title feeding strategies of japanese monkeys( dissertation ... · feeding strategies of japanese...

47
Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation_全文 ) Author(s) Nakagawa, Naofumi Citation Kyoto University (京都大学) Issue Date 1989-03-23 URL http://dx.doi.org/10.14989/doctor.k4162 Right Type Thesis or Dissertation Textversion author Kyoto University

Upload: others

Post on 24-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation_全文 )

Author(s) Nakagawa, Naofumi

Citation Kyoto University (京都大学)

Issue Date 1989-03-23

URL http://dx.doi.org/10.14989/doctor.k4162

Right

Type Thesis or Dissertation

Textversion author

Kyoto University

Page 2: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

学位申請論文中川尚史

Page 3: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality

Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Naofumi Nakagawa Primate Research Institute, Kyoto University,

Kanrin, Inuyama, Aichi, 484, Japan

Key Words: Feeding strategies, Habitat quality, Feeding speed, Cool temperate forest, Winter, Macaca fuscata

Page 4: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

ABSTRACT. Field observations of the feeding behaviour of

Japanese monkeys were carried out from autumn to winter on

Kinkazan Island which is covered with cool temperate forest. As

a result, the following two points became clear: (1) the

available food items were fixed for a long time; and (2) the

habitat quality deteriorated monotonously because the monkeys

themselves or their competitors, such as wild mice, utilized the

food resources. Against the decrease in food intake caused by

this deterioration of the habitat quality, the monkeys controlled

the decrease in food intake by employing the following strategies:

(1) they recovered their feeding speed by exploiting new food

patches (patch-increase strategy); (2) they extended the time

spent ,on feeding (time-extension strategy); and (3) they changed

their food (food-change strategy). The former two strategies

operated earlier than the third one.

INTRODUCTION

Among non-human primates, the Japanese monkey (Macaca fuscata)

is the species whose distribution is the most northerly in the

world. Many studies on the adaptation to cold districts have

been carried out from various standpoints, such as the morphology,

physiology, ecology etc. of this species (e.g. Suzuki, 1965;

Wada, 1975; Watanabe, 1975; Tokura et al., 1981; Wada & Tokida,

- 1 -

Page 5: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

1981). However, studies on the feeding ecology of Japanese

monkeys in snowy areas have concentrated on the food items and

frequency of feeding on each item, habitat utilization, travel

distance, home range size, etc. Research on adaptational

strategy in the feeding behaviour of Japanese monkeys, based on

estimations of the food intake or of the food environment in the

home range, has never been carried out.

Deterioration of habitat quality generally occurs in cool

temperate forest from autumn to winter- The present study was

undertaken to clarify what kinds of feeding strategy the Japanese

monkey employs against deterioration of its habitat quality. A

field survey was conducted on Kinkazan Island, which is covered

by cool temperate forest with a vegetation zone similar to that

of snowy areas.

STUDY AREA AND MATERIALS

Kinkazan Island lies about 700 m offshore at its shortest

distance from the Oshika Peninsula, Miyagi Prefecture (38°16'N,

141°35'E). The island is 5.1 km long and 3.7 km across. The

total area is about 10 km2. The highest peak is 444.9 m above

sea level (Fig. 1).

The mean annual temperature is 11°C and the mean annual

rainfall is about 1500 mm. This island is seldom covered with

- 2 -

Page 6: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

snow, although it does sometimes snow in winter-

The vertical distribution of vegetation on the island can be

divided roughly into three: a Fagus crenata zone at more than 200

m above sea level; an Abies firma zone at less than 200 m above

sea level; and a Pinus thunbergii zone around the coast. Besides

this, several grasslands are patchily distributed on the island,

and are dominated by Zoysia japonica, Miscanthus sinensis, and

Pteridium aquilinum (Yoshii & Yoshioka, 1949; Takatsuki, 1980).

The vegetation is strongly influenced by Sika deer which densely

inhabit the island. Therefore, the sub-high tree stratum and low

tree stratum are hardly developed (e.g. Yoshioka, 1960).

The Japanese monkeys on this island have been surveyed

intermittently since 1959 and reports on the population size and

food habits have been presented (Yoshiba, 1959; Izawa, 1963a,b;

Izawa & Nishida, 1963; Azuma et al., 1967; Yoshihiro, 1980).

Individual identification and long-term continuous observation

by habituation have been carried out by Izawa since 1982 (Izawa,

1983, 1985a,b).

At present, more than 200 monkeys forming 5 troops inhabit

the island. The A-troop of 20 animals which was habituated by

Sato, Izawa and others was chosen as the subject of this study-

- 3 -

Page 7: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

METHODS

A preliminary study was carried out from October 22, 1984

to November 12, 1984. The regular study was then carried out

from November 13, 1984 to February 13, 1985 and from October 16,

1985 to December 1, 1985. The total focal animal sampling time was

736 hours 16 min.

The method of data collection was by focal animal sampling

(Altmann, 1974). As a rule, one individual was followed all day

long. Three adult females, 1 young female and 2 adult males were

chosen as focal animals in 1984, while 5 adult females were

chosen in 1985. The focal animal was changed day by day-

However, the data for all individuals were analyzed together in

this paper because the age-sex difference in the data was

considered trivial.

Data were recorded as follows. The activities were divided

into 4 categories, that is, feeding, moving, resting, and social

activities, and were recorded in seconds. The food items were

also recorded during feeding. When the duration of a feeding

bout (as described later) on beech-seeds (Fagus crenata) and on

torreya-seeds (Torreya nucifera) exceeded 5 min, the feeding

speed (as described later) was calculated. Middle and high trees

of food patches where the duration of a feeding bout exceeded 5

min were marked with vinyl number tape and their location was

recorded exactly on a map.

- 4 -

Page 8: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

The terms used in this paper may be defined as follows.

Feeding bout: Continuous feeding on the same food item for

more than 1 min. However, when the interval between two

continuous feedings on the same food item for more than 1 min was

less than 2 min and, moreover, when the total moving time in this

interval was less than 1 min, these two continuous feedings were

regarded as one feeding bout (Ex. 1). Thus, when the total

moving time in this interval was more than 1 min (Ex. 2) or when

this interval was more than 2 min (Ex. 3), the activity was

regarded as two different feeding bouts (Fig. 2).

Food patch: One tree where feeding had been observed was

usually regarded as one food patch. However, when beech-seeds

and torreya-seeds were consumed on the ground, a food patch could

not be specified because of their continuous distribution. In

this case, the site within a radius of 15 m from the trunk of a

beech and of 10 m from the trunk of a torreya tree was regarded

as one food patch for the sake of convenience.

Feeding speed: The quotient of food intake divided by feeding

time. The actual method for measuring the feeding speed was

different between beech-seeds and torreya-seeds, as follows.

Beech-seeds: When the monkeys came to the site where beech-seeds

had fallen, they sat down, pushing fallen leaves aside and picked

up seeds one by one with one or both hands. Picking up some

seeds, they stood up and took a few steps. They then sat down

and began to pick up some seeds again. The time duration from

- 5 -

Page 9: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

sitting down to standing up was measured with a stop-watch and

the number of beech-seeds eaten during that time was counted.

The feeding speed in a feeding bout was calculated by averaging

the quotient of the number of seeds eaten divided by the time

duration. The proportion of empty seeds and insect-damaged

seeds was very high. Judging from the behaviour of the monkeys,

however, they did not appear to eat only sound seeds (as

described later). One seed was therefore counted as one seed

even if it was an empty or insect-damaged one. Torreya-seeds: In

some cases, the monkeys sat down and picked up seeds just as in

the case of beech-seed feeding. In other cases, they pick them

up during a walk. The feeding speed in a feeding bout was

calculated by the following two methods. 1) A hand-held computer

with a built-in clock (EPSON HC-20) was employed. By means of

pushing the key board, the time when a monkey took a seed into

its mouth was automatically recorded. In this case, the feeding

speed was calculated from the total data input-time and total

number of seeds eaten. 2) The alternative method was as follows.

One-minute units were randomly set up in a feeding bout, and the

feeding speed was calculated by averaging the number of seeds

eaten per one-minute unit. The monkeys never ate all the albumen

of a seed , even if they chewed and broke it. However, the seed

was taken as eaten, since they usually left almost the same

amount of albumen.

Number of seeds eaten in one day: This term was employed only

- 6 -

Page 10: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

in beech-seed feeding. For feeding bouts in which the feeding

speed was measured, the number of seeds eaten was calculated by

multiplying the average feeding speed in each bout by the

duration of each feeding bout. For feeding bouts in which the

feeding speed was not measured or for feeding lasting less than 1

min, the number was calculated by multiplying the daily average

feeding speed by the total duration. The numbers of seeds eaten

were then summed to give an estimated value for the number of

seeds eaten in one day.

RESULTS

The main food of the monkeys was beech-seeds in 1984 because

of the good beech crop. In contrast, the main food was

torreya-seeds in 1985 due to a bad beech crop and a good torreya

crop. The data for 1984 and the data for 1985 were therefore

analyzed independently-

Beech-seeds in 1984

The beech crop was super-abundant in the autumn of 1984. The

monkeys sometimes ate beech-seeds in the trees during the

preliminary study- However, they ate them only on the ground

during the regular study period because almost all the fruits had

- 7 -

Page 11: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

fallen. The A-troop ranged mainly in the Fagus crenata zone

throughout this study period. The home range size was 154 ha.

The study period was divided into 6 periods by half-months as

follows: the latter half of November, the , former half of

December, the latter half of December, the former half of

January, the latter half of January, and the former half of

February. The food items were classified roughly into 5

categories as follows: (A) beech-seeds, which were always eaten

from autumn to winter; (B) autumn food, comprising fruits which

ripened and became available in autumn, but became non-available

before long because of their disappearance due to consumption,

roting, outflow, etc.; (C, D) winter food, which was not eaten or

eaten only a little in autumn despite its availability, but began

to be eaten with lapse of time, and could be divided into the 2

categories of (D) barks and buds typical of winter and (C) other

winter food; and (E) others items including soils and unidentified

species (Table 1). Fruits of Viscum album were the only food

item which became newly available in winter because the fruits

ripened in winter. The time spent feeding on insects was

excluded from the time spent feeding because insect-feeding

rarely occurred.

Fig. 3 shows the proportion of time spent feeding on each

food category with respect to the total feeding time in each

period. Beech-seeds were one of the main food items throughout

the study period and represented about 70% of the total. Food

- 8 -

Page 12: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

items other than beech-seeds changed gradually with lapse of

time.

The change in feeding speed on beech-seeds is shown in Fig.

4. Since each data point is based on the average feeding speed

for each feeding bout, the standard deviation reflects the degree

of unevenness in feeding speed among the feeding bouts in each

period. Moreover, when the feeding bouts differed from each

other, the food patch was usually also different. It was

considered therefore that the standard deviation reflected the

degree of unevenness in feeding speed among the food patches.

The feeding speed was generally correlated to the food density.

This was suggested by the following findings.

From the latter half of November to the former half of

February, the feeding speed decreased monotonously with lapse of

time. From the latter half of November to the former half of

December, the feeding speed was very high and the values in both

periods were almost equal (4.7 sec/seed). Also, the standard

deviation was small; that is, the degree of unevenness was

apparently small among the food patches. On the other hand, the

feeding speed decreased with lapse of time (12.7 sec/seed) and

the unevenness became increasingly larger among the food patches.

The factors underlying these changes in feeding speed were

considered to be as follows. From the latter half of November to

the former half of December, the feeding speed converged at

maximum because only a short time had passed since the beech

- 9 -

Page 13: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

fruits had fallen to the ground and the fallen seed density was

very high. Subsequently, the feeding speed became dependent on

the fallen seed density as the density dropped with lapse of

time. Animals, including monkeys, non-uniformly utilize beech-seed

patches and the fruit production differs among individual beech

trees. This caused the unevenness in quality among the food

patches to become larger- As a result, the variance in feeding

speed became larger- Thus, the data in Fig. 4 indicate a

correlation between food density and feeding speed, and the

feeding speed is therefore employed as an index of food density

in this paper.

As the quality of the food patches deteriorated with lapse of

time, the monkeys extended the proportion of their time spent

feeding on beech-seeds with respect to the observation time from

27.0% to 48.7%. As a result, they extended the proportion of the

total feeding time to the observation time from 34.4% to 66.3%

(Fig. 5). The latter value was much higher than the 24%

obtained at Yakushima (Maruhashi, 1981), 29% at Koshima (Kuroki,

1975) and 28% at Takagoyama (Yotsumoto, 1976).

The number of beech-seeds eaten per one-hour observation time

was estimated. The mean values for each period are shown in Fig.

6. Since decreasing feeding speed influenced the number of seeds

eaten more strongly than extension of the feeding time did, the

number of seeds eaten decreased with lapse of time.

The present study period was divided into 2 periods: November

- 10 -

Page 14: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

and December, when the food other than beech-seeds was mainly

autumn food; and January and February, when the food other than

beech-seeds was mainly winter food (see Fig. 3). The proportion

of time spent feeding on food other than beech-seeds with respect

to the total feeding time was calculated, and the value before

3:00 p.m. was compared with that after 3:00 p.m. in each of the

2 periods (Table 2). The value after 3:00 p.m. was higher than

that before 3:00 p.m. in both periods, but a significant

difference was observed only in the January and February period

(t-test, P<0.05). Judging from this result and the data in Fig.

6, the number of seeds eaten does not decrease significantly in

the evening in autumn when large numbers of beech-seeds were

eaten. In winter when only small numbers of seeds were eaten,

the winter food was eaten in the evening as a means of

supplementing the shortage of beech-seeds.

The beech-seed feeding by wild mice, and the fertility and

insect-damage of beech-seeds, etc. were also examined.

First, the average feeding speed on beech-seeds shown in Fig.

4 was separated into the feeding speed in each feeding bout (Fig.

7). As mentioned, the unevenness in quality among the food

patches became greater with lapse of time. Moreover, the quality

of the food patch itself gradually deteriorated in every patch

regardless of whether the monkeys ate beech-seeds there or not.

It is considered therefore that the deterioration of the

beech-seed patches was more strongly influenced by other factors

- 11 -

Page 15: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

which acted uniformly on all food patches than by feeding by the

monkeys. Miguchi and Maruyama (1984), who conducted an ecological

study on Japanese beech forest, reported that 60-70% of the total

fallen beech-seeds were eaten by wild mice in a mastyear. In

view of the fact that at least Apodemus argenteus lives on

Kinkazan Island (Ohta, 1967) and that a super-abundant crop of

beech fruits slightly influenced the Apodemus argenteus population

increase (Miguchi, 1983), it is quite possible that the uniform

deterioration of the beech-seed patch is influenced by mouse-

feeding.

Data concerning the fertility and insect-damage of the seeds

are given in Table 3. With lapse of time, the proportion of

empty seeds was constant (about 40%), but the proportion of sound

seeds decreased and the proportion of insect-damaged seeds

increased. Beech-seeds are not damaged by insects after falling

(Miguchi & Maruyama, 1984). Judging from the monkeys' behaviour,

they did not appear to eat only sound seeds. Considering all

these observations, the decrease in proportion of sound seeds

seemed to result from selective feeding on sound seeds by other

animals, probably wild mice.

Comparing these results with those for other localities

(Table 4), the proportion of sound seeds was comparatively low in

the present study- This appeared to reflect the fact that the

sample seeds of the present study were collected from December to

February, at many days after the seeds had fallen, whereas the

- 12 -

Page 16: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

sample seeds in the other studies were collected soon after

falling. This again suggested selective feeding on sound seeds

by other animals. Judging from all these findings, the decrease

in number of sound seeds eaten with lapse of time seemed to occur

more rapidly than the data shown in Fig. 6.

Finally, the feeding strategy through increasing food patches

against deterioration of the food patch quality was examined

(Fig. 8). Only feeding bouts lasting for more than 5 min were

analyzed. The number of food patches always continued to

increase throughout the study period as the number of feeding

bouts increased. Although the monkeys appeared to employ the

patch-increase strategy, recovery of feeding speed could not be

confirmed as already shown (see Figs. 4 and 7), that is, this

strategy seem to be ineffectual. It is possible that feeding on

fallen beech-seeds by wild mice influenced the situation as

demonstrated above.

Torreya-seeds in 1985

The torreya crop was super-abundant in the autumn of 1985,

although the beech fruits failed. The monkeys picked up and ate

torreya-seeds usually on the ground but sometimes in the trees.

Seven items were compared between the beech-seed and torreya-seed

feeding (Table 5).

Fig. 9 shows the changes in cumulative numbers of feeding

- 13 -

Page 17: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

bouts and food patches. Only feeding bouts lasting more than 5

min were analyzed in this study. From November 14 to 21, the

number of food patches saturated for a time, although the number

of feeding bouts was increasing. The number of food patches then

began to increase again from November 22. The study period was

divided into 6 periods of about a week. The changes in average

feeding speed are shown in Fig. 10. When the number of food

patches saturated (from November 14 to 21), the feeding speed

decreased to 19.5 sec/seed, but it recovered to 12.4 sec/seed

when food patches were newly exploited.

Fig. 11 shows the changes of feeding speed in each feeding

bout. When the number of food patches saturated (from Wovermber

14 to 21), the feeding speed decreased markedly in repeatedly

utilized food patches as expected. This finding suggested that

deterioration of the food patch quality was caused by the feeding

carried out by the monkeys. This could be ascribed to the much

lower density of fallen torreya-seeds than of beech-seeds. On

the other hand, when the monkeys exploited new food patches after

November 22, the feeding speed was high in the newly exploited

patches. This suggested that there was no competitor to the

monkeys for the torreya-seeds when the seeds were covered with

pulp. Thus, a food patch which the monkeys visited for the first

time retained the same high quality as at the time of fruit-falling,

and whether the quality of a torreya-seed patch was high or not

was influenced by the visits and feeding by the troop.

- 14 -

Page 18: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

The newly exploited food patches were plotted on a map (Fig.

12). The area enclosed by the solid line shows the home range

during the study period. Since the monkeys ranged over almost

the same area before November 21 as in the study period, the

areas in which they newly exploited food patches of torreya-seeds

had also been utilized for moving or for feeding on other food

items. Thus, new patches were exploited only within the range

which the troop had been utilizing before November 21. The

distribution pattern of new food patches appeared to show that

the monkeys newly exploited food patches in the peripheral area

of the distribution of torreya trees which was located as a broad

clump only around the shrine. The monkeys thus employed a

strategy whereby they newly exploited food patches in the

peripheral area of the torreya distribution and, in consequence,

recovered their feeding speed against the deterioration of the

quality of the torreya-seed patches by caused their feeding.

Just as in the case of beech-seeds, the monkeys extended the

proportion of their time spent feeding on torreya-seeds with

respect to the observation time from 10.3% in P1 to 20.2% in P6.

As a result, they extended the proportion of the total feeding

time to the observation time from 46.0% in P1 to 62.8% in P6.

However, they did not eat the typical winter food (barks and

buds) even in P6. In addition, the proportion of time spent

feeding on other winter food (for example, Oplismenus

undulatifolius and Ixeris stolonifera) to the total feeding time

- 15 -

Page 19: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

was only 10.4% even in P6.

DISCUSSION

The feeding strategies of the Japanese monkeys on Kinkazan

Island from late autumn to late winter are shown schematically in

Fig. 13.

On Kinkazan Island, the autumn food including beech-seeds and

torreya-seeds, decreased from autumn to winter- As a result, the

quality of the habitat surrounding the monkeys deteriorated.

This was reflected in the data for beech-seeds and torreya-seeds

as main foods.

In the case of beech-seeds, the habitat quality deteriorated

because fallen seeds were probably consumed by wild mice.

Consequently, the monkeys controlled the decrease in their

beech-seed intake by extending their feeding time on beech-seeds.

They then changed their food other than beech-seeds from autumn

food to winter food. This change advanced as follows. Since the

beech-seed intake decreased in winter, the winter food was eaten

in the evening as a means of supplementing the decreased beech

intake. Even on the last observation day, February 13, 1985, the

time spent feeding on beech-seeds still represented 70% of the

total feeding time. The change to winter food was thus

incomplete. However, Izawa (pers. comm.) has observed that the

- 16 -

Page 20: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

monkeys did not eat beech-seeds but ate only winter food in early

March, 1985. This suggests that the monkeys do not extend their

feeding time on beech-seeds forever, but that they eventually

stop feeding on them and change their food entirely to winter

food. In the case of torreya-seeds, of which the fallen number

is much fewer than that of beech-seeds, when the habitat quality

deteriorated because of feeding by the monkeys themselves, the

monkeys recovered their feeding speed by exploiting new food

patches.

The above analysis of feeding indicates that the feeding

strategies used by the monkeys operate against a decrease of food

intake to a certain level caused by deterioration of the habitat

quality- The strategies can be separated into three, as follows:

strategy-1), a patch-increase strategy; strategy-2), a time-

extension strategy; and strategy-3) , a food-change strategy.

Moreover, the former two strategies are considered to operate

earlier than the third one.

The Japanese monkeys live in cool temperate forest where the

seasonal changes in environment are large but predictable. In

such animals, the time-energy budgets need to fit the time of

greatest stringency (principle of stringency; Wilson, 1975). If

their time-energy budget was fitted to the richest time for food

resources, they would fall into crisis at the time of stringency.

However, they are assumed to accumulate body fat in the autumn

and to consume it during winter under poor food conditions (e.g.

- 17 -

Page 21: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Wada, 1975; Wada et al., 1975; Wada, 1979; Wada & Tokida, 1981;

Nakagawa, in prep.). Thus, the energy budget does not appear to

be fixed so as to fit the time of greatest stringency exactly.

The former two strategies operate to accumulate energy under

conditions of surplus food, while the third one serves to

restrict the consumption of accumulated energy under conditions

of stringency-

Acknowledgements. I wish to express my deepest thanks to Dr. M.

Kawai, former Professor of the Primate Research Institute, Kyoto

University, for his guidance at every stage of this study. I

also wish to thank Dr. K. Izawa of Miyagi University of

Education and Ms. S. Sato of Yamagata University for offering

information prior to my study and for their invaluable help. I

am grateful to Drs. Y. Sugiyama, H. Ohsawa, A. Mori, U. Mori,

members of the ecology seminar of the Primate Research Institute,

Kyoto University, and Dr- T. Maruhashi of Musashi University

for their criticism of my preliminary draft. I am indebted to

Ms. M. Setoguchi for her assistance with the computer programming.

In the field study, I was helped by members of the No.29

joint-study room, Miyagi University of Education. I obtained

excellent facilities for my field work from the staff of

Kinkazan Koganeyama Shrine, especially the chief priest, M. Okumi.

I would like to thank all these persons.

- 18 -

Page 22: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

This study was financed in part by the Cooperative Research

Fund of the Primate Research Institute, Kyoto University, and

also by a Grant-in-Aid for Special Project Research on Biological

Aspects of Optimal Strategy and Social Structure from the Japaese

Ministry of Education, Science and Culture.

- 19 -

Page 23: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

REFERENCES

Altmann, J., 1974. Observational study of behavior: Sampling

method. Behaviour, 49: 227-265.

Azuma, S., K. Hayashi & M. Kawai, 1967. 1966nen Miyagi-ken

Kinkazanto ni okeru Dai-honyudobutsu no Chosa: Nihonzaru.

(Large mammal survey on Kinkazan Island, Miyagi Prefecture

in 1966: Japanese monkeys. Ann.Rep.JIBP-CT(5): 197-203.(in

Japanese)

Hashizume, H. & S. Yamamoto, 1974. Seed bearing of beech trees

(Fagus crenata BLUME) in the Chugoku District of Japan (II): The

fertility and character of seeds. J.Jap.For.Soc., 56: 393-398.

(in Japanese with English abstract)

Izawa, K., 1963a. The nomadic life of a troop of Japanese monkeys

living in Kinkazan. Primates, 4: 119.(abstract only)

Izawa, K., 1963b. Japanese monkeys on Kinkazan island. Yaen,

14: 5-11.(in Japanese)

Izawa, K., 1983. The ecological study of wild Japanese monkeys

living in Kinkazan Island, Miyagi Prefecture: A preliminary

report. Bull.Miyagi Univ.Educ., 18: 24-46.(in Japanese with

English summary)

Izawa, K., 1985a. The ecological study of wild Japanese monkeys

living in Kinkazan Island, Miyagi Prefecture: On the seasonal

change of vocalization in troops. Bull.Miyagi Univ.Educ., 19:

1-9-(in Japanese with English summary)

- 20 -

Page 24: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Izawa, K., 1985b. The ecological study of wild Japanese monkeys

living in Kinkazan Island, Miyagi Prefecture: On the vocaliza-

tion of the mating season. Bull.Miyagi Univ.Educ., 20: 7-18.

(in Japanese with English summary)

Izawa, K. & T. Nishida, 1963. Monkeys living in the northern

limits of their distribution. Primates, 4: 67-88.

Kuroki, K., 1975. A quantitative study of the daily activity

patterns of wild Japanese monkeys, Macaca fuscata fuscata, at

Koshima Islet. Master's Thesis of Kyushu Univ., Fukuoka.

Maruhashi, T., 1981. Activity patterns of a troop of Japanese

monkeys (Macaca fuscata yakui) on Yakushima Island, Japan.

Primates, 22: 1-14.

Miguchi, H., 1983. Population dynamics of murid rodents in the

next year of the beechnuts mastyear. Nihon-Ringakkai-Kantoshibu-

Happyo-Ronbunshu, 35: 187-188.(in Japanese)

Miguchi, H. & K. Maruyama, 1984. Ecological studies on a natural

beech forest (XXXVI): Development and dynamics of beechnuts in

a mastyear. J.Jap.For.Soc., 66: 320-327.(in Japanese with

English abstract)

Ohta, K., 1967. 1966nen Miyagi-ken Kinkazanto ni okeru Sho-honyurui

no Chosa (Small mammal survey on Kinkazan Island, Miyagi

Prefecture in 1966). Ann.Rep.JIBP-CT(5): 184-188.(in Japanese)

Suzuki, A., 1965. An ecological study of wild Japanese monkeys in

snowy areas :Focused on their food habits. Primates, 6: 31-72.

Takatsuki, S., 1980. Food habits of Sika deer on Kinkazan Island.

- 21 -

Page 25: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Sci.Rep.Tohoku Univ.Ser. IV (Biol.), 38: 7-31.

Tokura, H., N. Tanaka, S. Nakagawa & W. Ohsawa, 1981. Thermal

and metabolic responses in the Japanese macaque, Macaca fuscata,

acclimated to an ambient temperature of 5°C. Comp.Biochem.Physiol.,

69: 591-594.

Wada, K., 1975. Ecology of wintering among Japanese monkeys in

Shiga Heights and its adaptive significance. Physiol.Ecol.,

16: 9-14.(in Japanese with English abstract)

Wada, K., 1979. Yasei Nihonzaru no Sekai (The World of Wild

Japanese Monkeys). Kodansha, Tokyo.(in Japanese)

Wada, K., K. Moriya, F. Hara & W- Ohsawa, 1975. On the body fat

of Japanese monkeys inhabiting the Shiga Heights. Physiol.Ecol.,

16: 104-107.(in Japanese with English abstract)

Wada, K. & E. Tokida, 1981. Habitat utilization by wintering

Japanese monkeys (Macaca fuscata fuscata) in the Shiga Heights.

Primates, 22: 330-348.

Watanabe, T., 1975. Some features of the Japanese monkeys (Macaca n

fuscata) of Shiga A troop from viewpoint of somatometry.

Physiol.Ecol., 16: 55-63.(in Japanese with English abstract)

Wilson, E. 0., 1975. Sociobiology: The new synthesis. Belknap

Press, Harvard.

Yoshiba, K., 1959. Ecological survey of Japanese monkeys in the

Tohoku district. Yaen, 5: 15-23.(in Japanese)

Yoshihiro, S., 1980. Peculiar food habits of the Japanese monkey

in Kinkazan. Monkey, 24: 14-15.(in Japanese)

- 22 -

Page 26: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Yoshii, Y. & K. Yoshioka, 1949. Plant communities of Kinkazan

Island. Ecol.Rev.(Sendai), 12: 84-105.(in Japanese)

Yoshioka, K., 1960. Effect of deer grazing and browsing upon the

forest vetetation on Kinkazan Island. Sci.Rep.

Fac.Art and Sci., Fukushima University, 9: 7-27.

Yotsumoto, N., 1976. The daily activity rhythm in a troop of wild

Japanese monkeys. Primates, 17: 183-204.

- 23 -

Page 27: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Table 1. Food-species list of the monkeys of the Kinkazan A-troop from November, 1984 to February, 1985

Species name Japanese name Part eaten

A. Fagus crenata Buna Se B. Autumn food

Rubus microphyllus Nigaichigo Fr Carpinus tschonoskii Inushide Se

guercus acuta Akagashi Fr Perilla frutescens Remonegoma Se Sorbus japonica Urajironoki Fr Torreya nucifera Kays Se Zelkova serrata Keyaki Se Clematis apiifolia Botanzuru Se

Quercus serrata Konara Fr Cornus macropylla Kumanomizuki Fr Viburnum dilatatum Gamazumi Fr Zanthoxylum piperitum Sansho Fr,Se Rosa multiflora Noibara Fr Callicarpa japonica Murasakishikibu Fr Fungi spp.

C. Winter food except for barks and buds Euonymus fortunei Tsurumasaki Lf

Pinus densiflora Akamatsu Lf Trachelospermum asiaticum Teikakazura Lf Viscum album Yadorigi Fr Herbs and grasses

Oplismenus undulatifolius Chijimizasa Ixeris stolonifera Iwanigana Ixeris japonica Ojishibari, etc.

D. Barks and buds Callicarpa japonica Murasakishikibu Br

Zanthoxylum piperitum Sansho Br,Bu,Tw Fraxinus lanuginosa Aodamo Br, Ilex macropoda Aohada Br Celastrus flagellaris Tsuruumemodoki St Schizophragma hydrangeoides Iwagarami Bu

Cornus macrophylla Kumanomizuki Bu Cornus kousa Yamaboushi Bu Castanea crenata Kuri Bu Symplocus chinensis Sawafutagi Br Celtis sinensis Enoki Bu E. Soil and unidentified species

Fr: fruit; Se: seed; Lf: leaf; Br: bark; Bu: bud; Tw: twig; St: stem.

Page 28: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Table 2. Percentage of time spent feeding on all food items

except beech-seeds to total feeding time: Comparison between

after 3:00 p.m. and before 3:00 p.m.

N After 3:00 p.m. Before 3:00 p.m.

Nov.-Dec. 24 37 % 24 %

Jan.-Feb. 2646*23*

* t -test: p<0.05.

Page 29: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Table 3. Percentages of sound, insect-damaged and empty beech-seeds in each month

Sound seeds Insect-damaged Empty seeds i%1 seeds 1%1 i%i

Dec. 20.8 39.6 39.6 Jan. 12.0 50.0 38.0 Feb. 5.3 53.0 41.7

At the 3 periods, December 9 and 10, January 6, and February 14, respectively, 100, 150 and 150 beech-seeds were collected randomly in 3-5 food patches. Insect-damaged seeds had holes measuring 1 mm across which were made by insect larvae on their surface. In external appearance, an empty seed was difficult to distinguish from a sound one. However, when the shell was broken, the seed proved to be empty and an undeveloped ovule was found inside.

Page 30: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

,c3

a) . CO b0 ----.

-c1 ai •zt•

a) 0 t-- a) 03 cy)

u) id --I i I i d4 CH -I I 13e 1 1 1 • 0 ••

.0 1--1 ---1 I I I *-4 0/ .. 00t--o

a)00ocm 4-) • a) •r-I 0 H 0

,-0 0 o3 0 •=t, ..<4 0C1 -Iodco

›-.-H000) 4-)003 ,--1

E0$-1>4 Ei>' CO of1-.30- a)-p--1 C... a) al 0

iliak 't"—I CN7 Cf) 0.)›... 0 'd El--Pi ,-1d,1444 -) CU o3

0

1414-) CO 5›.a 00 0 0 -0 0 N $-4

Ti -P ..-1 cd a) 1rci•r 31a)4Z WI041:0 0IIV4-)o3 a3 0

03›.a= 0310 t-- cq c Hi 0— -H Pri I o3 -^1 cP) • • • O .1-1 4

1 I'd ak N CY) 1-1 cf) 7:1 0 0 -P1--.-I,--1 •zr,-^•riC .) 0

.1-)'00 IV a) 0010o3-H alid4-) 0ix0c0.1-01 ----

gI•H0 HI$-1o3o r-I

- I cd PO co 1 TSI >oa)

0 id4-)4-11-4 10 00 c0 >.0

O 0 ---4 tr) • • • 4-) h0 4-1 u3 032 Ch •P' co •--i •ri 0 a) 0 0 ''-'i t.- .-I C.- r•I •r•I CO

4•4 En •PI Pri o3 3-1 0 •-) $4 a) o3 3.4 o 34 CU U) — -0 0 0 0

a) tn •ty 44 o cu -P b0 DI 1 cu a) •tC TS to al a) — -p P 3-I PO o3 4-) .f-I ,--1 00 0 0 a) -0 5

0 4-) I 4-) +) a) 4-) 4-) 0 • 4-) a) •ri I 0 0 4 0 0 IEnu) 1a)

"I •-1 .1-i baoa) 0 3 .0 3-103f-I $-1 •r.1 4-1 4-1 1 CU 0 4-)

Cll 0 I 4-) 4-) 4.-• a) 0 14 3-4 -cl w0 I DI c0 c^I P F-1 I Ff 4-) 0 $-1

,-1 I •,..1 •1-i 4-1 ---- III (14 01 0 o.403cl-I

• 34 I A A 00 o3a3 ^0 0 -tt. a) +) 0 0 u) 0 0 +, of) a) $-1 03

.0 -H ..W ..W "d o3 03 o3 - a) 0 +) 0 4-> /-•1 0 o 0 0 ›.)a --- ,0 0 0 ,--1 o o3 bi) ba o3 -H a3 cd cN1 Pd A -0 0 0 0 4,-) 0 El - a)

a3 .4-) 0I.0 .0 ca 0 a3o3I--- 4 4-) — E-4 0.-1IC.) C.)— -c33I-4 +) -.-4 .14

Page 31: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Table 5. Comparison between the characteristics of beech-seed feeding and those of torreya-seed feeding

Beech-seeds Torreya-seeds

1. % of time spent 70% 30% feeding to total

feeding time 2. Distribution Uniformly in the Clumpily in a region

home range of the home range 3. Competitors Wild mice Almost none (while

seeds were covered with pulp)

4. % of ii.?n-sound 79.2-94.7% Almost 0% seeds 5. Weig of edible 0.10 g 0.09 g

part 6. Caloric content/2) 6.91 kcal 5.28 kcal

1 g edible part 7. Density of fallen High Low

seeds

1) The proportion of non-sound beech-seeds varied with the dominance of the beech trees: as shown in Table 3, it changed with lapse of time. For the torreya-seeds, 57 seeds on October 21 and 63 seeds on December 21 were collected as samples and examined: as a result, no non-sound seeds were observed. 2) Nakagawa, in prep.

Page 32: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

LEGENDS OF FIGURES

Fig. 1. Map of Kinkazan Island. The shaded portion shows

the Fagus crenata zone.

Fig. 2. Definition of a feeding bout. FB: feeding bout; M: moving.

Fig. 3. Changes in percentage of time spent feeding on each food

category from the latter half of November 1984 to the former

half of February 1985. A: beech-seeds; B: autumn food; C: winter

food other than barks and buds; D: barks and buds; E: soils and

unidentified species.

Fig. 4. Changes in feeding speed on beech-seeds from the latter

half of November, 1984 to the former half of February, 1985. The

ordinate shows the inverse of the feeding speed; that is, the

time spent picking up a seed.

Fig. 5. Changes in percentage of time spent feeding on

beech-seeds (broken line) and on all food items (solid line) to

observation time from the latter half of November, 1984 to the

former half of February, 1985.

Fig. 6. Changes in number of beech-seeds eaten per individual

per observation time (1 hour) from the latter half of November,

Page 33: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

1984 to the former half of February, 1985.

Fig. 7. Changes in feeding speed on beech-seeds at each food patch

from November 13, 1984 to February 13, 1985. The ordinate shows

the inverse of the feeding speed; that is, the time spent picking up a

seed. Data points for the same food patch are connected

with each other by thin line. The means for each half-month period

are connected by the thick line.

Fig. 8. Changes in cumulative numbers of feeding bouts and

food patches in beech-seed feeding.

Fig. 9. Changes in cumulative numbers of feeding bouts and food

patches in torreya-seed feeding. P1: Oct. 16-22; P2: Oct. 23-29;

P3: Oct. 30-Nov. 5; P4: Nov. 8-13; P5: Nov- 14-21; P6: Nov.

22-Dec. 1.

Fig. 10. Changes of average feeding speed on torreya-seeds from

October 16 to December 1, 1985. The ordinate shows the inverse of

the feeding speed; that is, the time spent picking up a seed.

P1: Oct. 16-22; P2: Oct. 23-29; P3: Oct. 30-Nov- 5; P4: Nov.

8-13; P5: Nov- 14-21; P6: Nov- 22-Dec. 1.

Fig. 11. Changes in feeding speed on torreya-seeds at each

feeding bout from October 16 to December 1, 1985. The ordinate

Page 34: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

shows the inverse of the feeding speed, that is, the time spent

picking up a seed . Data points for the same food patches are

connected with each other by thin lines. The means for each

period are connected by the thick line.

Fig. 12. Distribution of torreya-seed patches. The area

enclosed by the solid line shows the home range of the A-troop

from October 16 to December 1, 1985. Solid circles indicate food

patches before November 21; open circles indicate food patches

which the monkeys visited and fed at for the first time after

November 22.

Fig. 13. Feeding strategies of Japanese monkeys against

deterioration of the habitat quality.

Page 35: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

NIO HEAD

O 4) 0 a I I I I r4 OBAKO

mhos, HEAD

sHRIN

41.11^^•^•^^•••^•^ wows imi^

iblE^•^•••^•••^ ^^•^^^

PIER

• !MEW %WM', "^^•^••

•ANNNMIII^w, ••^•••^ 111111^11!— -^:;-

.11=1F 1111^11111^116

INWA•^^^•^1/0 11••••^•^•^ SENJOJIKI

.;)

0

70) LIGHT — AHOUSE

4.04111 KINKAZAN ISLAND

,TONO HEAD

?'500 1000 INA

FIGS 1

Page 36: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

(Ex.1) F B

2 min > 1 min 1 min.<

IMMI

1 min.> in all

(Ex.2) (Ex.3) B-41 1E- F B-31 B--)1

'I min < 2 min.> 2min <

Th1 min1 min <

1MMI "M I

I

1 min77I < In all 1 min >in all

FIG .2

Page 37: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

WOUM‹

IL

1001B

_J

ai

• U-

-).••• •

.• a)

. •

0 CD CD CD CD

6ulpeel weds ewR Jo%

Page 38: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

LL

0) LL

-1

cd -

LL

- C co

0

LL-

-

a) 0

0 u) 2 -

co (.0 0 CO CO 'I CV 0 r- r-- r-

0 cp pees e do bum* lueds ewu

'kq r„ 4

Page 39: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

u_ u)

.ci ak lo

-

a) a) u)N ,a) E% Iu.

a) -J

F3 as

o1'D —) co oI

*- u_

<4 Co -J

6

1/21\ a)

0

% ^ LL

41 6 as

1 0 I -J

0

z

,,, , . .I t I .

o 00 0 to

ewp uoimuesqo o; Buipeal weds ewn lo %

F 1 G . 5

Page 40: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

u_

.6 LL.

tIf --)

LL C

-J

LL

0

O.

0 0 1.0

C\1 C\1 T T""

OW- ewg uoneniesqo Jed

lenpvtipul Jed U131138 epees jo •ON

't1„6

Page 41: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

Cl: o• o\.....,:°.0—°°c'o

. - .

CI) Ll. o c .

,00 ^:.° .

0

k\k‘IIII*11.1°,-._ -----.....\ .0 0., ..,s•1,c.,

Skilit 0•

o

o 4\117, .ss 4 r— tA_ .

r_

d 1

\^ ‘ ' 1 0 rik,1 N k.. 0

lA.1*-, •0,

1‘.0.; 0

As . • \ \ 0 ,-.•7:

. N!cm

.

,. 1 0 0. ,k .cr7 I 100A 0 • cb

.1

0

0

co ..r.

8 N

LO 0 LO Lo 09 1--

VIG .7 co coc`a

Page 42: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

c/) a) 0 u)

o(0>-, cot riCi5 4-,-o n a_ o c

.0 0-)o c -47; L3):175 co C a)

0> Z5a)l-, a) u_ 11u) a) _o u_ 0

'11 0 . (NI

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 o -4. ce) CV

Jeciwnu engeinwno

Page 43: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

C u) 0 >, cn

7.3 al ..c cr; -0 >

o

17111 .. Ci5 0. : 2 I (i) CD : 0 a.

Cl) c .5:6..:", 0 o0\- Cv) I In

a) u_ \ 0...

0) \-

_

C 0\-

_ \

It a) ..:01°- a)\

u. - CN

\ CL(Y)

_

\_

\ : N ..:: 0 I C\I

\ -

_

\- :a:

0

0 0 0 0 Lo 0 1.0

Ir''"'

.1 eqwnu enReinwno

F i G 9

Page 44: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

0

CY) O.

CNI CL

O.

0 o 0 ("N 2

pees e do 6upfold lueds ()Lull

Page 45: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

sec

0

35—

30—

25— 0

0 0 0

O

20—

A

rA °PA PrAl °

0

AOPPIP' . .

o 0

-"1"111111111pip-

1 0-- 0

0

0 "gdgibl- •

5—

Oct.16 Nov. 1 10 20 Dec.1

eiG.1]

Page 46: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

.____. • O f i 2

0

.0 I--

Z •

• cC w

00 a _ O

• 0 • • • o • 0 • •

, • o o • ., •

•• 0•• 0 • • 0

• •

••• • • •

W • Z•

• • • cC

•i••• • co%• •

•0

• • ••

0 • •

4 <

2

..tt, '^ 0 r 0 <

1--

0 \._...)2)) 0 C•1Cl)

cf)

'(G . 12

Page 47: Title Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys( Dissertation ... · Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys against Deterioration of Habitat Quality Feeding Strategies of Japanese Monkeys

4.) N -.-1 u)

ro .--i U) al CI) col)) 0 a) 0 +1 ^iii-ca0 co

01ni (1.) I $4 NMI $4

4-)0 0RI >1 fa .,-1a)

a) -1-)P VP ,) a)

)4 ro -C14-1u)4:1) caa)V

+1+1 =V CT) 0-,-1 4-4 0

lit co

1 0f—I coa:1a, nz) ›,cr, a)a)a)ax) cll

.0 N co3-1 C.) >1

1 >I'$44.3r—I CC100al >1 g -P W0042

0 0 r0 $_.0 0 W

0 0P E-/ >-,Vr...1fa

.C/al W

tn a. g u) ---i Ts ro

Ntrio o a)go a) -.-144 49 rz4'0

C.) C $4 _ a)

9a) r=4 4-)c -1-1 rd

-.-10 (ao . . 4 -1

+ + 1-1 co * co co0 0co co

Va) VCU -9

W

,---i>-,toWa .)3 ca wbw

w .Xa)s1 ,-1gP .0 .0 COU () 0U alEa)

a)a)• b tocll >-1 0W al .r) as u) u) aa

.0 V cc1

C

CT-lia)a)• W

co-.-IP•ch C.1 V V 111)

1 a) a) w .0 .0 V1 1

Nel4.)U.0.0 W rmi 0 WVUU Ia)0

0CU a) .0 "WXI U +144 .c[1) V 0 * 1 -2 Tja) W 0

W0 a)0 C0W ca>,g,o 4)

Ts0og4-) )4 -,-ICl)o ,--i u) a) 4-) a)4 -1cll00 cacUa)0

EXE. 0 -1-1a.4 -r4cp-ri u) CritJnow °I 43-P P

co 0 -P01=11en171,-1 Cn -.-1

ca-,-I0 _,9 U) 0 0 0 .5N ...1 a) r0000r0r0r0 r0 wa) ..0 4,a)a)a) rcl0Cl)

a)(1)a) (1) WVP4Piu) 44 u)

FIG- 1 3