �����'� �'
�(�� :F�6�� c�* ��;. ��"-�'6*)� �%��@qq\ �@qqt(��� Kx?"Y* ��'t�� ��#. �.��*8��'.� � �� �- :�� �.�� �4"Y ���� &�� ��'#"* �' .��� �&�� �� ��;. '�x.��P)@qAw(� ".'F �Q7��!�� )@qq\ (���'* t)@qq@ (��� �� ��#. � �'
�* ��'#"�� � 1)� �%��@qqt (�� �&�� �� - ��;. 'w)@qAR( 7 Y.'� �7 Y.'�R)@qAq(7'!�- �L)@qAq(�7��'1 7��'1A)@qqP (��� �� x�.����.� '� ��'�'
�* ��'#"�� /'#"* � 1)�7 YN'� :�'F �� ��4- �'!.@qqA �7��!�� 7 Y.'� �P\\\.(
2- Dansereau 4- Maheady 6- Johnson and Johnson 8- Sharan and Sharan
1- Faust and Paulson 3- Fantuzzo 5- Cohen 7- Kagan
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
207
��"-�'6* �����'������ :� <� ��2'("�� �1� ���� �� r��� �� ��'�� /�/x2�.�� ��'�� & C#.�.�� X�'(� � `B� �7�� *8'<��� �����* �� 7�� *8�
��%f( �'�'T4�.�� r?Y� >'Ye� ��"B� �?�G�� ��f?(2 :B� �� ' �� 7�� *8 :-�'6* u����* �� �� & :1 .������ �� �� � �"��2 . ��d'� K��* �'
�* �'� �� ���H� )� �%��@qq@ .(7 f�� 7 Y?. �7 Y.'� �'*'��'* �7 Y.'�@
)@qA@ ���� * �� X<. �� u@qq\ (��� X�?����F �� ��"-�'6* �����'� �� � ��* �' ���1 ��* /'<�<�� �� �� �- �.��� 7'6.@\A �����'� �� �- �� * ��'#"�� �"-�'6*
:�� ��1 �T4* ��d'� �?�G�� :F�6�� �� � � ��1 .+D�"�� x!4�N'"��P)@qAR �� u7'( �� X<. (�� �- �.��� 7'6.A�� �� * q7 *�8 �� �- ��� * ��'#"�� ��%- �'
�� � c�"4- ��� �� �"6�� ��"-�'6* �����'� ��� �?�G�� :F�6�� ��f?(2 �� � ��1� �� x�. �� C#. /x2 ����* �� :`Y. ��!. ��"�� �����. r��� �4�*� �� ��
� � �"B� �� � ���.
x�. �$%&� �1� /')N'=* �� �"-�'6* �����'������:�� �"1������ �"`b* /� .x"� -��)@qA\(x`�� x"� -�� �)@qAQ (�N�'`� � !"#� �- �.��� 7'6.Q'02� �� �
�� ��"B� �7d'Y( �����4��:�� �$%&� /'0$ �?e�* ���h� ��44- .�� �*';. 'B.8@A c�'`� )�,�'Df� ��;.�Y�'<* ��d'� ��'0� ���'� (�`4� �- �.��- �e��J �� ��'
7'("#�t'02� �� 7'("#� �- �.��� 7'6. �4"Y �J'`��� ���� ')7d'Y( (���>%- >��* �'�'"#� '� �Y�'<*����� ��"6�� �.�� �$%&� c �� �?e�* ���h� ��7'� �
���� �N'- .��� c%& �� �- �.'� T6.�� ��.� � �����. �$%&� c �� �� �$%&� �'cd�"�� /'.'�� ���f� X�`$ �� ��'�'"F��* K'T.� ��4� � �' �2 . �� �f4�� '� �.���
+��)(� �� �w�* ����� * /'f. ���. 41 /'.'�� 78 �� �- �.�1 �� ��4� � �;.���(. E'��'���.'� T6.�� '*�'<��� ��$%&� c �� �;. �� �- �.�"F'� �� ��.� � �� � !"#�
2- Stallings and Stipek 4- Discourse
1- Johnson, Maroyama, Johnson, Nelson & Skon 3- Transactive 5- Collective monologue
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
208
�* ��'#"�� ��'�?(2�.��-)��, .@qAL :q@ ��4 ��-� �� ��4- �'!. x�. ��'4���@�P\\\ .(����� �' x"� -�� r� � ��*8 X(2)@qA\ �@qAw(7��'f( x"� -�� �
)@qA\(�!4��'� �x`�� �P�N F Q)@qqP (�* 7'6. �- ������� /'.'�� �<. 7d'Y( �� ��1 ��N �'<��� �� ���� ��� �'02� �?����'02� ��'� �$%&� cd�"�� �=�
z�`?- /%� �- :�� �x�, 78 �� ���)@qLw (���- ^���� 7d'Y( �<. �.�:�� ^?)* �<. �� �"6�� �'�Y�) .��4�N �� ��4- �'!.P\\R .(�� �;4* �� ���* �;. ���
����8 '� �"6�� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �� !"#� �"-�'6* �����'� �' ��"Y� ��"-�'6* �����'� E ,�', �� �$%&� cd�"�� ���� M�'4� 7d'Y(
�* ���� ��"6���4-.
�'���� ������"-�'6* �����'� �� e �� ��1 K'T.� /'<�<�� ��;. �'V�(� �� * x�. /'�$%&�:�� ~ F ��4� .��'� x"� -��t)P\\Q(�* ��'1� ��- �44-1� �� �"-�'6* �����'��4* �w/�'B* �$%&� �.�� �2'("�� �' �7�� *8�����
/�'B* � `B� �� �"-�'6* �����'� ���� ��'�� ��'f( /'3�')� XGF Xe �'�* �T4* �"6��� 1 . ��)P\\t(X�BY� ���� ��� * �� �� �"-�'6* �����'� �
/�'B* ��(� �1��)*'� �'�4Y�R WN'5* /��;. |�� �1� ��4���F �� :-�'6* �* 7'��.����'� {'("�� �� >�� >%- X��`��.�� .:4Y4�L)P\\Q (�- :�� �<")* x�.
�* � `B� �� �� & �)*'� �2'("�� �'"F� ��"-�'6* �����'� �'02� �� �. �� �65��* :� <� �� �)*'��4- .+� N' 7 Y.'� �7 Y.'�A)P\\L (�- �4"Y �'� �� ��
:�����.�� 7��- '418 �����* �?k� �� :�� 7�1 �2'("�� �2 . ��$%&� 7�� *8���� '���!. �'�<. �'�� '��� .'& |�"6* �� �- :�� 7'B� |���� �' �'
�* �4�F �)*'� �{'("���1'� .�?k� ��;4* �� �� �<?� �7�1 �2'("�� �`4� ���q
):�`b� (����$%&� �4* 'i����* :�� i* ��� �i�:���� �� e �� �� &�$%&�
2- Basinger 4- Bier 6- Prosocial 8- Holubec
1- Walker, Hennig & Krettenaver 3- Fuller 5- Character 7- Vincent 9- Inculcation
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
209
�- ��8 ^��F �=���1 �4- � G� �$%&� {'("�� �Nx4* �� �� � & ��'� ��1'� �� * �.���"`$��* :`b* r��� 7�� *8@)�.d jY* (^ '���%- ���$�� � & 7'(?)* '
�44-�����:�� �"-�'6* �����'� �����'f� Kx?"Y* � �� �J'$ .
�* 7'6. �6�� �� 1:�)$ * �� �7��!�� '� :`b* r��� �- �� �����'� �'�* �)� � �"B� �"-�'6*� � �� �� ��'������ ��.�'� �'��;. �� �$%&� 7�1 �2'("�P
r��* ���* �� �"6�� �"-�'6* �����'� �'�� .Kx?"Y* ��$%&� /'0$ �'<����'���� �� �� � ��"&'41 �$%&� cd�"�� ��d'� U =� �� ��'#"�� �� 7��!�� �'
�'���� �� �� 7� � �'� 7'.8 �'��;. 7��8 E'Ye:�� WN'5* �' .r���1 ���* �)� � �"6�� ~ F X*'2 �� � ��"-�'6* �����'��4�'� .7 Y.'�)@qA@ �� X<. �� u
��, .@qAL:q\(:�<F * �$%&� ��� �- ���6- ��� �� �;. �� �>%- �� �x�*8�' * �� ����i� �'�'"&'� �� �- ��i�"-�'6* ��Q� � +����- *� �'0F ��
�*�.�� .�6�� �� 1�* :�'(e 7 Y.'� �'2�* �� �� ��'�� �4- .
�"-�'6* �����'� �- :�� 78 �� �-'e �4�6�� �����������#N�* �� ��'�� �'��;. �$%&� �1� :�e%k �1�/�'B* ��4* �'/�'B* }�')� �F� �' �'
�.�� �2'("�� ���� 7�� *8)���'� x"� -��P\\Q uP\\w .( :4Y4� �;. ��)P\\Q(��.�� �'�"&� �� �"k�F �"-�'6* �����'��* ���$ 7�� *8 M$��* �- �.��!� �'� '� ��
�41'� ��� �'02� ��'� �'�'�. /'�'Ye� .7 Y.'� 7 Y.'�)P\\q (��� 1���- ��8����* 7'6. �- �.� '� �"�'$� �����'� '� �Y�'<* �� �"-�'6* �����'� ��
����F�������"6�� �'�Y� �'���� "F�� �;. �� �$%&� cd�"�� �� ��!�� �'�.��� .�* ���� ��"6�� �1� �$%&� cd�"�� ��"-�'6* �����'� r���1 �� ����.� �4-
'� ����� ����qL/\qQ/\�"-�'6* �����'� �Y�'<* ���� M���� �� V�����'� ���F �"-�'6*V:�� ��*8 :�� �� �"�'$� �����'� )�QL@(.�!�� �f� ���� Z&'1 ����)* ���'���� "F�� �;. �� �4)� �$%&� �1� �' '� :�� ����� ���!�� �'Rt/\
2- Constructivism 1- Caring 3- Cooperative goal Structure
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
210
R@/\:�N')F �� :-�1 �- �4)* �� �� ��� ��� M���* �� �"-�'6* �����'� �':�N')F �� :-�1 �'���� "F�� �;. �� ���� ��F :�F�� ��"�'$� ���F �����'� �'
�* ���xF� �� 7��!���� .���� �|'�8 � 4� - �;. ��V'� 7 � �.�� 4�� @)P\@@(��* o'5�� �� �$%&� �N'Y* Xe ��f�� ��"-�'6* �����'� �� �.'"�� r��� �=� �4-
���xF� �� �$%&� /'2 3 * �����'��*�� .7��!�� W?�)@qqA (����� ��� ��� ��� *+, - �'P�.��- ����� �f1x� 7'� T6.�� �$%&� �1� �� �� .'B.8
�$%&� cd�"��LPq c'� �� �- �N J �)N'=* �� �f1x� � T6.�� @qq@ '� @qqA ��� �� �$%&� ��� �� :-�1 �� C� ��� �� �:F'� �*��� �� * �� +, - �'
�'Y* /�* �� �- �.'� T6.�� �.��� 7'6. �.��� ����� �f1x� XP\�"6�� '� :2'� 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �� ��.� � ���- :-�1 ��$%&� X�'Y* �� * �� ��� ��� ��
�4)* ���xF�� � ��*8 � � �� ����.
��� �� '� ��� ��� �� '� �"-�'6* �����'� �� ����'- ���)"* �'��45� ��:�� ��1 �Y�'<* �.Q.�* '*� 78 �� �- �6�� s� 7 4-'� :#� 7� ��� ����'- cd�"�� �� e �� �.��45� �"-�'6* �����'� ���� ��� �'
�� :�� ��6. ��'6* '� �"F�!. /� k ��41'� ��1 �Y�'<* �$%&��* �;. �� ������0$ �1� �� ~ F �� �� ��8�'- �Y�'<* ��?`$ �'�.�� �$%&� /' 7�� *8
:�� �� `. �;. �* .Y* � ����'4���� �� �� �� �- :�� �� ��� �� ��'�� �N��� �� ��� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� �"-�'6* � �1 �� +, - �'
'<��� M`� +� K��- ��.��45��/'0$ �?e�* ���h� 7�� *8 �.�� �$%&� cd�"�� 78 �$%&��* '�� 1
2- Small group case study discussion 1- Kowino, Agak, Obiero- Owino & Ongunya Qi+* c'b* 7� 42 �� +�N - �g�-)@qLw �W�� �� X<. �� u@QLq:QqR (�� �� �'� �� ��� ��� �� �.��45� ��
|%*����.� ��)$� /'2%J� 7 *�8 �'f#� �����'� �'����.� d'� �=� �7'6. �.��- �Y�'<* ^'� �x�!.� ��!. �'.���i�� �- �P@* '� �- �Y�'<* i�� �.��45� �� ��1 K'T.� �)$� /'2%J� 7 *�8 |%@P�� � ��� ��� �� �� �"B� �� * ��t�� �.� � ^ Xb* �� � �� �� * w.��45� �� �� �"B� ��� ��� �� �� * � � �.��L�����'� |%* '� �- �Y�'<*
�� � � �.��45� >� �� �"B� ��� * K'(� �� ��� ��� �� ��1 K'T.� d'� �=� �f#� q ��!. |%* '� �- �Y�'<* �� ��� ��� �� ��1 K'T.� �x�!.�L+� �� �.� � ^ Xb* �� � �� �� * +� �� �� � �.��45� �� �� �"B� �� * �� *
� � �"B� �.��45� ��.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
211
)�*
�� �� �� � '� ���� �� �� ��'#"�� �� * I�<�� �� { 3 * :�'* '��� �6�'*�8 U�J ���'#"�� �� * U�J ���T� �� ����7 *�8VC�'� 7 *�8
�� � ���@:�� .�Y�'<* �� �� ��� �� �f4�� �� �� � '������ :���� �� �� �$%&��.�� �$%&� /'0$ c �� �� ��'#"�� ~ F U�J �� �k'& Xf1 �� �� � 7�� *8
�4"1�� � � ��� �� 78 �� �- �1 :�� � ��� E �6�'*�8 ��� �WN� �6�'*�8 ��� .Xf1 �� U�J �� ��� (.@:�� ��1 ���� 7'6. :
212121
TzTRTyTRTXTR
+�,).(� ���012� �*3' �4��'�5 6�7 *��3�8 9�:; <�� *
��� �- �.��- :F'��� �� X<"Y* ��h"* �� �k'& U =� �E WN� �6�'*�8 �'�.� � /'#"* ^ '� n'"�'* :�''()* ��'��� ��� ��� �� }�)* �� WN� ���
��� �� !"#� �� }�)* �� E ��� :F�� ���$ �$%&� � �1 �� +, - �'$ �$%&� �''()* ��'��� �"-�'6*:F�� ��� .c ()* �� }�)* �� x�. �� � ���
�=� "* >���* �� �$%&� /'2 3 * C����)�.��45� (:F�� ���$.
�8�3'�5�
�.�� �( �� :�� /�'`2 ��� �)*'� ��;. �&'1 7'"����� K� ��'� �"&� 7�� *8 �<=4* �"N� �.��� >���* �� �-@A"1� X�G�� �� 7��B� �B1 ���� �� *8 c'h
�4"1�� .�.�� X- ���)� �� *8 ����� �� ��1 :F'��� �'*8 �� �� � '� � -H* 7�� *8 ��<=4* ����@R\q MN'$ �� �- �.� � �#. @t 7'"����� t@7'*�'� >�� >%-
�.� � �"F'� .���� �'�. �� * ��'*8 �. (. .�i��� �� K'T� '� i�� �� �� � ��* �'
1- Pretest- Posttest, with Control group
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
212
�1 E'5".� �6�'*�8 /')N'=* ���� �. (. ^Te �`�'�* �� ./')N'=* �� �. (. ^Te :�� �6�'*�8������* ���$ X*'2 �'B, ���� :WN�V�4)* �=� ����)'#N8(E �VC.'���
�)*'�)2δ(� �V7 *�8 7� � )'"� �'B4* +�β−1(� V �� /'#� �� �.�x�* 1M2M�4- W6- �� 78 :�� X�'* I<�* �- .�)*'� �'�)* ����.� �� ��� /'#� ��
� �� 1 ^�Y<���'(. �?��d�* ���� ��'(. �* ���*'. ��� ^Te � 1� 1 :
δ
|| oMMd
−=
����� �� �. (. ^Te �`�'�* ���4)* �=� ��'� ��"�� ��6�'*�8 �' ����)a(7 *�8 7� �)β−1(��- �'�"&� �� .^Te �`�'�* '� ��;. �� * ��� ^Te /� k �� ��
X*'2 ����. (. ^Te �"F�� ���$ �� � �� * '�* ��)� M�'4* �� 1 .��'� ��� �� ��'#"��c�� �� - �?�� �� ��1 ��� �'@)@qAR 7'���'� ��*�� �� X<. �� u���'Te@QLq:@q\ (:�� .�4)* �=� ��3'e I�<�� �� ����)a('� �����\w/\�;. ��
�1 �"F��) :\w/\=a.( ��)� ���� �f4�� �� �� � '� �!�� ��J ��β� � �k'& ������$ � �����. 7��;4`e'k �'� (4� �� �� � ')�7 YN �1 ��;.@qAA ��4*'�- �(��� �@QAP(78 ���<* �P\/\�"(- '� )A\/\β≥V@(Z�56� 7'f*� '� �1 �"F�� �;. ��
� 1 �(0� �1'� �"1�� � � n')$� �- ��� k �� �/'#� .7'<<�* �!�� � � �� �f, - �� ���� ^Te �� �.� � �4($%2t\/\�`� �� ���� I`J /� k �� �� ��. �'
- c��)u7��!�� �*�� �� ��4- �'!.@QLq:@q\ QLw (�. (. ^Te �� �� c�')*PQn'2 (T* ��� � ���� �#. Rq �� �� � � �'�. ��� �� � ���� �#.
�* M���� '� ����� 7 *�8 7� � �� 7� �AR/\:F'� :�� .
�'*8 �. (. E'5".� � ;4* ���1 & �� �� ��� �� �'�. �� * ���1 ��'#"�� ��:�� U�1 �� �� ������ �. (. Xe��* :{ (T* ��q�- ��;. �&'1 7'"����� )�����
�.� � �=� "* K� ��'� >%- �� X$��e (�1 E'5".� �7'"����� +� �2�$ ��$ �� .�'!.8
1- Cohen
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
213
����� 7� � '"( :�'2� � ;4* �� ' c�')* �� :`Y. ��)N'=* �� * �'�"*��'� �;.�.�� 7��-��� 7�� *8�1 K��$� ' .����� 7��- c�')* ���� �#?"5* �' � � '
�1 E'5".� �F�'G� ���H�� �� 'B.8 �� �� �- ����)� * @QLA .( �f4�� �� �� � '��.� *�8 ��F�'G� ���H�� �� ���� '�� �� �F�'G� �. ���� � �6�'*�8 �'
�* ��H���� x�. �6�'*�8 X(2 �. 1��� �� �F�'G� � J�* �'G"&� ' �� ���'��� ��'� �� :`Y. ��"6�� :�x* ����� 7��- c�')* �'���� ' .���H�� ����
�.�� �F�'G���� �� 7�� *8�.�� �'>%- 7�� *8�� �- ��' E'5".� �F�'G� � J� ��1�� ��.� ��'(1 �F�'G� � J +� ��F�'G� ���2� c�� �� ��'#"�� '� �.�1 ���H�
�.� *�8 K � WN� �6�'*�8 ��� �� K � +� ��� � ��� �� ')��� ��� (+� E �6�'*�8 ��� �� �!�� K �)��� �� !"#�+, - �' (�.�1 ��H��.
=��>7� �*�5��# ��*�?��
+���' @��AB "3'�5:�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �T4� � ;4* �� �� 7�� *8 W��)� 7 *�8X�'Y*)DIT (�1 ��'#"�� ./'0$ c �� �4�*� �� :�� /'<�<�� Xk'e 7 *�8 ��
:�� �$%&�)�:��@qLQ u@qLq �7��!�� x!4�*'- uP\@\ .(DIT�4�x��4, �. *�8 ���� M-�* R�� �� :�'()* @qL\��� �� * ���"Y� � J ���)� �"F�� ���$ ��'#"�
��� �� �N'� � ��1 K'T.� ��x�� �� �� ��'#"�� '� �- ��'@\\\ '�k :�� ��� �� ��� �� �.� *�8 ��xt\��1 ���T4� 78 '� 7'B� � 6- ��e �N'� � �.�@w\
�* K'T.� 78 �� ��'#"�� '� ��� � 1)�:��@qqt7��!�� x!4�*'- �� X<. �� u�P\@\ .(�* �"�� & �.� *�8 �� 7 *�8 �� �� �� �.� 5� �� ''()* �� K��- � � 1
CD� ��� ��'� ��& '� �?� Xf1 �� �7'"��� �?k� 7'*�B$ �4-� �� * �� �N� � �� +� � :�(�@P^�(G� �� �- �N� � �* ���$ �� � �� * �N'Y* Xe ���� �� ����
/� k ��"n%k� "'�"'�Y��'�� �"�4- ��4� ���� .Xe��* �c� � � �� � ��* /%(��* �F�)* �� �$%&� /'0$ c �� W?"5*�44- .c� � ��4� �`�� �!. !, ����'4� '
�* ��.� *�8 �?�� � ��'#"�� �� * �$%&� c �� �N� � �� ��F �'!�'� ��)� ���� �.� � ���� ���$)�7��!�� �?F%f��@qAw�!�� :�� u7�@qqq .( �'()* � 7'�'� ��
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
214
^B* �� �� * �'B, ��'� �.� *�8���� ��� * ����`�� �� ��1 ��4���'(. ��4� .�� +� �E'5".� ���* 7'�� �� �.� *�8 cd�"�� � �. �'�4- .���* �;. { (T* �� ���t\
�1'� �F'- 7 *�8 �� �� !5�'� ���� :$ �<�$� .DIT /'#"* ��(. ��4, :�� ���*��)* �- �� �!.'6. �'B.8 ���P)�N k� ��(.(@�$%&� cd�"�� ��)* :��
�������$��FP)�N k� (:�� .��(.P'� �#k �� :�� �G&'1 �qw�k�� �Nx4* �� cd�"���* ��Y#� ��' :�(� 7�x�* ����'4� �4"Y �������$ ��F �=� �� �- � 1
�������$ ��F /';e%* �?e�*w'�R^�(G� �� �.� *�8 �;. �� �$%&� �1� �����* Cf)4* �� �$%&� �''()* 7 *���� �4-)�7��!�� :��@qqq �7��!�� x!4�*'- u
P\@\ .( :��)@qAR (�k�� ��(.Pc�')* w\�N k� ~%&� �=� ��)* �� �"6�� '� )�F�2 C� (�*�.�� .�. jN �� - �>'�� �d�Q)P\\R (h��4)* /���� ��(. �� ���P��
�* �$%&� /'0$ �1� �.'6. �4.��)�:�� �� ��4- �'!. x�.@qqL.(
���Z&'1 ��'��� ���)"* �'7�� �' �T4�DIT:�� ��1 K'T.� . :�� 7��!��)@qqq (���� 7'6. ���� �- �.�DIT:�� �4"`* ��� U�1 �� |%* :# �� :
��� �� ���H� x�'(�'��� �4� �:F�6�� �W?"5* �1� *8 �' �=��� ��N J �'>'�<* '���'.� � �T4� �' �=��� ��$%&� :���� /%&��* �� :��'Ye ��"&'41 �'
�)*'� �'"F� '��4Y�t^�(G� ��F�e E ?=* ������!. '� �=��� ���E'5".� �' �'��'�'� ��'�� .� ��-)@qLq � ��- �� X<. �� �@QLw(cd�"�� �� �- ��� 7'6. �
�� Xk'e /��(. ��'0F �*%- cd�"�� ��2�x".�DIT���� � � �=��� .:��)@qqt �7��!�� x!4�*'- �� X<. �� �P\@\(��'�'� Z&'1 �DIT �� ��'#"�� '� ��
7 *�8 �!"Y`(V�e�� ��.�� �.'Y( 7 *�8�'� A\/\���- ���x� :�� . Y� ��x4���� w)@qLA. �� �i�� ��- �� X<@QLw (.��� 7'6.iF �- �i7 *�8 �4?� K�DIT ����� �
:�� �.�� �.'Y( .�� ��'�'� M���3 �4*��L@/\'�AP/\*i� ��h"i� . Y� ��)@qAL�
2- Prosocial 4- Post Conventional
1- P- Score (Prinicipled Score) 3- Dellaportas, Cooper and Leung 5- Davison and Robins
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
215
�� ��- �� X<. ��@QLw (��(. ��'�'� �- ��� 7'6. �N k� ~%&� �'DIT I��J �� �� ��d'� ���'*�8�'� ��L\/\:�� .� ��-)@qLq (7 *�8 I��J ��V7 *�8�'� DIT �� �
��'�'� M��3AQ/\�.�� �.'Y( AP/\:F'� :�� .
Z&'17�� �' �T4�DIT* �� ��1 �6"4* ���'F 7'�� �� �- ��')N'= x�. �.�:�� ��1 ���x� .� ��-)@QLw (7 *�8 ��(. �=��� ����� I��J ��DIT 7 *�8
7 *�8 I��J �� 78 ��'�'� M��3 :��� 7 *�8 �- ��� 7'6. �y'�� �2�x".� �f#�V���T* 7 *�8AQ/\'� ����� 78 �.�� �.'Y( AP/\:�� .��'(-)@QLQ (M���3
��'*�8�'� �!"Y`(DIT Xe��* �� �� w�t�QP'� ����� M���� �� AL/\�RQ/\�LP/\LP/\���- ���x� :�� .7'�?�?�)@QLP (��� ��4, ��f?(2 �� �- ��� 7'6. x�.
�?h1)7'"����� 7����* �7����'- (�� ��'� ��DIT�4)* /'#� ����� � � ���� .��. �3'e ��� ��'�'� M��3 x�DIT '� ����� �.�� �.'Y( I��J �� AR/\:�� ��
:�� �`�'4* Z&'1 �- �*8 .7 *�8 �"`N�DIT �"F�� ���$ ��'�'<".� }�)* �� x�. :Y�. ^��F c'T* �� �� 'B.8 7'�� :k�F �- :��) :�� �� ��4- �'!. ��* ����
�7��!��@qqL ��4�N u@qqw.(
7� �*�5��# ��*�?��+��AB ����C1' &� D3��' =��>��EE�:X��)� �'��h"* �� ��44-�.�� �?�G�� :F�6�� �B`1 ��(� <� � �� �4��'`2 U�J ��7�� *8 .��8��� ����
�.�� �?�G�� ��.�� /'���4* �� ��'#"�� '� ��(� <� � �� * �� /'2%J� �7�� *8"�� 'B.8 �N � ���'�i���� ���'� �� ���5 �)N'=* �)��� �����7 *�8 ( ��� �1 �Y-
�1 �`�'�* �(� <� � M���� .�.�� � �T4� � ;4* �� �� ��)N'=* �� * 7�� *8C���'* 7 *�8�* ���� ��� /� k �� �- 7 �� ��.�6�� �'�1 ��'#"�� � 1 .����
�*'.�'- �� ��'#"�� '� ��?�G�� :F�6�� ��h"* ��'��� /'2%J� ��8����.�� �?�G�� � *8 :F�� ���$ X(2 |%* �`�'�* /��(. c�)* �X`$ �?�G�� c'� K� c� :� . ��.
F�(GB ���H� �8�* �F�'G� ���H�� �� C� �.��7�� *8 �� �� ���� ���7 *�8 X�'Y* W��)�)DIT (����
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
216
�.� *�8 �$%&� /'0$ �T4��.� *�8 �B`1 x�. ��1 ���� ' 7 *�8 �?�� �� 'C���'*�1 ���T4� 7 �� ��.�6�� �' . � �?�G�� :F�6�� �� � ��* /'2%J�
����� ���5"�� 'B.8 �?�G�� ��.�� /'���4* �� x�. �(� <�.
7����� �� �� �- ���� �� 7'(?)* ��� *8 ����� �� ��� ����� �<�'� '� 7� �N'2 /%�G��)�1�� ��'41�'- �e �� (�� �- �1� *8 �'��'- �� ��.� � ��1 E'5".�
�� �� /�*)@A:2'� (�.��- :-�1 ��1 X�f6� ./�* �� ��� �� CD�@P�Y?� w/@�"2'� *�4"F�� ���$ ��� U�1 �� C���� W?"5* �� �� }�)* ��.
�� �� �WN� �6�'*�8 ��� ���1 ���� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� �.��"����� ��;. �.'`* �� �� �'� :��� ���� X()N�� "�� �6�� �' ��'��� ���
��!6��� ��N� ��!6��� ��`�� � X*'1 ��$%&� �''()*I�(2 ��� CD� ��1���� �� �� �'����� { . �!4�F �''� ���� �� * �$%&� �' �4�6�� �� �'!.
/'<�<����.�� �.� "� �- M�'4* �$%&� �''()* ����� �$%&� }�')� �� �� 7�� *8�1 ��B� ��4- .
��� >'���� �E �6�'*�8 ��� �� �� !"#� :��� ���� X()N�� "�� �6�� �'����1 ��� �"-�'6* � �1 �� +, - �' .�.�� CD���6�'*�8 ��� 02 7�� *8
��� c�* I`J�.�� �(�� :F�6�� �'7�� *8@)� �%�� @qqt u@qAL (�1 �� ���t��� +� ��#. Q�.�1 ^�Y<� ��#. .
X�'Y* W��)� 7 *�8 C� ���� �� �� �� *8 7'��� K'(�� �� C�)DIT(�� +� ��1 ���� ��� �� � ���� �1� *8 ��� K'(�� �� C� .���� CD���� �'1 ��8 ��
�.�1 X�?�� �.����x*�.
&1���
�"F'��* �_��� �5� � �� ��� �'� 1 :WN�V�"F'� $ �� � ��* �'i�$%&� /'0
1- Student Teams-Achievement Divisions (STAD)
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
217
E V�"F'� �$%&� c �� �?e�* �� � ��* �' .�"F'� �*��� �� �;. �� WN� �5� �'�*�.�H� :* ���?k� c� � �� ��'� � ;4 ���� )��'��� ��� ��� �� �� �� ��
� ��$%&� �''()*i��� �� !"# +� K��- ��.��45� �"-�'6* �� �� +, - �'M`� '<����/'0$ �=� �.�� �$%&�7�� *8 �*�����(��f?(2 �.��7�� *8 �����
��� :�)$ * � ��C� 7 *�8&� /'0$ 7 *�8 �2 (T* �� ��'#"�� '� �$%7 *�8 �'K�. �"Y� ��'*8 ���xF�SPSS 7 *�8 X*'1 t7 *�8 �C.'��� X�?�� � �'- ��HT*
7 Y-'- X� 7 *�8)��'!?4� �(- �C���P\\t�?2 �(��� ����(k ��'�8@QAA(�1 �Y�'<* �.c�� ��w�G56* ���� � �$%&� /'0$ /��(. ��'*8 �'�'*�8��� :�)$ * �� �� � ��� �6C� 7 *�8 7 *�8 ��'". 7 *�8t�Y�'<* ����
��� �$%&� /'0$ /����h���� �� 'C� �� :`Y. 7 *�8:�� ��1 �-o 7 *�8 .���.�� �$%&� /'0$ ��(. ��)� � ;4* ��(. �� �7�� *8P7 *�8 DIT �- �1 ��'#"��
� � ��*8 7'�* �� 78 �-o n%`$.
I��H).("3'�5 J��18 t98�� � >�� =��K *� ��, ��L�� =����CB &���(' ���� &2 "��3'59�; &� MN�8 "3'�5 O; *� ���#"3'�5
���#�� >�� =��K ��C1'<�P8��'<�P8��'+��0B�t&H*�����5�EA'�*�����7 *�8 PP/Pq �.��45� C�7 *�8 RA/PL
ww/@R@Q/\PL wtw/\
���7 *�8 \t/PA��� ���
C�7 *�8 tR/QPtP/tV@AA/PVPP \t\/\
���7 *�8 ww/Pt ��� �� !"#� �'�"-�'6* �� �� +, -C�7 *�8 P@/Q@
RL/RVRA\/QVPw \\@/\
���� c�� �'@�* 7'6. C� /����h� ����� �� :`Y. 7 *�8 ���� 7 *�8 ���* �.��45��4)��� � �� '*� u:Y�. ������ �� !"#� ��� ��� �6�'*�8 �'
:�� ���'4)* +, - .�.�� /��(. �!.'�* �.��45� ��� ��C� �� 7�� *8 7 *�8�"F'� �'- �$%&� /'0$��� �� !"#� ��� ��� ��� � �� '*� �.��+, - �'
�.�� ��(. �!.'�* ���xF� �'1 7�� *8C� �� �$%&� /'0$ ��^�"Y 7 *�8 .�"f.
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
218
MN'���� �� !"#� �� �- :�� �� �� ���� ��� �� '� �Y�'<* �� +, - �'������.�� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� ��"6�� /�/'#� :�� �"1�� 7�� *8 ��"6�� �'
C� ��(. ����� �� :`Y. ��$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8:�� ���- �'T�� 7 *�8.
����� � ;4* �i. �� ��� �� �� /'#� �i. X3'#� �;i�� �$%&� /'0$ ��(���C� 7 *�8 7 *�8)��(.P7 *�8 DIT(+� C.'��� X�?�� 7 *�8 �� ����
c�� �� 78 ��'". �- �1 ��'#"��P:�� ��1 �_���.I��H)Q(9�; +��0B R�GS �� ���# &2 &���(' O8��*�� +��GB &L�18"3'�5O; �"3'�5
� >�� =��K O8��*�� TNE'=�*�UL' V3�L'����5 &H*� =�*�UL' <�P8��' F�EA'�*��
��� ��'��� 7��'
X-
qqR/qLt @Aq/q\@@ @Aw/qqAR
PLt LR
tqA/tAL LLQ/@P@
\\Q/t*\PP/\
*WX/WP<
���� c�� �'P�* 7'6. 0$ ��(. X3'#� �;. �� ��� �� �� �- �� /'�$%&� ��� ��C� 7 *�8���� � � /'#� 7 *�8 .�C.'��� X�?�� ��'". �� �� �'�
��� �� �� * � X$��e �� /'#���� /��(. X3'#� �;. �� '7 *�8VC�7 *�8�4)* ��$%&� /'0$:�� ��� .�Y�'<* 7 *�8 �� ��'#"�� '� �.'��4, �'HSD �- �
)c��Q('#� �- ��� 7'6.�.��45� ��� � �� /V��� �� !"#� �+, - �'�4)*:�� ��� :)\P@/\P<�Q@Q/AV=J=I(.�.��45� ��� �� /'#�V���� ���
�4)* �N :�� ��� � X�'$ �4,�:Y�. ��� .I��H)Z("3'�5 HSD9�; +��0B *� =��0B R�GS �� ���# &2 &���(' ���� ��3B "3'�5 [
O;� =��K "3'�5� >� ���#&���(' �� <�P8��' =��0B�<�P8��' �*��8�12� ��\��*���EA'
�.��45� V��� ��� qRqt/wV@\wt/Q@t\/\�.��45� V��� �� !"#� +, - �' P@Qt/AV\\wt/Q*\P@/\
��� ���V��� �� !"#� +, - �' PttQ/PV@wAA/QLwA/\*WX/WP<
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
219
�"F'� ���* 7'6. '��.� *�8 �$%&� /'0$ �� ��1 �'T�� /����h� �- ��'��� �� !"#� ��� 02C� �� �+, - �'��� �� :`Y. �7 *�8 �� �"6�� �7 *�8
�4)* /'#� 78 '� :�� �.��45� ��� ��� �.��45� ��� � �� x�. ����� �����.�� �$%&� /'0$ �� ��1 �'T�� ���h� �;. �� ���� *8 ��� �#. �� /'#� �7��
�4)* /'#� �� �N ����� � � ��� ���:Y�. ���.
����� :�)$ * � �� ��� �� �$%&� /'0$ /����h� �Y�'<* ����� � ;4* C� 7 *�8 �$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8)��(. X3'#�P��� �� 7 *�8VC�7 *�8 (7 *�8 ��
7 Y-'- X� +��"*��'���l@�`�� ���� ':*%2 �:#� ��1 ���H� ��1 � � �')K�. �"Y� ���xF�SPSS ( �1 ��'#"��)�X!�� �� ��4- �'!.@qwR ��(��- �(��� u@QLP:
qL .( c�� �� X�?�� �� ��'".t:�� ��1 �_��� .I��H)](� "3���� +�� "3'�5 J��18 [' ���[���8 ��*� +��0B &���(P9�; *� � "3'�5
O;>�� =��K "3'�5�
���#�^��,�
&NB* _�0E' ��)���89�; _"3'�5
�� �B`�� O;"3'�5(
&NB* _MNa' ��)���8O;"3'�5
�� �B`��9�;"3'�5(
&NB* _����' ��)9�; ���8 "3'�5
�� ����' O;"3'�5(
O; "3'�5 ��bE'
9�;"3'�5�EA'�*��
�.���F At@RPq@/@V@qL/\ �.��45� PA =n�`�� �(�'wt PtV
�.���F \A@wL@t/PV*\\L/\ ��� ��� PQ=n�`�� �(�'\QRV
�.���F \@\@R\w@/QV*\\P/\ ��� �� !"#� �'+, -PR=n�`�� �(�'\wwV
*W./WP<
���� c�� �'t�* 7'6. �� �- ��P��� �6�'*�8 )��� �� !"#�- �' +, ��� ���(��(. �P�.�� �$%&� /'0$ C� �� 7�� *8��� �� :`Y. �7 *�8�7 *�8
1- The wilcoxon matched- Pairs Signed Ranks
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
220
�4)* ��'*8 �;. �� �- �"1�� ���xF�:�� ��� .�`�� ��.��45� ��� �� * �� �#4* �')C� �� ��(. �'-��� �� :`Y. 7 *�87 *�8(�P�`�� ����� �4"Y :`b* �'
C� ��(. X3'#���� �� 7 *�8�4)* ��'*8 �;. �� ��$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8:Y�. ��� . ���"F'�7'6. x�. '��� �� !"#� ��� ��� �� 7� � �� * ��4� �� �+, - �'
�.�� �$%&� /'0$ ��(. �'<���:�� �.��45� �� '� �Y�'<* �� �7�� *8.
EV�"F'��$%&� c �� �?e�* �� � ��* �' :�?e�* ��$%&� �1� �')�� �� �f� 7 *�8 �� ��f?(2 >'���� �- :�� �$%&� /'0$DIT Xe��* '� I�'=* R�.'�
�* ��)� z�`?- �$%&� /'0$� 1 .c�� �� w�$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �.���F ��.�� 02 7�� *8i��� �� +� � �6�'*�8 �'�i��� :�)$ * � �� �� 7 *�8C�-o 7 *�8i:�� ��1 �.
I��H)X(98�� � >�� =��K &�c�' �8���� "3'�5 O; M�A 3' *� ���# &2 3K� "��3'5
���#����# dG� ���#*� 3P10#e 3� ���8��Ef2
� >�� =��K +c��' � >�� =��K +c��' =��K +c��'� >�� ^��,��
�0��3B *�'5 QtwQtwQtw
�.���F @@RR@@LAR@qQ�k�� Q/tR/Rq@/PRA/Qt/RwA/Q\t/P@q/RLL/@\
���� ����� c�� �'w���� '� 78 /'#� c�� �'P�- :�� 78 �� �-'e �.� *�8��� 02 �'��� �� �$%&� c �� �?e�* �;. �� 'C� 7 *�8 �7 *�8:�)3�.� *�8 �� ��"6�� �k�� �N �.��� ��'#"* :�)$ * � � �� ���� �� � �'
���C� 7 *�8 �$%&� /'0$ K�'B, �?e�* �� ��$%&� cd�"�� �;. �� 7 *�8�4"Y z�`?- .c�� ��R�.� *�8 �k�� �.���F �c �� �?e�* �;. �� �- ��'C� �� �$%&�7 *�8 ��� �� :`Y. �7 *�8�"1�� cx. '� � )k �/'0$ �?e�* '� �.�
:�� ��1 �-o �:�� ��.'* :�'� 'B.8 �$%&�.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
221
I��H)g(�8�3'�5 ��*� � �8���� O; *� � >�� I3GB &�c�' �h8 �� &� ���# &2 ��_"3'�5 9�; &� MN�8&1,�� I�?8 �� �3A� _"3'�5�8�
�8�3'�5 &� ��� � >�� I`�12�
i �b85 ��8�' M��M2�
�8�3'�5 &� ��� � >�� I`�12� &�c�' e� �b85
&1�� 9��?� M2�
�8�3'�5 &� � � >�� I`�12�&�c�' �� �b85 &1�� 9��?�
M2�
�8�3'�5 &� ��� � >�� I`�12� &�c�' e� �b85M2� &1�� 9��
�8�3'�5 &� ��� � >�� I`�12�
&�c�' �� �b85 &1�� 9��
�M2 ���#�
�8���� ��*��8���� ��*� �8������*��8������*� �8������*� ��� ��� @wP@/RwLtQ/Q\@Qt/tVVV��� �� !"#��'+, -
@R wQ/R@qR/Qt@At/QVVV
�.��45� @R@t/wLtPA/@tVVLPw@wL/Q
���� c�� �'R� ��"6�� �k�� �- :�� 78 �� �-'e �.� *�8 ���� � 02 �'��� �� !"#� ��� ��� �?e�* � '� +� ��$%&� /'0$ �;. �� �+, - �'
�"1�� � )k�.� .�.�� �� ��"6�� �k�� �!�� ��J �� �;. �� ��.��45� ��� 02 7�� *8�"1�� cx. �?e�* � '� +� ��$%&� /'0$ �?e�*�.� .����� �"6�� �')c��@@(
e���� ��� ��� �� �- :�� 78 �� �-'Q�.�� �� �#. �?e�* �� 7�� *8Q/'0$ �?e�* �� �$%&�t�t�?e�* �� �#. t��w@�?e�* �� �#. Q��w�"1�� � )k �.� .��
��"-�'6* �� �� !"#� ���Q�.�� �� �#. �?e�* �� 7�� *8Q��t�R�?e�* �� �#. t��w� �#. +� �?e�* �Q��w:�� �"F'� '<��� .
I��H)j(�8�3'�5 �8���� ���# �� e�� �� &�c�' �� �b85 � >�� I`�12� &� _�Z&�]�...M2� ���� M�4�;
�8�3'�5 I`�12� &� ��� &�c�' �� �b85 � >��Z&�]
M2� ���� M�4�;
�8�3'�5 I`�12� &� ���c�' �� �b85 � >�� &�]&�
XM2� ���� M�4�;
�8�3'�5 I`�12� &� ��� &�c�' �� �b85 � >��Z&�X
M2� ���� M�4�; ���#�
�.���F �k�� �.���F �k�� �.���F �k�� ��� ��� Q@Qtt/@L@t/t
��� �� !"#�+, - �'Qw/@@RPQ@A/Q�.��45� QL/@\@w/QV
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
222
�� /'#� ����� � ;4* �� �� �$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �� /����h� �;. �� ��� �� ���C� �� 7 *�8 c�� �� 78 ��'". �- ��1 ��'#"�� �'- �HT* 7 *�8 �� �7 *�8A
:�� ��1 �_���.I��H)l(18[# &2 ��� *�UL' "3'�5 &L�[B �h8 �� ���[*� � >�� =��K &�c�' *� ���C
O;9�; &� MN�8 "3'�5"3'�5
*��(' *�����5 &H �EA' m\2 *��)&�7 ��(7 ���� �'- �HT* )a(RAA/@LA\Pt/\��'(. :��� :`Y. LtQ/P\A\\A/\r& �� r& �'`��� tAq/@\@\\@/\
�.� *�8 ���)�'LL
���� c�� �'A�* 7'6. �?e�* �� ���h� 7�x�* �;. �� ��� �� �� �- ����� �� �$%&� /'0$ �� 7 *�8C��4)* ��'*8 �;. �� �- ���� � � /'#� 7 *�8 ���
:�� .���� ��'<��� �� �6�'*�8 X(2 7� � �� * �� �-'e '��$%&� c �� �?e�* �.� *�8��� 02 �'��� �� !"#� ��� ��� �'�* +, - �'�1'�.
��� ����� �N'("e� ^B� ��)� � ;4* ��". �� �$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8C� ��' 7 *�8�1 ��'#"�� C.'��� - X�?�� �� .�'��h"* �� �!"Y`( M��3 ��"�� � ;4* �� ��
�1 �`�'�* �?k�)c��q(.I��H)n(+��AB ����C1' � &1���� ��C1' <�� "32��; �P1�N� o���� ��EE�
���C1' 9�; "3'�5
� >�� =��K O; "3'�5
� >�� =��K �bN,3���3(B <2
4�; M�����GB
�$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8 ��� V*PqA/\\@w/\\Q@/\@\P/\�$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8 C� VV\@P/\\\w/\@@A/\
�B`1 VVV@\t/\\PR/\V�(� <� � VVVV@@A/\V
�?�G�� :F�6�� VVVVV
jj=nW./WP<=*a
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
223
���� c�� �'q�� ��h"* �� �- :�� 78 �� �-'e ��� �� �"Y)/'0$C� �� �$%&�7 *�8 (X��)� �'��h"* ��44-)�?�G�� :F�6�� ��(� <� � ��B`1 (
�4)* �=���X�?�� �� ����'4� �����. � � ������� �Y�'<* ���� �- ��' �;. �� 'C� �� �$%&� /'0$�* K'T.� 7 *�8 �'��h"* ��'*8 c�"4- �� ��'�. �� 1 '� ~ F
:Y�. C.'��� - X�?�� �� ��'#"�� .��� �� �f4�� �� �� �'� ��!�� � � ��7 *�8C� �4)* �!"Y`( ��$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8���� � � ���� )\@/\P< �PqA/\=r(�Y�'<* �
���C� �;. �� ' /'0$ 7 *�8 ��� ��'*8 c�"4- Kx?"Y* ��$%&� /'0$ 7 *�8?�� �� �� ��'#"�� '� �$%&�:�� C.'��� - X� .����7 N 7 *�8 �� � ��* �'@����
C.'��� ������ �3�#* ����� c�� �� '@Q:�� ��1 �_��� .I��H).W(O8��*�� ������ &���0' �2*�� ���� "3S "3'�5 �
����8��"3S �*�'5����5 &H*�.����5 &H*�Q�EA' m\2 �*���.� *�8 �$%&� c �� �?e�*� '��� �7 *�8PwQ/\PLtLLL/\�.� *�8 �$%&� c �� �?e�*C� �� '7 *�8PRR/\PLtLRL/\
���� >'���� �f4�� �� �� � '� c�� �'@\�4)* �=� ��$%&� /'0$ �����.� *�8 �� �"6�� '\w/\���� �:�� �� C.'��� �'=& ������ �3�#* ���� �'
� � ��� �� ��� �� �����`. c�.� .�.� *�8 �$%&� /'0$ C.'��� - X�?�� 7 *�8 '��� ��C� 7 *�8 c�� �� ���� �� � 7 *�8@@:�� ��1 ���� 7'6. .I��H)..(9�; *� � >�� I3GB &�c�' �h8 �� ���# &2 &���(' O8��*��3� +��GB � "3'�5
O;"3'�5 O8��*�� TNE' =�*�UL' V3�L'����5 &H*��'=�*�UL' <�P8� F�EA'�*��
��1 ���G� c�* \AA/tQQRP/@\\q/w\\Q/\Intercept tAA/@@@tAA/@@PPq/tP\\/\
C� �� �$%&� c �� �?e�*7 *�8AtL/@@AtL/@Lq/R\@@/\��� \RP/QPwQ@/@RPL/w\\w/\'=& AR/@qLQPLP/\X- @QPq LL
1- Leven
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
224
�����' c�� @@�* 7'6. C� �� �$%&� /'0$ 7 ����� �- �� �� 7 *�8����4)* 7 *�8 :�� ���)\@@/\P< �Lq/R=F(.���� :�� 78 �� �-'e x�. c�� �'
C� �� �$%&� /'0$ �� ��� �� /'#� �-��� /���� �He �� C� �7 *�8 7 *�8�4)*�4)* ��� :�� ����.� *�8 �� X*'2 ���� ������� � � ' .�"F'� �� �� �-'e '
�.� *�8 �$%&� /'0$ �� ��1 �'T�� /����h� �- :�� 78 �� �1'. ������ �� * �'��� ����� �� ��1 �_��� �6�'*�8 X(2 :�� �� `. 78 �� "�* '� ��'418 7 *�8
��� �6�'*�8 �')��� �� !"#� ��� ���+, - �' (������4)* ���� �� '<�����.�� �$%&� /'0$ :�� �"1�� 7�� *8 .
� dG�&L�18 ���#
��� 7'6. ��� �� �� Xk'e ��'".:
WN� :�� � �� ��'#"��"�$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� ""��� �� !"#��' �$%&� �''()* ��'��� �"-�'6* �� �� +, - "'� �Y�'<* ��"��'��� �.��45� ��
*�$%&� /'2 3 "�.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �� �=� "* K� ��'� �"&� 7�� *8����� �"`b* �* 7'.8 �$%&� /'0$ �'<��� �1� M`� ����� 1 .
E:C� �� �$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �;. �� ��� �� �'02� �� ��� �� :`Y. 7 *�8�4)* /'#� �7 *�88 �� ��"6�� �k�� ���� � � ��'*8 ����.� *���� 02 �' �'
�6�'*�8)�� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� !"#� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ������+, - �'(�"1�� � )k �?e�* � '� +� ��$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �;. �� ��.�)Qw
��� ��� ��� �� �k��w/QA��� �� !"#� ��� �� �k�� +, - �' (�� X�'<* ��J�.� *�8 �� ��"6�� �k�� ��.��45� �� ��� 02 �')R/PA�k�� (�� �
�"1�� cx. �?e�* � '� +� ��$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �;.s� �f.8 c'e �.� �� K��-'02���"1��. :F�Y� �$%&� cd�"�� �;. �� ��6�'*�8 ��� � �.�.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
225
�:�������� �� !"#� �� � /'0$ �1� �� +, - �'�.�� �$%& �7�� *8 �� �"e����� �� 78 �� ��� :�� �"6�� ^ �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� ��
'<�����.�� �$%&� /'0$ �=� �* �T4* 7�� *8� 1.
�"F'� WN� �5� c� :(Y$ �� �- ���� �� �'����� �� ��� ��� �� �.�� �$%&� cd�"�� '<���� �Y�'<* �� 7�� *8�* � ��* �.��45� �� '�.'`* '� �� 1
��� ��'". ��� ��;.:�� �4'( � �6�� �' .��* �� �- �. !.'(��� z�`?- /%� �:1H� �;. �� �6�� �')@qLw (��� ��� �- �.��� 7'6.
�4)* :F�6�� �� ��$%&� /'2 3 * ��'����* �T4* �$%&� cd�"�� �� ���� 1 .�`N - 7��!�� )@qLL (�"F'� x�.���- �_��� ��'�* 7'6. �- �.��.�� :-�1 �� �� 7�� *8
�� ���'<��� �� 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� ���*�� .x4�!�)@qA\ (�- ��� 7'6. x�.�* �$%&� cd�"�� �1� M`� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ���� 1 . �?F%f��
7��!��)@qAw (F �� C� X�?����ww��� '� ���T� )�(�.���T� (:���� �� e �����- �_��� ��� 1 ��$%&��* 7'6. �- �.� ��$%&� �''()* ��'��� ��� ��� ���* �$%&� cd�"�� �1� ���*'T.� .7��!�� �?F%f�� �?�� �� ��1 ��* /')N'=*
)@qAw (�� �4��'`2 :7 "�����@)@qLq( � :�?F ����'� P)@qLR(�.d � �Q)@qA\(�7 "���t)@qLq(��d'� �w)@qLA(7 ��N'.� �R)@qA@(�#�1 �L)@qLA(�� #.' �A
)@qA\(�?��� �q)@qAw( � - �@\)@qA@(�N�'F �@@)@qA\(X� 4* �@P)@qLq( �4?� - ����'�@Q )@qLq(+* ��x4-@t )@qA\(C-'� �@w)@qLA(�4�� - �@R)@qA\( � ��.�@L
2- Fleetwood & Parish 4- Preston 6- Donaldson 8- Hanford 10- Kenvin 12- Manville 14- Mc Kenzie 16- Codding
1- Bridston 3- Boland 5- Gallagher 7- Shafer 9- Riley 11- Farrelly 13- Copland & Parish 15- Sachs 17- St. Denis
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
226
)@qA\(|�%- �w)@qLA(��� -R)@qLw(s� .'� �L)@qLw( - �� �A)@qLw(�c'!��q
)@qLt(���� �@\)@qLt(C�'� �@@)@qLL (�-�@P)@qLt(x*��8 �@Q)@qAP(|�%- �)@qLq(7 "-�� ���N �@t)@qA@.(
�"F'� 7��!�� +� �?�� �� �~ F /'<�<�� ��'". '� ��'6* ��')@qLP(���� �)@qLt(C�� �)@qLR(`�N � *�)@qLw('* � :�� �)@qAR(x"� -�� �)@qA\ �@qAw(�
x`�� x"� -��)@qAQ(7��!�� x!4�*'- �)P\@\(�4�N �)P\\Q uP\\R(�.��"Y*�8 �)@qqQ(7��!�� W?� �)@qqQ(W�=N �)@qqq �P\\\(:�� ��1 �_��� �.7� � �� * X�N�
�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �� �$%&� �''()* ��'��� ���8��'�� 'B.8 �� �- :�� �� 7�� *�*�N'Y* Xe ��:k�F �44- ��(� �� �$%&� �'cd�"�� |�� EH� �' �'
�N'2 �$%&��* �_��� 7d'Y( � � �� �- ����* ���$ 'B.8 �'�"&� �� �� � 1��.
�"F'� WN� �5� K� :(Y$ �� �- ��� �� �'�������� �� !"#� �� �' ��.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �1� �� �"-�'6* � �1 �� �, �� '� �Y�'<* �� 7�� *8
�* � ��* �.��45���� ��'". ��� ��;. �.'`* '� x�. �� 1 �6�� �':�� �4'( :��� �� !"#� ��y'�� �"&'41 �1� ���;. �� �� �'� �� �� +, - �'x� ��"-�'6*�� - :�� �?*')� c')F �'�����'� �� 78 c%& �� ��.����'� ��'
�* :�� ����� * ^B* ��-�� ��.��45� �� '� �Y�'<* �� 78 :�<F * X�N� ��'��<. �"&'41 }�')� Xk� �� �� �� �1� �� ��H���� �'�4���F �� �- :�� ����
�� �$%&� �1� �"&'41�* �'(1�.� .
* �����'� ��;. E ,�', �� �� �'��"F'� x�. �"-�'6 ��� �� �5� �� �'�* ��� �� 1 : �%�� �;. ��)@qq\ �@qq@ �@qqt �@qqR(7��!�� 7 Y.'� �)P\\\�
P\\L(7 Y.'� 7 Y.'� �)P\\q('02� ����� ^�� E ,�', �� '�' :F�6����� J
2- Coder 4- Piwko 6- Troth 8- Walker 10- Laisure and Dacton
1- Clark 3- Panowitsch 5- Siegal 7- Geis 9- Adams
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
227
�* �'- |�"6*�� �� '� �44-�� �4��� |�"6* �' �T�'". c'`.�� �- �4"Yi�1� & �#.i2� ��'� 7'i'0�� �HN :�� ��� i�� �� ��'�"�� ����' ��� |�"6*
�4"Y ���� &�� ��"6�� �x�!.� K'TY.� �� .��!�� � � �� 7��!�� 7 Y.'� �;. �� )P\\L(��'� x"� ��� �)P\\Q uP\\w( �� �)P\\t(7��!�� 4� � �)P\@@(�
�� �� � ��"&'41 �$%&� cd�"�� ��d'� U =� �� ��'#"�� Kx?"Y* �/'�$%&� �����'��'�����'���� �� �� 7� � �'� �7'.8 �'��;. 7��8 E'Ye �� 7��!�� �'5* �' WN'
�����'� r���1 �� �- �:�� ��� �'02� ��'� �<. ��� �� ��� 7��- ��'� X*'2 �( ��"-�'6*�* 7'6. � & �� ��"6�� �1� ~ F �'�� .��;. �.'`* ��*
�* 7'6. �"-�'6* �����'� �� e �� 7��!6�� K (2 �� �� �'���� �� �- ���� ��� e :�� ��1 �"F��H� �� &)4- �'!. �:4Y4� �� ��P\\Q ��, . u@qAL 7 Y.'� u
�7 Y.'� P\\q.(
������* 7'6. ��*8 X(2 �� �'��� �- �� �� * �� ��'�� �'����� ��'#"�� ��� �� !"#� �� �� ��$%&� /'0$ �1� �� �"-�'6* �����'� � �1 �� +, - �'
��� ��� �� � �Y�'<* � G5�)>%- X- (�� !"#� ��� �� +, - �' /'<�<�� �&�� �� �:�� ��*'�. X(2)�7 Y.'� 7 Y.'�P\\q(������ �����'�
� �� �� �:�� ��1 �Y�'<* �"�'$� '� ���F �����'� '� �$%&� cd�"�� �� �"-�'6*��� �� ��'".��� �� �� �'� ���'� �� �� +��x. n'"`Y. �' W?� �?(� �� ���
7��!��)@qqA (�* ��*� 1 .�Y�'<* s� �� �H* ��� �� �"`N� � ����'- �� ����� �� !"#� ��� ��� �� ��� �HB)* �:�� ��*'�. X(2 �� +, - �'
����� �� �- :�� ��'<�<�� ��)* �� �f� ~ F�������� �� ��� �1� �� +, - �'��i:�� �"&���� �$%&� cd�" .�� 7'6. 'B.8 �� �f1x� 7'� T6.�� :-�1 �- �.�
������ ��� * �'�� �+, - �'�4)* � J 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �� ��������� '<��� M`� �"1�H���* 'B.8 �$%&� /'0$ � 1.
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
228
�"F'� �� �!�� �5� ��� �� �')E �5� (�$%&� /'0$ �?e�* �� �-�.���* � ��* 7�� *8�* 7'�� � 1 �4-�$%&� cd�"�� �� ��1 �'T�� /����h� �( �- �.�� �6�'*�8 ��� � 7�� *8)��� �� !"#� ��� ���+, - �' ( :`b*
��� ��;. �.'`* '� x�. �:�� �� � �� )k)�'����'<��� ��'��� z�`?- �y'�� �'��$%&� cd�"�� (��� ��'". :�� 7� 5( �?`$ �' :`?- /%� z�)@qLw(�7��!�� �`N -)@qLL (�.�� :-�1 ��� �� �- ������h� �( �- �.��� 7'6. �� 7�� *8
:�� �� � �?*'f� :`b* ��1 �'T�� 'B.8 �$%&� cd�"�� �� ���� ��� .�� �)@qLR(x"� -�� �)@qA\(7��!�� �?F%f�� �)@qAw(� |d �)@qLA ('* � :�� )@qAR (F'� x�.�"���- �_��� ��� �� ��'". ��'6* ��'�.� .7� � �� )k :`b* X�N�
�� �1'. /����h� �� �- :�� �� �7�� *8 �.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �� ��1 �'T�� /����h��� �:Y�. ^�'#* �����'��(. X<"4* ^?)* �?���(. �;F'e �� �f"* � 1 �f?� ��1'�
�)$� �"&'41 }�')� �� �1'./'0$ ��.'*�'� ��'�� �)$� ���h� �$%&� �'�.� *�8 �$%&� cd�"�� � !N�:�'.
�"F'� �� �65� ��� �� �')� �5� (�* 7'6. �- �������� �� !"#� �� ����.�� �$%&� cd�"�� �1� �� +, - �' �� �7�� *8����� ^ ��� ��� ��
� ��;. �.'`* '� �:�� �"6�� ��)��1� ��f��V���;. /'�$%&� �� �"&'41 �"-�'6* �����'� (:�� �4'( :��1� ��f�� ��;. E ,�', �� �� �'�V��"&'41
)��y'�� /��;. �� ^B?*@qQP (}�')� Xk�)���N�')� (7d'Y( '� ����� X*')� ��"&'41�<. :�� �$%&� �1� ��'�� �'�'-�'� �� ����� .� �� �'� !"#� �� �� �f4�� ���� ��+��x. ���� X*')� �>%- X- ��� ��� '� �Y�'<* �� �+, - �' ���.d J'02� �� ������ ��� ^ �* � � �e ��"(- �� ^?)* �'� (4� ��8
�* f(*�'���� I`J ���� �y'�� �')@qQP(z�`?- �)@qAR (��* ���;. I�'=* )@qQt (4- ��'��� � ��'(. X�'<"* ������� �� Xk'e /�i '� ����� X*')i�7d'Y(
}�')��<. �4���F ���d'� �=� �$%&� cd�"�� �_��� �� �1'. �"&'41 '418 ����
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
229
���!�� �'��;. '� 7�1����� ��4���F �� ��� �� ���� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� ��"6�� /��* '<��� �$%&� cd�"�� �=���'� .
'���N� �5Y. :F'��� ����N'<* :@t/\w/@Qq@ �5Y. :F'��� ���'��N'<* ��'B. :P\/\q/@Qq@ �N'<* ���H� ���'�:PA/\@/@QqP
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
230
T��E' References !?4� u��'g�� ��(- u%f�. �C��� ��*�� ��')P\\w.(+��GB���� &'�8�� �� �2�E48��* ��
q�.�;.q�.q���?2 �T��& �(��� �c� �', �7��� /��'6".� �7��B� ���(k �?2 ��'�8@QAA.
�BN� ���'Te >'`2 �7'���'� u��� ��*��)@QLq .()�*�*�1* r3�� *� F�(GB �� ��7��B�K � �', ��'�8 /��'6".�.
�� �X!�� �.�)@qwR .(�*�1* r3�� ���� ��1'�*�;��s *�'5 ��'!6.�� �7��B� ��(��- W� � �(��� �K� �', ���'`J'`J �*%2@QLP.
�?2 �W�� �`-�)@QAR .(�,*��; �2�E48��*��'�8 /��'6".� �7��B� .
�'.�B* ���8�B1)@QAt.("�3H38 �,* �2�E48��* :�S3GB ��#����c� �', �^?2 �6. �7��B� .
�� ���'g�� �7 YN �1.)@qAA .(�*�1* r3�� *� �*�'5 I`�12� �K� �?� :��'*8 �'`4"��.�(����4*'�- '3��?2 .��'`J'`J �*%2 �e� �'!6.�� �'B� /��'6".� �7��B� .7'"Y�'� �K�'B, �',
@QAP.
%�"� ��4`$%2)@QLR .(�"-�'6* �����'� �'!6.�� C���� .9�:;�1���B �����'(1 �^T4� c'� @PZk �:LRVwq.
��'. ����'$)@QLL .( �� �C#. /x2 �7'�"*� �� M?<� �;. �� �$%&� /'0$ �1� Xe��* �Y�'<*��'G"$� �'!�'� �?�G�� ��f?(2V�� � �B1 �=� "* K� c� c'� 7�� *8 �.�� �2'("�� �
"���;�1���B �2�E48��* �,*� �2�E,*�� &'�8 ��'!6.���� � 7��(, ��B1 .
���� ��(�'-)@QLq .( &���('��itB)�* ���CB �� 9(8 ��0�� � ���# dG� _�8��Ef2 O�*�B ��98�� )�P8u� � �3� v�A' &� MN�8 "��3'5����E�* I�� I�2 �E�� q*� �,�*� ������x�
���� �� *8 /��� �:���� ^�?)� ��f6�� ��6�� U�J.
�� �� ��- �)@QLw.(98�� � >�� "��H� �,* �2*��&2*�' �8�'��2 3H �� "5 &\��* � "��3'5����� �� *8 /��� �:���� ^�?)� ��f6�� �6�� U�J ���x�.
��� �� ��-)@QAQ.(�>�� �2�E48��*�K� �', ���8 �6. �7��B� .
��6(� ���'(-)@QLQ .( /'0$ �1� Xe��* �� �=��� ����� U =� �'B* �'!�'� �� ��$%&��.�� 7'�* �� /%�G����'� 7�� *87'� T6.�� 7'"����� K� ���'(4�� K � �����"�� ^T4� �'
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
231
�� � ^?)* :���� x-��*."��� ��b, ��P48�� �1���B �2�E48��* �,*� �2�E,*�� &'�8 "���;��3�.
W=N �Ye ���'�8)@QA\ .( �,�*� _� >�� �,*�8�3H � �8�3H38 *� �E�� ���', �7'.� � �?* 7'*�'�c�.
��B, +�. ��4Y�*)@QLA .(�������;. �� �$%&� �'���'46.�� W?"5* �' �1���B r3�� &��48 �7��B� �'!6.��.
��� ��*�x& � )Y* �K�<* ��'#k u� G4*��� ��62�*)@QAq .( ���������� �� *8 �*'.�� ����� �� �#Y?F�.�� �$%&� /'0$ �1� �� �6�� {'("�� �� �� 7'-� - �� ^T4� ��'� 7�� *8
��� � �B1 ����"��w�3� � ��0B &'�E�� �Zk �c� ��'(1 �c� c'� :@PLV@\P.
�?4"�� ���'g�� ���"�� � � �X� �:��)@qL@ .(M���B F\E' :&0�� ��P8 �� M���B r3b0' +��GB����GB�'�F �(��� �c� �', ��!4�F �(?2 /��'6".� ��(��- �@QAq.
�?2���e � * )@QLA.(�*�1* 9�:; *� �*�'5 D�NE12��K�'B, �', �'��'� �6. �7��B� .
Armstrong, M. (1993). Ethics and Professionalism in Accounting Education: A Sample Course, Journal of Accounting Education, Vol. 11, pp. 79-92.
Aspin, D., (2000). A Clarification of Some Key Terms in Values Discussion, in M. Leicester, C. Modgil, and S. Modgil, (eds). Moral Education and Pluralism, Falmers press.
Berkowitz, M.W., (1985). Peer Conflict and Psychological Growth: New Directions for Child Development, San Francisco: Jossey- Bass.
Berkowitz, M.W., (1982). The Role of Discussion in Moral Education, Paper Presented at the International Symposium on Moral Education, Friburg,Switzerland, September, 1982.
Berkowitz, M.W., (1980). The Role of Transaction Discussion in Moral Development: The History of a Six-year Program of Research-part II., Moral Education Forum. Vol. 5, pp. 15-27.
Berkowitz, M.W. and Bier, M.C., (2003). Character Education Literature Review, Available at web: www.character.org.
Berkowitz, M.W. and Bier, M.C., (2005). What Works in Character Education: A Research Driven Gide for Educators, Character Education
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
232
Partnership. University f Missouri-st. Louis, Washington, DC. Available at Web: www.character.org.
Berkowitz, M.W., and Gibbs, J., (1983). Measuring the Developmental Features of Moral Discussion, Merrill- Palmer Quarterly, Vol. 24, P. 399-410.
Berkowitz, M.W., Gibbs, J., and Brughton, J., (1980). The Relation of Moral Judgment Stage Disparity to Developmental Effects of Peer Dialogues, Merrill- Palmer Quarterly, Vol. 26, pp. 341-357.
Blatt, M., (1969). Studies on the Effects of Cassroom Discussion Upon Children’s Moral Development, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation.
Blatt, M.M., and Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Effects of Classroom Moral Discussion Upon Children’s Level of Moral Judgment, Journal of Moral Education, Vol.4, No. 2, pp. 129-161.
Boyd, D. (1976). Education toward Principled Moral Judgment: An Analysis of an Experimental Course in Undergraduate Moral Education Employing Laurence Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, Harvard University.
Broughton, J., (1978). The Cognitive-developmental Approach of Morality: A Reply to Kurtines and Greif, Journal of Moral Education, Vol 7, No. 2, P. 81-96.
Cazden, C.B., (1988). Classroom Discourse, Portsmouth. NH: Heinemann.
Colby, A., and Kohlberg, L., (1987). The Measurement of Moral Judgment, Vol 1: Theoretical Foundations and Research Validation, New York, Cambridge University Press.
Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Fenton, E., Speicher- Dubin, B., and Lieberman, M., (1977). Secondary School Moral Discussion Programes Led Social Studies Teacher, Journal of Moral Education, Vol, 6. No. 2, pp. 90-111.
Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Biggs, J., and Lieberman, M., (1983). ALongitudinal Study of Moral Judgment, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 48 (Serial No. 200).
Cummings, R., Maddux, C.D., Cladianos, A., and Richmond, A., (2010). Moral Reasoning of Education Students: The Effects of Direct Instruction in Moral Development Theory and Participation in Moral
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
233
Dilemma Discussion, Teacher College Record, Vol. 112, No. 3, pp. 621-644.
Dellaportas, S., Cooper, B,J., and Leung, P., (2006). Measuring Moral Judgment and the Implications of Cooperative and Rule-based Learning, Accounling and Finance, Vol. 46, p.1-18.
Dillon, J. T., (1994). Classroom Discussion, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encychopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.
Duric, L., (1988), Essentials of Educational Psychology, UNESCO.
Dembo, M.M., (1994). Applying Educational Psychology, Longman.
Faustt, J.L., and Paulson, D.R., (1998). Active Learning in the College Classroom, Journal of Excellence in College Teaching, Vol. 9, No. 2, p. 3-24.
Festinger, L.A., (1957). Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, Row, Peterson and Company.
Galbraith, R.E., and Jones, T.M., (1976). Moral Reasoning: A Teaching Handbook for Adopting Kohlberg to the Classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Green haven Press.
Gall, M.D., And Artero- Boname, M.T., (1994). Questioning Dtrategies, In T. Husen and T.M. Post Lethwaite (eds). The International Rncyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.
Gibbs, J., (1995). The Cognitive Developmental Perspective, In W.M. Kurtines, and J. L. Gewirtz (Eds). Moral Development: An Introduction (pp. 27-48). Boston; Allyn and Bacon.
Gibbs. J.C., Basinger, K.S., and Fuller, R., (1992). Moral Maturity: Measuring the Development of Sociomoral Reflections, Hillsdale, NJ, Erlbaum.
Gibbs, J., Schnell, S., Berkowitz, M., and Goldestein, D. (1983, April), Relations between Formal Operations and Logical Conflict Resolution, Paper Presented at the Biennial Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Detroit.
Gilligan, G., (1982). In A Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
234
Graham, J., Haidt, J., and Rimm- Kaufman, S.E., (2008). Ideology and Intuition in Moral Education, European Journal of Developmental Science, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 269-268.
Kagan, S., (1989). Cooperative Learning Resources for Teachers, San Juan Capistrano, CA: Resources for Teachers, Available at web.
Kohlberg, L., (1984). Essays on Moral Fevelopment, Vol. 2, The Psychology of Moral Development, New York: Harper and Row.
Kohlberg, L., (1968). Moral Development, In D.L., Sills (ed), International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, Vol. 10, New York: Macmillan Company and the Free Press, pp. 483- 494.
Kohlberg, L., (1969). Stage and Sequence: The Cognitive Developmental Approach to Socialization, in D. Goslin (ed). Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research, Chicago, IL: Rand McNally, pp. 347-480.
Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Cognitive Developmental Approach: New Developments and a Response to Criticism, Paper Presented at the Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Denver, March 1975.
Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Cognitive-developmental Approach to Moral Education, Phi Delta Kappan, Vol 56, p. 670-677.
Kohlberg, L., (1958). The Development of Modes of Moral Thinking and Choice in the Years 10 to 16, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Chicago, Chicago, 111. pp: 17-125
Kowino, O.J., Agak, J.O., Obiero- Owino, C.E. and Ongunya, R.D., (2011). The Preceived Discrepancy between the Teaching of Charistian Religious Education and Inculcation of Moral Values amongst Secondary School Students in Kisumu East District, Education Research and Review, Vol. 6, No.3, pp. 299-314.
Krebs, D.L., and Denton, K., (2005). Toward A More Pragmatic Apporach to Morality: A Critical Evaluation of Kohlberg’s Mode, Psychological Review, Vol. 112, No. 3, pp. 629- 649.
Kurtines, W., S, and Greif, E.B., (1974). The Developmen of Moral Thouht: Review and Evalucation of Kohlberg’s Approach, Psychological Bulletine, Vol. 81, No. 8, P. 453- 470.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
235
Hersh, R.H., Paolitto, D.P., and Remier, J., (1979). Promoting Moral Frowth: from Piget to Kohlberg, New York: Long man.
Higgins, A., (1980). Research and Measurement Issues in Moral Education Interventions, In R. Mosher (Ed). Moral Education: A First Generation of Research and Development, pp. 92- 107, New York: PRAGER.
Hoffman, M., (1979). Development of Moral Thought, Feeling and Behavior, American Psychologist, Vol. 34. No. 10, pp. 958-966.
Hoffman, M., (1977). Moral Internalization: Current Theory and Research, Advances in Experimental Psychology. Vol. 10, pp. 86-115.
Johnson, D.W., and Johnson R.T., (2009). An Educational Psychology Success Story: Social Interdependence Theory and Cooperative Learning, Educational Researcher, Vol. 38. No. 5, pp. 365-379.
Johnson, W.D., Johnson. R.T., and Beth Stanne, M., (2000). Cooperative Learning Methods: A Meta-analysis, University of Minnesota, Available at web.
Johnson, D.W., Johnson, R.T. and Holubec, E., (2007). Cooperative Learning and Moral Education, The Newsletter of the Cooperative Learning Institute, Vol. 22, Iss. 1, pp.1-8.
Latif, A., (2000). The Relationship between Ethical Dilemma Fiscussion and Moral Development, American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, Vol. 64, pp. 126- 133.
Latif, D.A., (1999). Using Ethical Dilemma Case Studies to Develop Pharmacy Student’s Moral Reasoning, Journal of Pharmaceutic Teaching, Vol. 7, pp.51- 66.
Lind, G., (2006). Effective Moral Education: The Konstanz Method of Dilemma Discussion, Hellenic Journal of Psychology, Vol. 3, pp. 189-196.
Lind, G., (2005). Moral Dilemma Discussion Revisited- the Konstanz Method. European Journal of Psychology, February 2005, Available at web: www.uni-konstanz.de/ag-moral.
Lind, G., (1995, April). The Meaning and Measurement of Moral Competence Revisited, Paper Presented at Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco.
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
236
Lockwood, A.L., (1978). The Effects of Values Clarification and Moral Development Curricula on School-age Subjects: A Critical Review of Recent Research, Review of Educational Research. Summer, Vol. 48, No. 3, pp. 325-364.
Murray, F.B., (1990). Cooperative Learning. In N. Entwistle (ed). Handbook of Educational Ideas and Pratices, Routledge, London.
Narvaez, D., (2002). Does Reading Moral Stories Build Character? Educational Psychology Review, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 155-171.
Nucci, L., (1997). Moral Development and Character Formation, In H.J. Walberg and G.D. Haertle (Eds). Psychology and Educational Practice, Berkeley Maccarchan, P. 127-157.
Nucci, L., (1987). Synthesis of Research on Moral Development, Educational Leadership, February, pp. 86-92.
Nucci, L., and Turiel, E., (2009). Capturing the Complexity of Moral Development and Education, Mind, Brain and Education, Vol. 3, pp. 151-159.
Nunner- Winkler, G., (1994). Moral Development, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.
Oser, F.K., (1997). Acquiring Sttitudes and Balues. In L.J Saha (ed). The International Encyclopedia of the Sociology of Education, Pergamon Press.
Oser, F.K., (1986). Moral Education and Values Education: The Discourse Perspective, In M.C. Wittrock (ed). Handbook of Research on Teaching,Merican Education Research Association.
Oser, F., and Reichenbach, R., (1994). Moral Education: Philosophical Issues, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds)., The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Perss.
Pen, W.Y. Jr., (1990). Teaching Ethics- a Direct Approach, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 19, pp. 128-138.
Piaget, J., (1932). The Moral Judgment of the Child, Translate by: M. Gabain, New York: Free Press, 1965.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
237
Rest, J.R., (1979). Development in Judging Moral Issues, University of Minnesota Press. Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Rest, J.R., (1986). DIT Manual. (3th ed). University of Minnesota, Center for the Study of Ethical Development, Minneapolis.
Rest, J.R., (1986). Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory.PRAGER. New York.
Rest, J., (1973). The Hierarchical Nature of Stage of Moral Development, Journal of Personality, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 86-109.
Rest., J.R., Narvaez, D., Bebeau. M., & Thoma, S., (1999). A Neo-kohlbergian Approach: the DIT and Schema Theory, Educational Psychology Review, Vol. 11, No. 4, pp: 291- 324.
Rest J.R., Narvaez, D., Thoma, S.J., and Bebeau, M,J., (2000). A Neo-Kohlbergain Approach to Morality Research, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 29, pp. 381-396.
Rest, J.R., Narvaez, D., Thoma, S,J., and Bebeau, M.J., (1999). DIT 2: Devising and Testing A Revised Instrument of Moral Judgment, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 91, No. 4, P: 644- 659.
Rest., and Thoma, S.J., (1986). Educational Programs and Interventions, In J.R. Rest (ed), Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory, PRAGER. New York.
Rest, J.R., Thoma, S,J., Narvaez, D., and Bebeau M,J., (1997). Alchemy and Beyond: Indexing the Defining Issues Test, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 89. No. 3, pp: 498-507.
Rubtsov, V.V., (1994). Social Interaction and Learning, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.
Schlaefli, A., Rest, J.R., and Thoma, S.J., (1985). Does Moral Education Improve Moral Judgment? A Meta-analysis of Intervention Studies Using the Defining Issues Test, Review of Educational Research, Vol. 55. No.3. pp: 319-352.
Self. D.J., Baldwin, D.C Jr, and Olivarez, M., (1993). Teaching Medical Ethics to First-year Students while Using Film Discussion to Develop Their Moral Reasoning, Academic Medicine, Vol. 68, pp. 383-385.
����� ���� ���� ���� �� ���� ���� ��� �� ��! " #
238
Self, D.J., Olivarez, M. and Baldwin, D.C., (1998). The Amount of Small-group Case- Study Discussion Needed to Improve Moral Reasoning Skills of Medical Students, Academic Medicine, Vol. 75, No.5, pp. 521-523.
Shaffer, D.R., (1989). Developmental Psychology, (2th ed). Brooks Cole pub. Company, Wadsworth, Inc.
Slavin, R. (1990). Cooperative Learning: Theory, Research and Practice, Needham Heights, Mass: Allyn and Bacon.
Slavin, R.E., (1994). Educational Psychology: Theory and Practice, (4th ed), Allyn and Bacon.
Slavin, R.E., (1996). Research on Cooperative Learning and Achievement: What We Know, What Are Need to Know, Contemporary Educational Psychology, Vol. 21, pp. 43-69.
Slavin, R.E., (1987). Students Motivating Students to Excel: Cooperative Incentives, Cooperative Tasks, and Student Achievement, In H.F. Clarizio, R.C. Craig and W.A. Mehrens (Eds). Contemporary Issues in Educational Psychology (5th ed). Mc graw-hill, International Edition.
Slavin, R., (1991). Synthesis of Research on Cooperative Learning, Educational Leadership, Vol. 48, No. 5, pp. 71-82.
Sprinthall, N.A., Sprinthall, R.C. and Oja, S.N., (1994). Educational Psychology: A Developmental Approach, (6th ed). Mc Graw- Hill Inc.
Tomlinson, P., (1992). Moral Judgment and Moral Psychology: Piaget, Kohlberg and Beyond. In L. Smith (ed): Jean Piaget, Critical Assessment, Vol, 1. Routledge, London.
Turiel, E., (1998). The Development of Morality, In W. Damon (chief ed)., Handbook of Psychology, Vol. 3. Nancy Eisenberg-John, willey.
Turiel, E., (1983). The Development of Social Knowledge: Morality and Convention, Cambridge University Press.
Vezzuto, L.A., (2004). How Young People Develop Character, A Conceptual Framework with Descriptions of Promising Practices, Institute for Character Education, Learning Support unit.available at web.
���$% &'! (�� �� $)*+,���-� ��!�. ... . � ���$0 .�$ 1�$2�
239
Vincent, P., (2003). Developing Character in Students; A Work Book for Teachers, Parents and Communities, Chapel Hill, NC; Character Development Publishing.
Walker, L.J., Henning, K.H., and Krettenauer T., (2000). Parent and Peer Context for Children’s MoralR Development, Child Development, Vol. 71, No. 4, pp. 103-104.
Wark, G.R., and Krebs, D.L., (2000). The Construction of Moral Dilemma in Everyday Life, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 29, p. 5-21.