managerial economics 07042011
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
1/129
1
qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwerty
opasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfg
klzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvb
nmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqweyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopa
dfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklz
vbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmq
wertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyu
pasdfghjkl bnmqwerty
uiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasd
ghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzx
vbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqw
ertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuio
asdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjxcvbnmrtyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqw
tyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiop
dfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjk
xcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm
[Managerial Economics ]AMITY eLEARNING
Amity University
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
2/129
2
Preface
This is an attempt to the integration of economic theory with business practices for the purpose
of facilitating Decision Making and Forward Planning by the management. As economics
provides as a set of concepts, these concepts furnish us the tools and techniques of analysis. It is
in this context economic analysis is an aid to understand business practices in a given
environment. As decision making is a basic function of manager, economics is a valuable guide
to the manager. In the following we shall be discussing the decision making process of the
management and how managerial economics and its various tools and techniques help a
manager in this process.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
3/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
4/129
4
Chapter-I
Managerial Decision Making
Contents:
1.1Introduction
1.2 Decision Making Process
1.3 Management Decision Problems
1.4 Corporate Decision Making: Ford Introduces the Taurus
1.5 Types of Decision
1.6 Conditions Affecting Decision Making1.7 The Steps of Decision Making
1.8 Selecting the Best Alternative
1.9 Implementing the Decision
1.10 Evaluating the Decision
1.11 Decision Making Model
1.11.1 The Classical Model
1.11.2 The Administrative Model
1.12 Decision Making Techniques1.12.1 Marginal Analysis
1.12.2 Financial Analysis
1.13 Group Decision Techniques
1.13.1 Brainstorming
1.13.2 Nominal Group Technique
1.13.3 Delphi Group Technique
1.14 Decision Making Tools
1.14.1 Linear Programming1.14.2Inventory Control
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
5/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
6/129
6
1.4 Corporate Decision Making : Ford Introduces the Taurus
In late 1985 Ford Introduced the Taurus -a newly designed, aerodynamically styled, front-
wheel drive automobile. The car was a huge success at the time and helped Ford almost to
double its profits by 1987. The design and efficient production of this car involved not only
some impressive engineering advances, but a lot of economics as well. Ford, had to think
carefully about how the public would react to the Taurus design. Would consumers be swayed
by the styling and performance of the car? How strong would demand depend on the price
Ford changed? Understanding consumer preferences and trade-offs and predicting demand
and its responsiveness to price were essential parts of the Taurus program.
Ford had to be concerned with cost of the Car. How high would production costs be, how
would this depend on the number of cars for produced each year? How would union wage
negotiations or the prices of steel and other raw materials effect costs? How much and how fast
would costs decline as managers and workers gained experience with the production process?
To maximize profits, how many cars should Ford plan to produce each year?
Ford also had to design a pricing strategy for the car and consider how its competitors would
react to this strategy. For example, should Ford charge a low price for the basic stripped-down
version of the car but high prices for individual options, such as air conditioning and power
steering? Or would it be more comfortable to make these options "Standard" items and charge
a high price for the whole package? Whatever prices ford choose, how were its competitors
likely to react? Would GM and Chrystler try to under cut Ford by lowering prices? Might Ford
be able to deter GM and Chrysler from lowering prices by threatening to respond with its own
price cuts? The Taurus program required a large investment in new capital equipment and
Ford had to consider the risks involved and the possible outcomes. Some of this risk was due to
uncertainty over the future price of gasoline (Higher gasoline prices would shift demand to
smaller cars). What would happen if world oil prices doubled or tripled, or, if the government
imposed a new tax on gasoline? How should Ford take these uncertainties into account when
making its investment decisions? Ford also had to worry about organizational problems, Ford
is an integrated firm -separate divisions produce engines and parts, then assemble finished
cars. How should the managers of the different divisions be rewarded? What price should the
assembly division be charged for engines it receives from another division? Should all the parts
be obtained from the upstream divisions, or other firms? All these decision come under
managerial decision taking process.
1.5 Types of Decision
Managers make many decisions, in order to answer the following questions:
What goods shall firm produce?
How should firm raise the necessary capital and what shall be its legal form.
What technique shall be adopted, and what shall be the scale of operations?
Where production is located?
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
7/129
7
How shall its product be distributed?
How shall resources be combined?
What shall be the size of output?
How shall it deal with its employees?
Managers make these decisions, and in order to obtain a clear understanding of the decision
making process, a classification system is useful. Three such systems are available; each based
on different types of decisions.
Organizational and personal decisions,
Basic and routine decisions
Programmed and non-programmed decisions.
Organizational decisions are those executives make in their official role as managers. The
adoption of strategies, the setting of objectives and the approval of plans constitute only a few
of these. Such decisions are often delegated to others, requiring the support of many people
throughout the organizational if they are to be properly implemented.
Personal decisions are related to the managers as an individual, not as a member of the
organizations. Such decisions are not delegated to others because their implementation does
not require the support of organizational personnel. Deciding to retire, taking a job offer from a
competitive firm, or slipping out and spending the afternoon on the golf course are all personal
decisions.
A second approach is to classify decisions into basic and routine categories. Basic decisions can
be viewed a much more important than routine ones. They involve long-range commitments,
large expenditures of funds, and such a degree of importance that a serious mistake might well
jeopardize the well being of the company. Selection of a product line, the choice of a new plant
site, or a decision to integrate vertically by purchasing sources of raw materials to complement
the current production facilities are all basic decisions.
Routine decisions are often repetitive in nature, having only a minor impact on the firm. For
this reason, most organizations have formulated a host of procedures to guide the manager in
handing these matters. Since some individuals in the organization spend most of their time
making routine decisions, these guidelines are very useful to them.
Taking a cue from computer technology, decision could be classified as computer technology
programmed and non-programmed. These two types can be viewed on a continuum,
programmed being at one end and non-programmed at the other. Programmed decisions
correspond roughly to the routine decisions, with procedures playing a key role. Non
programmed decisions are similar to the category of basic decisions, being highly novel,
important, and unstructured in nature. The value of viewing decision making in this manner is
that it permits a clearer understanding of the methods that accompany each type.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
8/129
8
1.6 Conditions Affecting Decision Making
In an ideal business situation, managers would have al of the information they need to make
decisions with certainty. Most business situations however are characterized by incomplete or
ambiguous information, which affects the level of certainty with which a manager makes a
decision. There are three conditions that affect decision making:
Certainty
Risk
Uncertainty
Certainty is the condition that exists when decision makes are fully informed about a problem
its alternative solutions, and their respective outcomes. Under this condition, individuals can
anticipate, and even exercise some control over, events and their outcomes.
In the context of decision making, risk is the condition .that exists when decision-makers must
rely on incomplete, yet reliable information. Under a state of risk, the decision-maker does not
know with certainty the future outcomes associated with alternative courses of action; the
results are subjects to chance. However, the manager has enough information to determine the
probabilities associated with each alternative. He or she can then choose. The alternative that
has the highest probability of success.
Uncertainty is the condition that exists when little or no factual information is available about a
problem, its alternative solution, and their respective outcomes. In a state of uncertainty, the
decision-maker does not have enough information to determine the probabilities associated
with each alternative. In actually, the decision-maker may have so little information that he or
she may be unable even to define the problem, let alone identify alternative solutions and
possible outcomes.
1.7 The Steps of Decision Making
Identifying the problem
Generating the alternative course of action
Evaluating the alternative
Selecting the best alternative
Implementing the decision; and
Evaluating the decision
The first step in the decision-making process is identifying the problem. Problem identification
is probably the most critical art of the decision making process, for it is what determines the
direction that the decision making process takes, and, ultimately, the decision that is made.
The second step in decision-making process is generating alternative solutions to the problem.
This step involves identifying items or activities that could reduce or eliminate the difference
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
9/129
9
between the actual situation and the desired situation. For this step to be effective, the decision
makers must allot enough time to generate creative alternatives as well as ensure that all
individuals involved in the process exercise patience and tolerance of others and their ideas.
In the Pursuit of quick fix managers too often shortchange this step by failing to consider
more than one or two alternatives, which reduces the opportunity to identify effective
solutions. After generating a list of alternatives, the arduous task of evaluating each of them
begins. Numerous methods exist for evaluating the alternatives, including determining the
pros and cons of each; performing a cost-benefit analysis for each alternative; and weighting
factors important in the decision, ranking each alternative relative to its ability to meet each
factor, and then multiplying cumulatively to provide a final value for each alternative.
1.8 Selecting the Best Alternative
After the decision-makers have evaluated all the alternatives, it is time for the fourth step in the
decision-making process; choosing the best alternative. Depending on the evaluation method
used, the selection process can be fairly straightforward. The best alternative could be the one
with the most "pros" and the fewest "cons"; the one with the greatest benefits and the lowest
costs; or the one with the highest cumulative value, if using weighting.
1.9 Implementing the Decision
This is the step in the decision making process that transforms the selected alternative from an
abstract situation into reality. Implementing the decision involves planning and executing the
actions that must take place so that the selected alternative can actually solve the problem.
1.10 Evaluating the Decision
In evaluating the decision, the sixth and final step in the decision-making process, managers
gather information to determine the effectiveness of their decision. Has original problem
identified in the first step been resolved? If not, is the company closer to the situation it desired
than it was at the beginning of the decision-making process?
1.11 Decision Making Model
There are basically two major models of decision-making -the classical model and the
administrative model.1.11.1 The Classical Model
The classical model of decision making is a prescriptive approach that outlines how managers
should make decisions. Also called the rational model, the classical model is based on
economic assumptions and asserts that managers are logical, rational individuals who make
decision that are in the best interest of the organization. The classical model is characterized by
the following assumptions:
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
10/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
11/129
11
Similarly, land's marginal -product is the change in total product resulting from one additional
unit of land with all other inputs held constant. The manager can use the concept to answer
questions such as how much more output will result if one more worker is hired? The answer
often called marginal physical product, provides a basis for determining whether or not one
new man will bring about profitable additional output.
1.12.2 Financial Analysis
The firms are supposed to safeguard their interest and avert the possibilities of risk or try to
minimize it. For this a firm needs to analyze the assets as well as liabilities, efficiency of capital
investment, choice of project and various vital ratios. The cost benefit analysis ensures the
firms to take prudent financial decision.
1.13 Group Decision Techniques
There are several group decision techniques:
1.13.1 Brainstorming
Brainstorming is a technique in which group members spontaneously suggest keys to solve a
problem. Its primary purpose is to generate a multitude of creative alternatives, regardless of
the likelihood of their being implemented.
1.13.2 Nominal Group Technique
The Nominal Group Technique involves, the use of highly structured meeting agenda and
restricts discussion or interpersonal communication during the decision making process. While
the group members are all physically present, they are required to operate independently.
1.13.3 Delphi Group Technique
The Delphi group Technique employs a written survey to gather expert opinions from a
number of people without holding a group meeting. Unlike in brainstorming and nominal
groups, Delphi group participants never meet fact to face; in fact, they may be located in
different cities and never see each other.
1.14 Decision Making Tools
The major decision- making tools are as under:
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
12/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
13/129
13
Where:
D = expected annual demand
A = Administrative costs per order
V = Value per item
r = Estimate for taxes, insurance and other expenses
The EOQ formula is used by many firms in solving inventory control problems. However, it isonly one of many mathematical techniques that lave been developed to help the manager make
decisions.
Another important tool in taking one of the most economical decisions is "Decision Trees"
Many managers weight alternatives base don their immediate or short-run results, but a
decision- tree format permits a more dynamic approach because it makes some elements
explicit that are generally implicit in other analyses. A decision tree is a graphic method that
the manager. can employ in identifying the alternative courses of action available to him in
solving a problem; assigning payoff corresponding to each act-event combination.For example, consider the case of a firm that has expansion funds and must decide what to do
with them. After careful analysis, three alternatives identified:
Use the money to buy a new company
expand the facilities of the current firm
put the money in a saving account
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
14/129
14
And wait for better opportunities. In deciding which alternative is best, the company has
gathered all the available information and constructed the decision tree.
In the figure there are four important components. One is the decision point, represented by a
square, which indicates where the decision maker must choose a course of action. second is a
chance point, represented by a circle, which indicates where a chance event is expected, such as
solid economic growth, stagnation, or high inflation. A third is the branch, represented by a
line flowing from the chance points, which indicates an event and its likelihood such as 0.5 per
solid growth, 0.3 for stagnation or 0.2 for high inflation. Finally, at the far right is a payoff
associated with the each branch. It is called a conditional payoff since its occurrence depends
on certain conditions. For example, in figure the conditional ROI (Return on Investment)
associated with buying a new firm and having solid economic growth is 15 per cent, but this
return is conditional on the two preceding factors (buying the firm and having solid growth).
In building a decision tree, the company will start by identifying the three alternatives, the
probabilities and events associated with each alternative, and the amount of return that can be
expected from each. Having then constructed the tree, the firm will roll back it from right to
left, analyzing as it goes.
This analysis is conducted, first by taking the conditional ROls at the far right of the tree and
multiplying them by the probability of their occurrence. For example, if the company buys a
new firm and there is solid growth in the economy, as seen in figure, it will obtain a 15 per cent
ROL However, the probability of such an occurrence is 0.5 Likewise, the probabilities
associated with stagnant growth, where the return will be 9 percent, and high inflation, where
the return will be 3 percent, are .3 and .2 respectively. In order to determine the expected return
associated with buying a new firm, each of the conditional ROl s is multiplied by its respective
probability and the products are then totaled. For alternative one, buying the firm, the
calculation is as follows:
Conditional ROI Probability Expected Return
15.0 0.5 7.5
9.0 0.3 2.7
3.0 .02 0.6
10.8
For alternative two, expanding current facilities, the calculation is:
Conditional ROI Probability Expected Return
10.0 0.5 5.0
12.0 0.3 3.6
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
15/129
15
4.0 0.2 0.8
9.4
For alternative three, expanding current facilities, the calculation is:
Conditional ROI Probability Expected Return
6.5 0.5 3.25
6.0 0.3 1.80
6.0 0.2 1.20
6.25
These expected returns are often placed over the chance points on the decision tree. They can
be determined only after the tree has been drawn and the analysis of the branches has been
conducted. The first alternative is the best, because it offers the greatest expected return. In
evaluating alternatives, decision these help the manager identify both what can happen and thelikelihood of its occurrence .In building the tree we moved from left to right but in analyzing
we moved from right to left. In the final analysis the decision tree does not provide any
definitive answers. However, it does allow the manager to allow benefits against costs by
assigning probabilities to specific events and then ascertaining the respective payoff.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
16/129
16
End Chapter quizzes :
Q.1. The Technique that employs a written survey to gather expert opinions from a number of
people without holding a group meeting is known as -
(a) Brainstorming
(b) The Delphi group Technique
(c) The Nominal Group Technique
(d) None of the above
Q.2. Approval of Plans is the best example of -
(a) Organizational decisions,
(b) Basic decisions
(c) Programme decisions.
(d) Both (a) & (c)
Q.3. Which sort of decision does not require the organizational support-
(a) Basic decision
(b) Routine decision
(C) Personal decision
(d) Organizational decision
Q.4 In the context of formulation of an investment decision on a project, the availability of
land, plant, machinery, raw materials and technical know how etc. means-
(a) Technical Feasibility
(b) Financial feasibility
(c) Commercial feasibility
(d) None of the above
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
17/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
18/129
18
(a) Nominal Group Technique,
(b) Brainstorming,
(c) Delphi Group Technique,
(d) Both (b) & (c)
Q.10. In identifying the alternative courses of action available to a manager while solving a
problem, a decision tree is
(a) More dynamic in nature,
(b) Graphical method,
(c) Assigns payoff corresponding to each act-event combination,
(d) All of the above.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
19/129
19
Chapter-II
Business Forecasting
Contents:
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Purpose and need of forecasting
1.2.1 Specific purposes of demand forecasting
1.3 Steps Involved in Forecasting
1.4 Period of forecasting
1.5 Levels of Forecasting
1.6 Methods of Forecasting1.6.1Qualitative Forecast
1.6.1.1 Survey techniques
1.6.1.2 Opinion pools
1.6.2 Statistical Forecast
1.6.2.1 Trend projection method
1.6.2.2 Barometric methods
1.6.2.3 Regression method
1.6.2.4. Simultaneous equation method (Econometric Models)1.6.2.5. Input Output Forecasting
1.7 Reasons for fluctuations in time series data
1.7.1 Cyclical fluctuations
1.7.2 Seasonal variation
1.7.3 Irregular and random variation
1.8 Smoothing Techniques
1.8.1 Moving average smoothing technique1.8.2 Exponential smoothing technique
1.9 Risks in Demand Forecasting
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
20/129
20
1.1 Introduction
Estimation of demand for a product in a forecast year/ period is termed as Demand forecast.
Demand forecast is a must for a firm operating its business as today's market is competitive,
dynamic and volatile.
1.2 Purpose and need of forecastingForecasting is done both for long term as well as short term. The purpose of the two however
differs. In a short run forecast seasonal patters are of prime importance. Such a forecast helps in
preparing suitable sales policy and proper scheduling of output in order to avoid over-stocking
or costly delay in meeting the orders. It helps in arriving at suitable price for the product and
necessary modifications in advertising and sales techniques. Long run forecasts are helpful in
proper capital planning. It helps in saving the wastages in material, m -hours, machine time
and capacity. Long run forecasting is used for new unit planning, expansion of the existing
units, planning long run financial requirements and manpower requirements. Different set of
variables is used in than in short term forecasts.
1.2.1 Specific purposes of demand forecasting
Better planning and allocation of resources
Appropriate production scheduling
Inventory control
Determining appropriate pricing policies
Setting s les targets and establishing controls and incentives.
Planning a new unit or expanding existing one
Planning long term financial requirements
Planning Human Resource Development strategies.
1.3 Steps Involved in Forecasting
Identification of objective
Determining the nature of goods under consideration.
Selecting a proper method of forecasting.
Interpretation of results.
1.4 Period of forecasting
Short run forecasting: In short run forecasting, we look for factors which bring
fluctuation in demand pattern in the market for example weather conditions like
monsoon affecting the demand.
Medium run forecasting: In medium run forecasting is done basically for timing of an
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
21/129
21
activity like advertising expenditure.
Long run forecasting: It is done to ascertain the validity of trend. It is done for decision
like diversification.
1.5 Levels of Forecasting
Macroeconomic forecasting is concerned with business conditions of the whole
economy. It is measured with the help of indices like wholesale price index, consumer
price index.
Industry demand forecasting gives indication to firm regarding direction in which the
whole industry will be moving. It is used to decide the way the firm should plan for
future in relation to the industry.
Firm demand forecasting is done for planning companies overall operations like sales
forecasting etc.
Product line forecasting helps the firm to decide which of the product or products should
have priority in the allocation of firm's limited resources.
General purpose or specific purpose forecast helps the firm in taking general factors
into consideration while forecasting for demand.
Forecast of established product or a new product
Types of commodity for which forecast is to be done. Goods can be broadly classified
into capital goods, consumer durable and Non-durable consumer goods. For each of
these categories of goods there is a distinctive pattern of demand.
1.6 Methods of Forecasting
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
22/129
22
1.6.1Qualitative Forecast
1.6.1.1 Survey techniques
Survey of business executives, plant and equipment, expenditure plans.
Basically compilation of expenditure plans of related industries.Survey of plans for inventory changes and sales expectations.
Survey of consumer expenditure plans.
1.6.1.2 Opinion pools
Consumer survey: In this method the consumers are contacted personally to
disclose their future purchase plans. This could be of two types-Complete
enumeration and sample survey.
Sales force opinion method: In this method people who are closest to themarket are asked for their opinion on future demand. Then opinion of
different people is compiled to get overall demand forecast. This method has
advantage that it is based on first hand knowledge of sales people and also it
is cheap and easy. However the opinion of the concerned people could be
biased or twisted for their own benefit. Therefore a final ratification has to be
done by the head office.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
23/129
23
Experts opinion method: In this method opinion of experts' in the related
field is solicited and the final forecast based on their opinion. A special case
in this method is the Delphi Technique. In this different sets of experts are
given the relevant problem without each knowing about the other and their
opinions or conclusions are compared. If the opinion is matching then theopinion is accepted other wise the experts are asked to sit together and
arrive at a narrow range. Thus the experts giving a very high or a very low
value are concerned and the group argues until it comes up with a narrow
range of value. This process is continued till a sufficient range is reached.
Then the mean of the upper and lower values is computed to reach a point
estimate.
1.6.2 Statistical Forecast
1.6.2.1 Trend projection method
Under the trend method the time series data on the variable under forecast are used to
fit a trend line or curve either graphically or by means of a statistical technique known
as the Least Squares method. Trend projection method can be used when there is some
sort of correlation between the two variables. It could be linear, logarithmic or power
correlation. The linear regression model will take the form of
Y = a + bX
Fitting a trend line by observation: This method involves the plotting of thedata on the graph and estimating where the trend line lies. The line can be
extrapolated and the forecast read from the graph.
Trend through least squares method: This method uses statistical formulae to
find the trend line which best fits the available data. The trend line is the
estimating equation, which can be used for forecasting demand by extrapolating
the line for future and reading the corresponding values of variables on the
graph.
Time series analysis: This is an extension of linear regression which attempts to
build seasonal and cyclical variations into the estimating equation. This method
assumes that past data can be used to predict future sales. This is one of the
most frequently used forecasting methods. It refers to he values of variable
arrange chronologically by days, weeks, months, quarters or years. The first step
in time series analysis is usually to plot past values of the variable that we seek
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
24/129
24
to forecast on vertical axis and the time on the horizontal axis in order to
visually inspect the movement of the time series over time. It assumption is that
the time series will continue to move as in the past. For this reason time series
analysis is often referred as "native forecasting.
1.6.2.2 Barometric methods
Barometric methods are used to forecast or anticipate short term changes in economic
activity by using leading economic indicators. These indicators are time series that tend
to precede changes in the level of economic activity. There are only three types of
indicators:
Leading economic indicator: These indicators tend normally to anticipate
turning points in a business cycle. There are certain problems associated with
this method. The major problem is not choosing the technique but choosing the
relevant indicator for the product in question. Secondly even if the relevant
indicator is found out the changes in factors may render the indicator redundant
over time. Thirdly the time lag between the indicator and forecast could be so
small that it could become useless.
Coincident indicators: These are indicators which move in step or coincide with
movements in general economic activity or business cycle.
Lagging indicator: These are indicators which lag the movements in economic
activity or business cycle.
1.6.2.3 Regression method
It is one of the statistical tools to fore cast demand. In this estimating equations are
established and tests can be carried out to observe any statistically significant. It
involves following steps
Identification of variables which influence the demand for the good whose
function is under estimation.Collection of historical data on all relevant variables.
Choosing an appropriate form of the function.
Estimation of the function
Regression method is popular because it is prescriptive as well as descriptive.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
25/129
25
Also it is not as subjective or objective as other methods. However if the
variables chosen are wrong then the forecast will also be wrong. A typical
demand equation could be :
Log d = -12.4 + 1.78 log y -1.22 log 0 + 2.20 log v + 0.8 log g + 1.62 log e
Y = National income
O = groundnut oil price
V = Vanaspati price
G = ghee price
E = egg, fish and meat price
The above equation is a demand forecast equation for groundnut oil
1.6.2.4.Simultaneous equation method (Econometric Models)
Econometric forecasting incorporates or utilizes the best features of other forecasting
techniques such as trend and seasonal variation, smoothing techniques and leading
indicators. Econometric forecasting models range from single equation models of the
demand that the firm faces for tits product to large multiple equation models describing
hundreds of sectors and industries of the economy.
Single equation models:The simplest form of econometric forecasting is with the
single equation model. The first step here is to identify the determinants of the variable
to be forecasted.
Q = a0 + a1P + a2Y +a3N + a4P5 + a5Pc + a6a + e
Q = demand
P = Price
Y = disposable income
N = size of population
Ps = price of a substitute
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
26/129
26
Pc = price of complement
A = level of advertising by the firm
Multiple equation model: Sometimes economic relationships may be so complex that amultiple equation model may be required. This is particularly used in forecasting micro
variables or the demand and sales of major sectors or industries. Multiple equation
model for GNP
Ct = a1+b1GNPt+u1t
It =a2+b2IIt-1+U2t
GNPt= Ct+ It+Gt
C = consumption expenditures
GNP = Gross national product in year t
I = investment
II = Profit
G = Government expenditures
U = stochastic disturbance (random error term)
T = current year
t-1 = previous year
Variables to the left of the equal sign are called endogenous variable. These are
the variables that the model seeks to explain or predict from the solution of the
model. Exogenous variables are those determinants outside the model or right
of the equal sign of the equation.
1.6.2.5.Input Output Forecasting
Input output analysis was introduced by Prof. Leontief. With this technique the firm
can also forecast using Input output tables. It shows the use of the output of each
industry as input by other industries and for final consumption. Input and output
analysis allow us to trace through all these inter industry input and outputs flow
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
27/129
27
though out the economy and to determine the total increase of all the inputs required to
meet the increased demand. In this technique we have two input output matrixes.
Direct Requirement Matrix
Total Requirement Matrix
1.6.2.5.1 Uses and shortcomings of input output forecasting
Input output analysis and forecasting has many uses and applications. It is used by the
firm to forecast the raw material, labor and capital requirement needed to meet the
forecasted change in the demand for their product. The shortcomings are that the direct
and total coefficients are assumed to be fixed and thus do not allow input substitution.
Input output tables are usually available with a time lag of many years and while the
input output coefficients do not change very rapidly they can become very biased.
1.7 Reasons for fluctuations in time series data
Changes occur in secular trend i.e. long run increase or decrease in data series.
1.7.1 Cyclical fluctuations
There are the major expansions and contractions in most economic time series data that
seem to re-occur every several years.. A typical cycle could last 15-20 years.
1.7.2 Seasonal variation
This refers to regularly recurring fluctuations in economic activity during each year e.g.
a typical factor could be weather and social customs.
1.7.3 Irregular and random variation
This is the variations in the data series resulting from unique events like wars, natural
disasters or strikes. The total variation in the time series is the result of all the above
four factors operating together. They are usually examined separately by qualitative
techniques.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
28/129
28
1.8 Smoothing Techniques
This technique predicts feature value of time series on the basis of some average of its
past value only. This technique is useful when the time series exhibits little trend or
seasonal variation but a great deal of random variation. There are two smoothing
techniques.
1.8.1 Moving average smoothing technique
The simplest smoothing technique is the moving average. Here the forecasted value of a
time series in a given period is equal to the average value of the time series in a number
of previous periods. This method is more useful the more erratic or random is the time-
series data.
1.8.2 Exponential smoothing technique
This technique is used more frequently than simple averages in forecasting. This
method is a refined version of moving average method. The disadvantage of moving
average method is that it gives equal weightage to thedata related to different periods
(i.e. months) in the past. According to exponential smoothing method more recent the
data the more relevant it is for forecasting and therefore it would be more appropriateto give more weightage to recent observations. The value given to weightage is
normally chosen to form a geometric progression.
With exponential smoothing, the forecast for period t +1 (i.e. Ft + 1) is a weighted
average of the actual and forecasted values of the time series in period. The value of the
time series at period t (i.e. At) is assigned the weight of 1-w6. The greater the value of
w, the greater is the weight given to the value of the time series in period as opposed to
previous periods. Thus, the value of the forecast of the time series in period t +1l is Ft +
1 = WA1 + (1-w) Ft.
In general, different values of W are tried, and the one that leads to the forecast with
smallest root-mean-square error (RMSE) is actually used in forecasting.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
29/129
29
1.9 Risks in Demand Forecasting
Demand forecasting faces two major risks
Overestimation of demand
Underestimation of demand
One risk arises from entirely unforeseen events such as war, political upheavals and
natural disasters. The second risk arises from inadequate analysis of the market.
All these forecasting errors could possibly have been avoided through:
Carefully defining the market for the product to include all potential users of the
market and considering the possibility of product substitution.
Dividing total industry demand into its components and analyzing each
component separately.
Forecasting the main driver or user of the product in each segment of the
market and projecting how they are likely to change in the future.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
30/129
30
End Chapter quizzes :
1. Out of the given plannings, short run forecasting is required for
(a) Expansion of the existing units
(b) New unit planning
(c) Sales forecasting
(d) capital planning
2 This forecasting technique helps the firm to decide which of the product or
products should have priority in the allocation of firm's limited resources.
(a) Product line forecasting
(b) Industry demand forecasting
(c) Firms demand forecasting
(d) Sales Forecasting
3. In Sales force opinion method, opinion of sales people is collected to forecast the
future demand, because
(a) They cannot deny from providing the information.
(b) They are paid by the company.
(c) They are the only experts of consumer behaviour.
(d) Sales People are closely associated with the market.
4. Reasons for fluctuations in time series data may occur due to
(a) Seasonal variation
(b) Cyclical fluctuations
(c) Irregular and random variation
(d) All of the above
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
31/129
31
5. Which one is not a type of Barometric Indicator?
(a) Leading economic indicator
(b) Coincident indicators
(c) Lagging indicator
(d) Climate indicator
6. The disadvantage of this technique is that it gives equal weightage to thedata
related to different periods (i.e. months) in the past.
(a) Moving average smoothing technique
(b) Exponential smoothing technique
(c) Input Output Forecasting
(d) None of the above
7. Which of the following step may help in avoiding or minimizing the errors
in business forecasting?
(a) Carefully defining the market for the product to include all potential users of
the market and considering the possibility of product substitution.
(b)Dividing total industry demand into its components and analyzing each
component separately.
(c) Forecasting the main driver or user of the product in each segment of the
market and projecting how they are likely to change in the future.
(d) All of the above
8. This forecasting technique incorporates or utilizes the best features of other
forecasting techniques such as trend and seasonal variation, smoothing techniques
and leading indicators.
(a) Regression Technique
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
32/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
33/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
34/129
34
1.12 Exceptions to the Law of Demand Upward Sloping
Demand Curve
1.13 Theory of Consumer Behaviour
1.13.1The Cardinal Utility Theory
1.13.1.1 Equilibrium of Consumer
1.13.2The Ordinal Utility Theory
1.13.2.1Equilibrium of Consumer
1.13.2.2 Properties of Indifference Curve
1.14 The consumer surplus
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
35/129
35
1.1 Meaning of Demand
Conceptually, demand can be defined as the desire for a good backed by the
ability and willingness to pay for it. The desire without adequate purchasing
power and willingness to pay do not become effective demand and only an
effective demand matters in economic analysis and business decisions.
1.2 Types of Demand
The demand for various commodities is generally classified on the basis of the
consumers of the product, suppliers of the product, nature of goods, duration of
the consumption of the commodity, interdependence of demand, period of
demand and nature of use of the commodity(intermediate or final).
Individual and Market Demand
Autonomous and derived demand
Demand for durable and nondurable goods
Demand for firms product and industry product
Demand for consumers and producers goods
1.2.1 Individual and Market Demand
The quantity of a commodity which an individual is willing to buy at a
particular price during a specific time period given his money income, his taste
and prices of other commodities is called individuals demand for a commodity.
On the other hand market demand of a commodity is the summation of
individual demand by all the consumers. Market demand is a multivariate
relationship and determined by many factors simultaneously. Some of the most
important determinants of the market demand for a particular commodity are
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
36/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
37/129
37
all the firms of an industry as a whole. A Clear understanding of the relation
between company and industry demand necessitates the understanding of
different market structures. These structures can be differentiated the basis of
product differentiation and number of sellers.
1.2.5 Demand for consumers and producers goods
Consumer goods are those, which are, meant for the final consumption by the
consumers or the end users. Producer's goods on the other hand are used for the
production of consumer goods or they are intermediate goods, which are further
processed upon to convert them into a form to be used by the end user. Another
distinction is that the demand for producers goods is derived demand and it
indirectly depends on the demand for the consumer goods which the producergoods is used to produce. It may also be possible that this demand may be
accelerated or accentuated in the same proportion as the change in the demand
for the final consumer goods. A small change in the demand for consumer
goods may either completely wipes out the demand for the producer goods or
may accelerate it.
1.3 Determinants of Demand
Commoditys Own Price
Prices of related goods Substitutes and Complements
Income level of consumer
Tastes & Preferences
Expectations
Population
Other exogenous factors
1.4 Demand Function
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
38/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
39/129
39
dozen) (dozen per month)
0.50 7.0
1.00 5.0
1.50 3.5
2.00 2.5
2.50 1.5
3.00 1.0
1.7 Demand Curve
Demand curve is the graphical representation of the relationship between price
and quantity demanded of a good, all other things being held constant. A
demand curve is said to be linear when its slope is constant all along the curve,
whereas for a nonlinear or curvilinear curve the slope never remains constant.
The linear demand curve may be written in the form of;
Q b0@b
1P
Q
P
Linear DemandQ
P
Non Linear Demand
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
40/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
41/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
42/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
43/129
43
If 0 < ep < 1, the demand is inelastic total expenditure total expenditure and price
change move in the same direction.
If 1< ep
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
44/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
45/129
45
If the demand is inelastic (e < 1) an increase in price leads to an
increase in total revenue and vice versa.
If the demand is elastic (e>1) an increase in price will lead to a
decrease in total revenue and vice versa.
If the demand has unitary elasticity (e =1), total revenue is not affected
by changes in price.
1.10.1.2 Determinants of Price Elasticity of Demand
Number and availability of Substitutes
The proportion of income spent on the particular commodity
Nature of the need that the product satisfies
Length of time period under consideration
The number of uses to which a commodity can be put
1.10.1.3 Price elasticity and Decision Making
Information about price elasticities can be extremely useful to managers
as they contemplate pricing decisions.
If demand is inelastic at the current price, a price decrease will result in a
decrease in total revenue.
Alternatively, reducing the price of a product with elastic demand would
cause revenue to increase.
Remember TR = P*Q
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
46/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
47/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
48/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
49/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
50/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
51/129
51
Consumer surplus = PCA
End Chapter quizzes :
Q.1. The demand curve of a normal commodity is
(a) Upward Sloping
(b) Downward sloping
(c) Horizontal
(d) Vertical
Q.2 What happens to demand when price of the commodity falls
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
52/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
53/129
53
(d) Downward sloping and convex to the origin
Q.7 The shape of indifference curve implies
(a) Diminishing MRSxy
(b) Increasing MRSxy
(c) Constant MRSxy
(d) Infinite MRSxy
Q.8 The marginal utility from successive consumption of normal good
(a) Increases
(b) Decreases
(c) Remain constant
(d) Undefined
Q.9 According to the ordinal approach consumers equilibrium is where
(a)MUxMUy
ffffffffffffffff1PxPy
ffffffff
(b)
MUx
MUy
ffffffffffffffff
PxPy
ffffffff
Q.10 Given the demand function Q = 90-3p and P = 6, Q=?
(a) Q = 67
(b) Q = 72
(c) Q = 108
(d) Q = 81
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
54/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
55/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
56/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
57/129
57
Fixed costs are those which are fixed in volume for a certain given output. It does not
vary with variation in the output for a certain scale. The fixed costs include the cost of
managerial and administrative staff, depreciation of fixed assets, maintenance of land
etc. Fixed costs are associated with the short run. Variable costs are those which varywith the variation in the total output. It include cost of raw material, cost of direct labor,
running cost of fixed capital such as fuel, repairs, routine maintenance etc.
1.3.3 Total, Average and Marginal Costs
1.3.3.1 Total Cost
Total cost is the total expenditure incurred on the production. It connotes both explicit
and implicit money expenditure and include fixed and variable costs.
C f X,T,Pf
,K
Where C total cost
X output
T technology
Pf
prices of factors
K fixed factors
TC TFC TVC
Total Cost Curves
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
58/129
58
1.3.3.2 Average cost
Average cost is obtained by dividing the total cost by the total output.
ACTC
Q
fffffffff
Average cost further can be categorized as average fixed cost (AFC) and average
variable cost (AVC).
AFCTFC
Q
ffffffffffffff
AVCTVC
Q
ffffffffffffff
Average cost curves
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
59/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
60/129
60
If capital is held constant (short run) then the marginal product of labor gives
the short run cost curves their shape.
The levels of cost curves are determined by market price of factor along with
technology.
AFC falls continuously
MC equals AVC and ATC at their minimum
Minimum AVC occurs at a lower output than minimum ATC due to FC
1.5 Short-Run Output Decision
Firm sets output at Q1, where MC=MR subject to checking the average condition:
If P > ATC, the firm produces Q1 at a profit
If ATC > P > AVC, the firm produces Q1 at a loss
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
61/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
62/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
63/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
64/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
65/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
66/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
67/129
67
1.1Production Function
The creation of any good or service that has value to either producers or consumers is
termed as production. Production function is a technical relation between factor inputs
and outputs. It describes the laws of proportion that is the transformation of factor
inputs into outputs at any particular time period. The production function includes all
the technically efficient methods of production.
X f L, K, R, S, v, y
In the process of production, the manager is concerned with efficiency in the use of
inputs (Labor, Capital, Land and Entrepreneurship)
Technical Efficiency Occurs when it is not possible to increase output without
increasing inputs
Economic Efficiency Occurs when a given output is being produced at the lowestpossible cost. Improvement of Technology is reflected in an upward shift in the
Production Function. The same amount of input leads to a higher output
L
X f L
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
68/129
68
1.2 Short Run Analysis
Short Run is the period of time in which one (or more) of the factors of production
employed in a production process is fixed or incapable of being varied. We usually
assume Capital (K) to be fixed and analyze how output varies with changes in Labor (L)
X f L
1.2.1 Marginal Product of Labor
The change in output resulting from a very small change in Labor keeping all other
factors constant.
MPL = XL
If MP > 0, total production is rising
If MP < 0, total production is falling
Total production is maximum when MP = 0
f L
f1 L
L
Q
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
69/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
70/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
71/129
71
1.3.2 Laws of Returns to Scale
In the long run expansion of output may be achieved by varying all factors by the same
proportion or by different proportions. The laws of returns to scale refer to the effects of
scale relationship. Three types of returns to scale are observed.
Constant returns to scale
Increasing returns to scale
Decreasing returns to scale
1.3.2.1 Constant returns to scale
If the quantity of all inputs used in the production is increased by a given proportionand we have output increased in the same proportion; it is termed as constant returns
to scale.
1.3.2.2 Increasing returns to scaleIf output increases by a greater proportion in comparison to a change in the scale of
inputs it is termed as increasing Returns to Scale. The causes of increasing returns to
scale are:
Specialization of labor
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
72/129
72
Inventory Economies
Managerial indivisibilities
Technical indivisibilities
1.3.2.3 Diminishing Returns to Scale
If output increases by a smaller proportion in comparison to the change in the scale of
inputs, it is described as diminishing returns to scale. The reasons of diminishing
returns to scale are:
Managerial inefficiency
Exhaustible natural resources
Increased bureaucratic
Labor inefficiency
Pressure on inputs market due to increasing demand
Pressure on inputs prices due to bulk purchase
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
73/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
74/129
74
MRTSl
,k@ K/ L X/ LD X/ K
MRTSl ,kMP
l
MPk
fffffffffffffff
1.5 Equilibrium of the Firm
A profit maximizing firm will be using optimal amount of an input at the point at
which the monetary value of the inputs marginal product is equal to the additional cost
of using that input. Monetary value of the input is;
MPl
Px MPl
Profit Maximization requires
w Px CMPl
Px Price of final output
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
75/129
75
w Wage rate (Cost of input)
1.6 Isocost
The isocost line is the locus of all combinations of factors the firm can purchase with a
given monetary cost outlay. If a firm uses only L & K, the total cost or expenditure of
the firm can be represented by:
C wL rK
One can solve Optimization problem for the combination of inputs that either
minimizes total cost subject to a given constraint on output
OR
maximizes output subject to a given total cost constraint.
1.7 Isocost Curve and Optimal Combination of L and K
Optimal input Combination Depends on the relative prices of inputs and the degree to
which they can be substituted for each other represented by the point of tangency
between Isocost and Isoquant.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
76/129
76
MPlMP
k
fffffffffffffff w
r
ffff
1.8 Production with Two(or more) Outputs-Economies of Scope
Economies of scope exist when the unit cost of producing two or more
products/services jointly is lower than producing them separately,
producing related products, and the products that are complementary.
The average total cost of production decreases as a result of increasing the
number of different goods produced
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
77/129
77
End Chapter quizzes :
Q.1. Production function states
(a) Qualitative relationship between input and output
(b) Quantitative relationship between input and output
(c) Technical relationship between input and output
(d) No relationship between input and output
Q.2 Total output is maximum where
(a) Marginal production is maximum
(b) Marginal production is zero
(c) Average production is maximum
(d) Average production is zero
Q.3 The law of variable proportions states that given at least one input constant the
marginal product of variable factor
(a) Increases
(b) Decreases
(c) Remain constant
(d) Fluctuates
Q.4 Returns to scale means
(a) Change in output due to change in one variable factor of production
(b) Change in output due to change in one constant factor of production
(c) Change in output due to change in all variable factors of production
(d) Change in output due to change in all constant factor of production
Q.5 The slope of isoquant is called
(a) Marginal rate of technical substitution
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
78/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
79/129
79
(a)MP
l
MPk
fffffffffffffff>
w
r
ffff
(b)MPlMP
k
fffffffffffffff gd> gc
d) (d) ga6 gda6 gc
Q.7 The relationship between discretionary investment and managers utility
maximization is
a) Positively high
b) Positively low
c) Negatively high
d) Negatively low
Q.8 Owners utility maximization is determined by
a) Revenue maximization
b) Profit maximization
c) Investment maximization
d) Prices maximization
Q.9 Satisficing behavior theory states that
a) Firm is a coalition of harmonized interest groups
b) Firm is a coalition of conflicting interest groups
c) Firm is not a coalition of interest groups
d) Firm is a single goal entity
Q.10 Satisficing behavior theory focuses on
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
105/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
106/129
106
Chapter-VIII
Market Structure
Contents:
1.1 Introduction1.2 Meaning of market
1.3 Classification of Market Structure
1.3.1 Perfect Competition
1.3.1.1 Price Output Determination Under Perfect
Competition
1.3.1.2 Equilibrium in Short Run
1.3.1.3 Perfect Competition in the Long Run1.3.1.4 Perfect Competition and Plant Size
1.3.1.5 Perfect Competition and the LR Supply Curve
1.3.1.6 Long Run Equilibrium
1.3.2 Monopoly Market
1.3.2.1 Why do Monopolies exist?
1.3.2.2 Equilibrium of the Firm
1.3.2.3 Price Discrimination
1.3.3 Monopolistic Competition
1.3.3.1 Structure
1.3.3.2 Short Run Equilibrium
1.3.3.3 Long Run Equilibrium
1.3.3.4 Efficiency under Monopolistic Competition
1.3.4 Oligopoly Market
1.3.4.1 Structure
1.3.4.2 Mutual Interdependence
1.3.4.3 Collusion is difficult if
1.3.4.4 Explicit Collusion Cartels
1.3.4.5 Sweezeys Model of Kinked Demand Curve
1.3.4.6 Price Stability with a Kinked Demand
Curve
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
107/129
107
1.3.4.7 Tacit Collusion: Price Leadership
1.3.4.7.1 Dominant Firm Price Leadership
1.3.4.7.2 Barometric Price Leadership
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
108/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
109/129
109
1.3.1 Perfect Competition
Characteristics of Perfect Competition:
Large number of small sellers and buyers: The number of buyer as well as
seller is so large that the share of each buyer in total market demand and the
share of each seller in total market supply is insignificant and hence no
individual buyer or seller can influence the market price.
Homogeneous products: Products supplied by the firms are identical and are
regarded as perfect substitute to each other.
Perfect mobility of factors of production: For a market to be perfectly
competitive, the factors of production must be in the position of moving freely
into or out of the industry and from one firm to another.
Free entry and free exit of the firms: No legal or otherwise restrictions on the
entry and exit of the firms.
Perfect dissemination of the information: to the buyers and sellers.
No government intervention and Absence of collusion.
Examples: Agricultural commodities and Stock market
1.3.1.1 Price Output Determination Under Perfect Competition
In a perfectly competitive market, where large number of sellers selling homogeneous
product, no single seller can influence the market price. Similarly, each buyer has too
small share in total market demand to influence the price. Market Price is therefore
determined by the market demand and market supply for the industry and is given for
each individual firm and for each buyer. Thus, a seller in a perfectly competitive market
is a price-taker not a price maker. This means the individual firm will face a
horizontal demand curve. It will be horizontal at the market price, established by
supply and demand on the market as a whole.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
110/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
111/129
111
In the long run, entry and exit become possible. Why? Because potential firms can buy
fixed inputs and become actual firms. And existing firms can sell off or stop renting
their fixed inputs and go out of business.Firms will choose to enter the industry if the existing firms in the industry are making
economic profits. The profits are an incentive to enter. As a result the total market
supply will increase and, therefore, the market supply curve must shift to the right. It
drives down the price on the market, thereby reducing the profits of each firm.
Now the firms are making profits, but smaller profits than before. But if there are still
economic profits being made, more firms will enter. This must continue until there are
no economic profits. What has to be true when profits equal zero?
TR = TC
p*q = qATC
p* = ATC
So entry finally stops when firms are producing at their lowest average total cost. Here
is a diagram of the final, long-run equilibrium under perfect competition:
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
112/129
112
What if typical firm is making losses? Then the reverse process will take place. Firms
will exit the market, causing a left shift of market supply, causing a rise in market price,
causing a reduction of losses. This continues until losses are zero. Thus, Long Run
competitive equilibrium consists of two conditions:
p* = MC
p* = minimum ATC
The first condition is caused purely by profit maximization, and its true in both the SR
and the LR. The second condition, however, is caused by entry and exit in the LR. Itwont necessarily be true in the SR.
These two conditions have important efficiency implications. Marginal-cost pricing (p*=
MC) means that consumers who buy the product face the true opportunity cost of their
choices. They will only buy the good if the value to them is greater than the price,
which represents the value of the resources that went into making the product.
Minimum average cost pricing (p* = minimum ATC) means that the product is being
made at the lowest average cost possible, so that no resources are being wasted in its
production.
The conclusion that firms make zero profit in the LR may seem odd, given the profits
that many firms earn in reality. What could explain the difference between theory and
reality? (1) Reality may differ from the perfectly competitive model, and to that extent
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
113/129
113
economic profits can be made. But also, (2) the profits we generally hear about are
accounting profits, not economic profits. To find out whether these profitable firms
are really making economic profits, wed need more information about their implicit
costs.Finally, (3) we may be observing short-run profits, not long-run profits.
1.3.1.4 Perfect Competition and Plant Size
It turns out that the perfectly competitive firm produces not just at the minimum of its
SRATC, but also its LRATC. Why? Because any PC firm not at its minimum LRATC
will, in the LR, change its input combination to take advantage of lower average costs.
If firms are able to make positive profits by moving outward on the LRATC curve,
those profits will attract entrants into the industry in the usual fashion. So by the same
arguments as before, profits will eventually dissipate to zero. The price must be at the
bottom of the LRATC, not just the SRATC.
1.3.1.5 Perfect Competition and the LR Supply Curve
As we have seen, changes in demand in a PC market create profits and losses for firms.
In the SR, this has no effect on the supply curve; but in the LR, firms enter for profits
and leave to escape losses, leading to supply curve shifts. We want to use this
information to derive a LR supply curve. A LR supply curve, just like a SR supply
curve, shows the total quantity that will be supplied in a market at different prices; but
unlike the SR supply curve, it shows the quantity supplied after all long-term changes,
including entry and exit of firms, have been taken into account.
In the basic supply-and-demand framework, notice that we can use demand
curves and equilibrium points to trace out the supply curve. If you look at three
different demand curves, and then mark the equilibrium point on each one, you can
connect the equilibrium points to find where the supply curve must be.
Now were going to use the same basic technique to trace out the LR supply curve. We
can do this by changing demand, and then finding the equilibrium points after allowing
LR adjustments, including entry and exit. Start with an initial (short-run) supply and
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
114/129
114
demand. If we are in long-run equilibrium, profits are zero. Now, let demand shift to
the right. In the short-run, price rises a lot. But the higher price creates profits, and
profits attract entry in the long run. So eventually supply shifts to the right as well,
pushing price back down (though possibly not as low as it was before). Once profits areback to zero again, youre in a new long-run equilibrium. Do this all again to find a
third long run equilibrium, and then connect the dots to get the long-run supply curve.
The interpretation of the LR supply curve is pretty much the same as the SR supply
curve: it shows the willingness of producers to sell at each price. But the LR supply
curve measures this willingness in the broadest sense, including all firms that might
potentially supply this product.
Notice that the LR supply curve is flatter than the SR supply curve. This must be so,
since the LR supply curve takes into account the quantity responses of all firms, not just
the ones currently in the market, but potential firms as well. It is even possible that the
LR supply curve can be downward-sloping. Why?
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
115/129
115
Consider what must happen if entry and exit do not affect the cost curves of individual
firms. Then after all adjustment to a change in demand has taken place, the market
price must have returned to the lowest point on the LRATC, which is exactly where it
was before. So in this case, the LR supply curve must be horizontal. We call this aconstant--cost industry. This is most likely to be the case when the industry in question
constitutes only a small portion of the demand for its inputs.
If the industry in question has a large impact on the markets for its inputs, then the LR
supply curve may slope upward or downward. If the effect of entry into the industry is
tobid up the price of inputs, so that a firms cost curves rise as a result of the entry of
new firms, then the market price after adjustment will be higher than it was before. In
this case, the LR supply curve must be upward-sloping as in the picture above; this is
called an increasing-cost industry, which results from external diseconomies. On the
other hand, if entry into the industry creates a greater demand for inputs that allows
those inputs to be produced through mass production techniques (i.e., at lower average
cost), then the industry can benefit from lower costs of production. In this case, the LR
supply curve is downward-sloping. This is called a decreasing-cost industry, which
results from external economies. They face a perfectly elastic demand curve Market
prices change only if demand and supply change
1.3.1.6 Long Run Equilibrium
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
116/129
116
Normal profit is necessary to attract and maintain capital investment
Marginal Analysis
MR = MC => Normal Profits
Output will settle at the point where;
P = MC = AC = MR
1.3.1.7 Supply Curve under Perfect Competition
Short Run Firm Supply MC curve is the SR supply curve so long as P > AVC
Long Run firm Supply LMC curve is the LRsupply curve so long as P > ATC
In the LR, the firm must cover all necessary costs of production and earn a
normal profit
1.3.2 Monopoly Market
A monopoly market is one in which there is only one seller of a product having no close
substitutes. The firm has substantial control over the price. Further, if product is
differentiated and if there are no threats of new firms entering the same business, a
monopoly firm can manage to earn excessive profits over a long period.
Only one firm produces the product
Low cross elasticity of demand between the monopolists product and any other
product; that is no close substitute products.
Substantial barriers to entry that prevents competition from entering the
industry.
1.3.2.1 Why do Monopolies exist?
Barriers to Entry
a) Control of scarce resources or input
b) Economies of scale natural monopolies
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
117/129
117
c) Technological superiority
d) Govt. created barriers
e) Patents
1.3.2.2 Equilibrium of the Firm
Monopoly firms ability to set price is limited by the demand elasticity
Supernormal profits may be earned in the Long Run since there is no entry
P > competitive price
Q < competitive quantity
The monopolist will always try to operate on the elastic portion of the demand
curve
1.3.2.3 Price Discrimination
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
118/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
119/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
120/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
121/129
121
three firms is characterized by marked differentiation in products The nature of
products is such that very often one finds entry of new firms difficult. Oligopoly is
characterized by vigorous competition where firms manipulate both prices and
volumes in an attempt to outsmart their rivals. No generalization can be made aboutprofitability scenarios.
1.3.4.1 Structure
In an oligopoly there are very few sellers of the good.
The product may be differentiated among the sellers (e.g. automobiles) or
homogeneous (e.g. petrol).
Homogenous product Pure Oligopoly
Entry is often limited
by legal restrictions (e.g. banking in most of the world)
by a very large minimum efficient scale
by strategic behavior.
1.3.4.2 Mutual Interdependence
The essence of an oligopolistic industry is the need for each firm to consider
how its own actions affect the decisions of its relatively few competitors
To predict the outcome in such a market, economists need to model the
interaction between firms.
Oligopoly may be characterized by Collusion Cartels Or Non - Cooperation
1.3.4.3 Collusion is difficult if
There are many firms in the industry
The product is not standardized
Demand and cost conditions are changing rapidly
There are no barriers to entry
Firms have surplus capacity
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
122/129
122
1.3.4.4 Explicit Collusion Cartels
A Cartel is a formal organization of sellers that seeks to restrict competition
Maximum possible profits that can accrue as a result of a cartel is the amount
that would prevail under Monopoly
If the firms compete vigorously on the basis of price, lowest possible
equilibrium price that could prevail is the competitive price and output
1.3.4.5 Sweezeys Model of Kinked Demand Curve
Explains Price Rigidity under Oligopoly
Starts with a predetermined Price Output
Demand Curve is kinked at current price:
The firm may expect rivals to respond if it reduces its price so, demand in
response to a price reduction is likely to be relatively inelastic
For a price rise, rivals are less likely to react, so demand may be relatively
elastic
1.3.4.6 Price Stability with a Kinked Demand Curve
For any MC between a and b, the profit maximizing price and output remain
unchanged.
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
123/129
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
124/129
124
There is no one dominant firm
Price changes are in response to changes in some underlying market conditions,
obvious to all the firms
The critical requirement for being a leader is the ability to interpret marketconditions and propose price changes that other firms are willing to follow
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
125/129
125
End Chapter quizzes
Q.1. Banking Sector is an example of
(a) Perfect Market
(b) Monopolistic Market
(c) Oligopoly Market
(d) Monopoly Market
Q.2 Which is not the characteristic of a perfect market
(a) Large number of small buyers and sellers
(b) Restricted entry and exit
(c) Homogeneous Products
(d) Free mobility of factors of production
Q.3. Profit maximizing condition for a firm is
(a) MR=MC.
(b) MR>MC
(c) MR
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
126/129
126
(c) Profit maximizing Output in Oligopoly market
(d) Profit maximizing Output in Monopoly market
Q.6. A formal organization of sellers that seeks to restrict competition is known as
(a) Sellers Association
(b) Cartel
(c) Trade Union
(d) Trade Association
Q.7. Which condition is false in case of a monopoly firm to earn excessive profits
over a long period
(a) Only one firm produces the product
(b) Low cross elasticity of demand between the monopolists product and any
other product; that is no close substitute products.
(c) Free entry of new firms
(d) Substantial barriers to entry that prevents competition from entering the
industry.
Q.8. Price Discrimination under Monopoly is not possible if
(a) Different markets are separable.
(b) Elasticity of demand is same in different markets.
( c) Market is imperfect.
(d) Elasticity of demand is different in different markets.
Q.9. In a Perfectly competitive market, in long run, firm earns
(a) Abnormal Profits
(b) Supernormal Profits
(c) Normal Profits
(d) Economic Profits
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
127/129
127
Q.10. Demand curve of a firm in perfect competitive market is
(a) Upward sloping
(b) Downward sloping
(c) Horizontal
(d) Vertical
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
128/129
128
Key to End Chapter Quizzes
ChapterI Managerial Decision Making
1 (b ); 2(a ); 3(c ); 4(a ); 5(a ); 6(c ); 7(b ); 8(b ); 9(a ); 10(d )
ChapterII Business Forecasting
1 (c ); 2(a ); 3(d ); 4(d ); 5(d ); 6(a ); 7(d ); 8(b ); 9(b ); 10(c )
ChapterIII Demand Analysis
1 (b ); 2(a ); 3(b ); 4(b ); 5(c ); 6(d ); 7(a ); 8(b ); 9(c ); 10(b )
ChapterIV Cost Analysis
1 (b ); 2(a ); 3(a ); 4(c ); 5(a ); 6(b ); 7(c ); 8(a ); 9(b ); 10(a )
ChapterV Production Analysis
1 (c ); 2(b ); 3(b ); 4(b ); 5(a ); 6(d ); 7(a ); 8(d ); 9(c ); 10(b )
ChapterVI Pricing Policy of the Firm
1 (b ); 2(c ); 3(c ); 4(b ); 5(b ); 6(b ); 7(a ); 8(d ); 9(c ); 10(a )
ChapterVII Objectives of the firm
1 (b ); 2(b ); 3(b ); 4(d ); 5(d ); 6(b ); 7(a ); 8(b ); 9(b ); 10(b )
ChapterVIII Market Structure
1 (c ); 2(b ); 3(a ); 4(d ); 5(a ); 6(b ); 7(c ); 8(b ); 9(c ); 10(c )
-
7/30/2019 Managerial Economics 07042011
129/129
Bibliography
Parl R Ferguson,Glenys J Ferguson(2000), Business Economics, Macmillan,
London.
K. E. Boulding(1948), Economic Analysis Harper and Bros., New York.
Koutsoyiannis,A.(1979), Modern Microeconomics, Macmillan, London.
K. E. Boulding(1966), Economic Analysis: Microeconomics Harper and Bros.,
New York.
Browning, E.K. and Browning, J.M., Microeconomic Theory and Application,
Scott Foresman and Co., London.
Stigler George J.(1966), The Theory of Price, Macmillan, New York.
Mansfield,E.(1970), Microeconomics- Theory and Application, W.W. Norton and
Co., New York.
RH Dholakia and A.N Oza(1997), Microeconomics for Management Studies,
Oxford University Press.
Ivan Png(2004), Managerial Economics, 2nd Edition, Blackwell Publishers.
Baumol, William, J.(1972), Economics Theory and Operations Analysis, Prentice
Hall of India, New Delhi.
Pindyek & Rubinfield(2004), Microeconomics, Prentice Hall of India, New Delhi.
Mansfield,E.(1996), Managerial Economics- Theory Application, and Cases, W.W.
Norton and Co., New York.Salvatore D (1989) Managerial Economics McGraw Hill New York