haxxsxws
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
1/7
Whether This Case Involves A ... vs State Of Gujarat & on 18 December !"1#
R/SCR.A/6330/2015 CAV JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION (QUASHING NO. 6330 !" 2015 #$%&
SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 633' !" 2015 #$%&
SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 6263 !" 2015
#$%&
SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 626 !" 2015 #$%&
SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 6265 !" 2015
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE)
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE J.B.PARDI#ALA
1 CONSPIRAC* TO COMMIT OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 121 (SECTION 121A OF THE IPC)
+#&!,-, $%&$ ! $%&!% I$ 4!$, %! 7 !" %&, !"",4,
$&89, 87 S,4%$! 121: ! 4!$, %! !-,,: 87 ;, !" 4$;$9
"!4, ! %&, &! !" 4$;$9 "!4,: %&, C,%9 G!-,;,% ! 7 S%%, G!-,;,%: &99 8, $&, $%& $;$!;,% "! 9$",: ! $%& $;$!;,% !" ,$%&, ,4$%$! &$4& ;7 ,$ !" 4!$4$,)
($ C!$$= $%&$ ! !%$, I$ %! C!;;$% 7 !" %&, !"",4, $&89, 87 S,4%$! 121 I.P.C.@
($$ C!$$= %! !-,, %&, G!-,;,% 87 ;, !" C$;$9 "!4, ! %&, &! !" 4$;$9 "!4,.
H,4, %&, ,,%$9 $=,$,% !" %&, !"",4, , %&$ ,4%$! !9 HCNIC P=, 120 !" 136 C,%, O S%
D,4 1' 02)35)0 IST 2015 120 !" 136 8,)
($ =$= =$% %&, G!-%. !" I$@ !
($$ %%,;%$= %! =, =$% %&, G!-%. !" I$@ !
($$$ 8,%%$= %&, =$= =$% %&, G!-%. !" I$.
($- C!$, %! !-,, 87 ;, !" 4$;$9 "!4, ! %&, &! !" 4$;$9 "!4,.
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1569253/
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
2/7
3 A 4!$47 $ 4!;8$%$! !" %! ! ;!, ,! %! ! 9"9 4%: ! %! ! 9"9 4% 87
9"9 ;,. T&$ ,4%$! $%$4%$! 8,%,, %&, G!-,;,% !" I$ S%%,
G!-,;,%. A7 4!$47 %! 4&=, %&, "!; !" %&, G!-,;,% !" I$ ! 7 S%%, G!-,;,%: ,-,
%&!=& $% ;7 ;!% %! !"",4, , !%&, ,4%$! !" %&, C!,: !9 !% 8, !"",4,, %&$ ,4%$!: 9, $% $ 4!$47 %! !-,, 4& G!-,;,%
87 ;, !" 4$;$9 "!4, ! &! !" 4$;$9 "!4,: $99%%,
$ %&, ;%%, !" J&89 - E;,!: (1'33 55 ILR (A99 100.
T&, ! !-,, 49,97 $;!% ;!, %& %&, 4,%$! !"
,&,$! ! 9; ! ,-, ,& ",. T&, &, +4!$47 %! !-,,+ & 8,, , $ %&$ !-$$! !" %&, IPC. O-,, $ 97 ; %,; ;, %! 8,: "$=&%, ! $%$;$%,. T&, !
4!$, %! !-,, 87 ;, !" 4$;$9 "!4, ! %&, &! 4$;$9
"!4,: %&, G!-,;,% !" I$: ! 7 S%%, G!-,;,% $ %&$ ,4%$!
49,97 ,;84, !% ;,,97 4!$47 %! $, =,,9 $,4%$!: HCNIC P=, 121 !" 136 C,%, O S%D,4 1' 02)35)0 IST 2015 121 !" 1368% 9! 4!$47 %! !-,, %&, G!-,;,% !" I$ ! 7 S%%,
G!-,;,% 87 %&, !=$%$! !" ,$! $!% ! 9=,
%;9%! 9"9 ,;897 ,, $ %&, 4, !" R; -.
E;,!: (1'50 30 ILR (P% 152.
I% , %! 4!!%, %&, 4,%$! !" $%%$! $ &$4& %&, ;,;8, !" %&, C,%9 ! %&,S%%, G!-,;,% ",,9 %&,;,9-, 4!;,99, %! 4&!!, 8,%,, 7$,9$= %! "!4, ! ,
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
3/7
,-, $" %&, ,%$, 4, !" %&, !,4%$! $ 44,%, %,: $49$= %&, %%,;,% 99,=, %! &-, 8,, ;, 87 %&, 9$4% &,,$: !9 !% 4!%$%%, !"",4, !"
,$%$! $&89, , S,4%$! 12A !" %&, IPC. H, 8;$%%, %&% !, !" %&, $=,$,% %! 4!%$%%,
%&, !"",4, $&89, , S,4%$! 12A , ,9% !% ! %&, 9$ ,$= !" %&, F.I.R. H,
8;$%%, %&% $ ,;!4%$4 4!%7: 9$>, I$: 7 4$%$, 4 $,&$ -!$4, =$% 7 G!-,;,%: $" %&, G!-,;,% $ !% "! %! 8,
4%$= $ %&, $%,,% !" %$49 4!;;$%7. H, 8;$%%, %&% %&, =$%%$! "! %&, ,,-%$! 4!9 !% 8,
$ %! 8,: $ 7 ;,: 9"9.
10 M. M=>$7: %&, 9,, 4!,9 ,$= "! %&, 9$4%
8;$%%, %&% %&,, $ !% &$, !" 99,=%$! %&% %&, 9$4%&,,$: 87 %&,$ ,$4$9 4%$-$%$,: !;!%, ,;$%7 8,%,, $"",,% =! ! =! !" ,9$=$!: ,%4.
M. M=>$7 8;$%%, %&% %&, !"",4, !" =$= $,%, $ %&, I$ P,9 C!,
&, %&, N%$! "$=&%$= "! $,,,4, =$% %&, B$%$&,.
A44!$= %! M. M=>$7: %&, ,
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
4/7
M. M=>$7 8;$%%, %&% 8,"!, ,! $ 44, !"
&-$= 4!;;$%%, !"",4, !" =$= : %&, $%,%$! ! !,
8,&$ %&, ,"$4, ! $$= %&, G!-,;,% &!9 9! 8, 9!!>,
$%!. H, 8;$%%, %&% %&, =$%%$! $ "! ,,-%$!. T&, !8,4% !, !" %&, =$%%$! $ !% %! %$>, % %&, !-,,$= %&!$%$, !" %&, R9, ! %&, G!-,;,%.
S,4%$! 12A ,9 $%& S,$%$!: S,$%$! $ 4$;, =$% !4$,%7
,97 99$, %! %&% !" %,!: $% ",,%97 ,4,, %,! 87
&!% $%,-9. S,$%$! $ $%,9" $ 4!;,&,$-, %,;: $% ,;84,99 %&!, 4%$4,: &,%&, 87 !: ,,: ! $%$=: &$4& , 4949%, %! $%8 %&, %$9$%7 !" %&,
S%%,: 9, $=!% ,! %!
,,-! %! 8-,% %&, G!-,;,% 9 !" %&, 4!%7. T&, !8,4%
!" ,$%$! =,,997 , %! $4, $4!%,% $,4%$!: %$ !!$%$! %! %&, G!-,;,%: 8$= %&, ;$$%%$! !" %$4, $%! 4!%,;%@ %&, -,7 %,,47
!" ,$%$! $ %! $4$%, %&, ,!9, %! $,4%$! ,8,99$!. +S,$%$! & 8,, ,4$8,
$9!79%7 $ HCNIC P=, 20 !" 136 C,%, O S% D,4 1' 02)35)0 IST 2015 20 !"1364%$!: %&, 9 4!$, ,$%$! 99 %&!, 4%$4, &$4& &-, "! %&,$ !8,4% %! ,
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
5/7
I% $ %&, ";,%9 $=&% !" ,-,7 4$%$, %! &-, &$ ! !9$%$49 %&,!$, $, %!
!=%, %&,; !> "! %&,$
,%89$&;,% ! 9!= &, !, !% ,,> %! ! ! 87 "!4, -$!9,4, ! 4!%-,, 7 !-$$! !" 9.T&, ,; "! ,,-%$! "! %&, ;,;8, !" %&, P%$ P%,9 4!;;$%7 87 $%,9" $ !% !"",4,. I% $
!, %! %&, ;,;8, !" %&, P%$ P%,9 4!;;$%7 %! ,,> ,,-%$!: $" -$989, $ 9 ! %&, S%%,
G!-,;,%: 87 7 !" !9$47 ,4$$!:,,; "$% %! !-$,. I% $ 9! !, %! ,; "! ,,-%$! 87 ,4,"9;,: 4,,9,97 "$=&%$= 89$4 !$$! %&% ;$=&% 8, =$% %&,; !!$=
%&!, &! ,$, %&, 4!%$4, !" %&, ,! !"",4, !" ,$%$! $%& &$4& ;7 $ %&$ 4!%7 ,, !97 %!! ";$9$ $=%&, 7 !" B$%$& 9,. T&, !"",4, !" ,$%$! $ %&, ,9%% !" %&, 894$= !" %!
4!%,$= "!4, ) ;,97: ",,!; ,4$%7.
F,,!; ,4$%7 $ %&,$ , "!; , %=!$%$4 !9, ) !, !9, ,,,%
%&, $%,,% !" %&, $$-$9 $ 8,$= ""!, %&, ;
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
6/7
-
8/18/2019 Haxxsxws
7/7
2. T&, ,, ;, "! 7 %,!89, !, $ 8,99;
9,-%;: %&!=& !% 8,99; ,4;.
33 S,4%$! 121 !" %&, I.P. C!, ,;84, ,-,7 ,4$%$! !" &,%&, 87 $,4%$! ! $-$!. T&, %, 4$%,$! $ %&, !, ! $%,%$! $%& &$4& %&, -$!9,% 4%
, 99,=, %! &-, 8,, 4!;;$%%,. T&, !8,4% !" 4& -$!9,% 4% ;% 8, %! %%$ 87 "!4,
-$!9,4,: !8,4% !" =,,9 89$4 %, %&,,87 %$>$= $,4%97 =$% %&, G!-,;,% %&!$%7.
2. T! %&$ 9$% & %! 8, , +%,!$% 4%+ &$4& , ! 4!$4! !7. T&!=& ,-,7 %,!$% 4% !, !% ;!% %! =$= : 4,%$ %,!$% 4% 4 9! 4!%$%%,
%&, !"",4, !" =$= %&,, $ ! $4&!%!;7 8,%,, %&, %!. T,!$% 4% 4 ;$",%
%&,;,9-, $%! 4% !" . T,!$% 4% !;%, 87 $%,%$! %!
%$>, % %&, !-,,$= %&!$%7 !" %&, S%%,/G!-,;,%: %%;!% %!=$= $,,4%$-, !" %&, ;8, $-!9-, ! %&, "!4, ,;9!7,.
10. A F99 B,4& !" %&, A99&8 H$=& C!% & 9,7 %>, $4$9 !%$4, !" %&$ -$,
S9$= R; -. E;,! MANU/UP/001/1'2 ) AIR 1'3 A99 26 %&, C!% $ E=9 &-,
%>, $4$9 !%$4, !" $;$9 "4% : "! $%4,: %&% %$49 , &-, 8,, %%4>, 87 &!%$9,$4"%. +I,4%$!+ $ ,"$, $ %&, O