marxbad.docx
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
1/50
,
! "#"$ % & ' () * + , +--.% +-/0! 12 3 4 56 %
"7 *$ 57" 2%+" "8 ,
% 2&9,: &; 7 ?+ .@" "% !
1"% A! .@. ?+ 4 * $
-.% .@" % 'A B%C7 + 1 .D7 =.$
> = .@. E,B%C7, 'A + F G
C *$ HI A / -.% +--.%
"%8 .@." B%C7 + ! 7 + J-1 56 8 D " %K L& F $ . + 5L MNN)-
MO(P 1 +7 .@. &Q 9 'R 12 'A %S
* C $
! " "#" $% &' $$ : (-) *
"
% 5T & .L/ '7 "%8 .6 * $-. % !L& B ! J 'D '7 -.%-+
-.% "%8 &Q > 8IS! ! $ 1.
UQ V % . : "% *Q .Q$ W> %. %XY
, X7T Z ,![ ,-5\ 1
1 ! U ! &Q $ 1 1 MOMO J
'D 2] 5; !$ 1 2] '7 =& 0 . 5[ ! &7
!$ ^ *" " ,,5\,![ 'C 7D! 12 U ?_
` "- ' +a bG !$ .6 c J-1 d "AC[ 7e .6 !$(M) & d & ?fg= ` 5
h= 2&9 &Q . " !$ 1 7D L& L! %
U0 % "=&! "@Q, J +7 'i I% Y 5 7.
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
2/50
5D AF .$ G 1 9 j > 1 R+ I% @ W k&
7< ,
L! > L " 9. 12 lm 7. D, 7 .
. ' G> n 5+ *$ G G " !`K. > 1 9 12 ! L o ` 56 7. " G +> &! D p (q)
1 1 .6 +7 J-.% +--.% "%8 " o
"% .>8 =7 'i> & 1 .6 !$ + '7
1 "%8 " IF r 2] 5 ! %.Q +7 " MOqs -MOqN 5+
.-.% +--.% "%8 GQ 'v '+"
$ GQ '7w Y hD 1 2] 1> GQ .% $1 "> GQ ` X .% 'i> 1> "%
. 12 ` 1 "> GQ *2%+ ! xR &A! !$ @ 'D GQ
.% +-.%8 < 2] JA D .K "
*:
'D, ` 7 .>8 " D 1 "%8 -&0 'D
, " ., L . .y"." "%> -.% D %;
(z) (MM 2 D)
L" { 1 D q, z, | 1 MM 2 n ' ?+ u
. "*$ 1 G ! 7 &0 7 +7
.D78 }C $ ,
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
3/50
7 /-1 " D -.% 12 .y"." "%8 -&0
" 8 D H+ 1 % L "%8,
H+ 7 1 7 ! .>8 ."=! 1 !* 12 "
% 78 ~ %G !*, L, "% -&0
8 IF 2] p (()
1 D &0 D D , 57"
IF '" ?+ ?fg= ! .K $ 1 56 ' "AC
hD J 577 "7A GQ 1 &9=
G$ hD .% GQ> .%8 &0
D H+ ' D '` G$ [ ">
: . $ 'Df .K "@Q L &n k
. &0 o= W>% -.%" D L< *$())
kf, 1 1 L o: 7 ! {
2G7 % 5]&7 ! 9*, L * : x "*$ .y"." "%8 -&0
D 7 / 12 7 .>8 7- 1 * " - $ 1 .
! b F/ . ! L -&0 , H+ -
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
4/50
o 1 D .$ 1 % 52% A " k &9, L .@" o
'+S $ L" .y"." "%8 ! .> u " !, ! 1 "%8
A D 1> "C o 7, 'A .K D 7 7
% 12 7 o: ., 1> 5 *Q *$3
"4 ! 5 )6 " 7 70 -18*9 , &:%
&-;"9 >!; )6 >9 60-! "?0"0 0@!
)- "@! A 5 B/)6 6 7 ",C 1 / * )9
&-;"! 6, ) F/- :%6, ",C 0@! , 70 ,0, !@! &* , *" &E0, 0 &* )9 0 %
&J 4, F* ) * 0 &*6 , &! =, ! )- =, L
!C6 $!H1 7.> % o= ' !* 12 U L 1 .D7>
+7 12 ' & -&0%"> -D> k
'6. 1> 1 9 .$ 1 o > ! L 7 !
-.% "%8 ?+ 8 H+ G D L" 1
8 'A 5D ! 12 " '+ A " .F %K 12
2&9 " IF $ ^ L" 5D D, ! G7" 7 D* 2" " IF Q , L + k /
.Q(N)
5D k 2] &0 " + +7 .D7 * k
w, H+ , " 'i> 2] 1 .%
k ! 4 *$6 A6 ! 7 : & 1! "
0 &E0,0 &* !6 H )9 &6 F $%H 3
&M !6 * F7,,& "-/, ! N" 00 02 OI 0 &* 7 "HhD >
56 "A D L, L!.%8 ! 1G 2]
7 LDC B , .%8 !" ?+ % AS
K]` A" 7 . " 8IS . $ hD '`
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
5/50
GQ> ! 'v '[ *5 D > H+ 1 J
bR &A! ! L .%8 !" ?+ ! 5]& ! + W
1 .6 *$
-.% "% " '[ k "AC[ *. k 2] 5 "7 +7 . L$ '+ .-- . 7"" D
" 5/k "AC[ 5"7 ,
1G L> 'i u. !* > L ` . 1>5
7 L 'i8 1G !*, " 1 'i
9 "*$ "% * & & "G 'i o=. " *$
&0 o , "%> ?+ 12 1> ?+ G-AF o
1 }A! *$ !9 & 9 L Q t 12 "AC/= " 7& "! '; *$ 1> . L "% *
1> & + 2A 1> GL&7 : !*$ 1 "%
* .. & : 5K D* H+,
" & 5K !*$ L" 1G " %K &
D L ! ! %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
6/50
G, K 1 7D D$ 1 o: 12 1 L
, L 1> A *. ! *, A S " 1 9 >
" .>5+7 D $ '> " 12 5+. L
?+ ! 5! !$ 1 > 5G H+
. 7" IF , " ? " IF, L "% '+ Q
" k &9$ "I, 7Q 0 , ! 2 &
&, Q U/, 7 Q6 0 / V" &6 & " , )6
*9 F/ 0 0* 56 7*H & 7 )9 U/,
0 F*! 0 &G "4 &71&/ )- )6 6 , =
WL )- 0 1 " &E0 &* #/ Q X (O)
1G .-- d .6 : D D . 7"" D
" o . 1 "C *$ 'D" " ?D G
7"" IF " Q* ^ LG "% ~@
HI G . 7"" D ~.Q &$ 7-1 '+
% & [ W>% 7"" o > .-- +$(Ms) Y
"% &Q 9 ." [ 7" 1 + &@>*Q *$ (MM)
+, -.&-", F/ (N" Y FP :
k 2] " . 5; '7 & 'D 2]-1 -.% 'i k "AC[ 5A ! 12 ,A 7 8 %"
!$ =
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
7/50
7 + .%8 !" 2&9 = !$ -.% +-
-.% "%8 .>8 7 k+ . !
'7 -.% 12 +--.% "% 7 .>8, L 1G %
*, " '7> 52%]! L +7 & * .* .$1D L .I0 !`d%-"K o 28 12
' 8 IF " ' R ' 5L !. 2" ~@
! D .< 2&98 K 12 8 7. &w Q2&9
./ 3%7p (Mz)
hD " '7 'i .>,.% +-.%8 : "8
+ : "% : . . " 1 "% x $ MOqN
5; ; 2] 5 1 . J'+7 *$ 1 '[ G ', 1 1 ,% "% ` " ' $(M()^ 1 1> ' AC * L L J-1 )
2] GQ " K f ` f ("/ '7 % ) "
GQ 9 $ f " { GQ .%8 -56.: +
1 '& D !*$ 1 " .%8 ?+
= %< ! " [ J-1 o 6. " !*$ 1 1
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
8/50
5D -.% ! L "% 7" [ .-
~ ` ?+ 5 .* > Y ` * 57/ }C *$ 1
.-1 = n ECCI-1 | 1', MOq)-1 56 [2] ? .> .
52% D 7" + L KUTV-
*" ' @ MN ! .%8 ?+ LF A S =
7 !" 'v $ 1 ` 8IS.= ."8 D 12 G."
+. +. !9 !$ 1 3%7 ! 1> 7" + AC 12 1
! +.7 y $ 1 -> G 1D 1> 12 A "
.>, ; L 1 >X k F, .> . ]! ., ^ L
1 #> #> ! 1 $ "%8 7 .> ?0 ! 5] 7"
& ! +.7 1 7 .> +7 'v 12 ` p (MO)
2 1 D ~ Lt L .%8 : : B%C7 o f ` }C 56
*$ $ ) )9 I 0 5! 7Q & 59 "
5! F*$ &6 0 0 )9 C F-6 &E0,0 &* "I 5!79
) $, H N" IZ &' G! [\]^ &! _
0" $6H ^ f` 11 " .. ' 12
5' * $(qs) L" MOq) [ 1 !" ?+"7& % .K $ `f ` MOqN 5 k 56
5 *$ MOqP-1 k o 1 A ` { 1 + G
$(qM)
" /-" 0 $% &' ` -&---) FP :
1> "% " > f - -2 & L! *$
f -1 8 'D
3
% D . !$ c/ .6 : .L ` .'K f "% "
' "AC[ : % 7G7 * 1 G8$ -1
: 3 - L 12 Z : 7" "%8
1> .@." 5+$ 1 : 3 .8 IF 2] , 7" "%8
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
9/50
+7 k8 L& & ', 'D " +7 1 D [ .
'+ 12 H % K7 # '$ "!?., 5, 3 -" +7
W> ?.K, " ?.K 12 ." ?.K : " *$ . IF '+ LF
1" W> L%"
?.K 3 "8 G 3%7 o= # & p (qq)
1 "G L 3 " +7 X *
! 1> , L 1 D Bk 5+$ 1+ 7" k
.Q /" k %AF 12 5 " " D k$ 1 'K
%$ 7" 12 LF"8 IF Q 7 1> . c! '"% *$3 F0
"0a &E0 )- &0 / && ! F*b b &
Q 0! )- &E0 &0 &* F*b c Q F/ F:d 5H )9
A 7Q 1 =, : _!, V" . Bk
5 "C .12 1> "C 5+ 7" 12 LF"
8 IF 52% . 12 1> %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
10/50
&D ! ) )9 7 &E0, 0@! "#"0 : &
)- 0 + &7e !! (q() 12 `ff &D &06 &E0
"0!, (q)) 12, &D 9 & !C , 0
FGZ g Q h &E0 " ,!(q|)$
f -1 3 '7" "% +7 A! k D $ ^
" K 7"" D *!L& o D " D 2#> 1>
. 7 o '+ " ! "@Q$ 1 J-1 ; . 2] A
&A! .% +-.% ` " 1 56
. "@Q 1o k "AC[ .6 *$ Y ^ "C
` .'K 3 +> .6 *$ -1 `
'> 3 .@. - 1 1+ '7" "% 5+ *$ X 3
+ 57 "% K '& & ..% ` $
&D / "`&-i Y
1> .@" / L& (internationalization o !ono"ol#
$a"ital) %3 %> L .f2l *," 7G7
1> 7" "% 12 3" +7 n 5t"7 + : 3
!. -1 $ ?DK !" 5L . ' & 1
' * .$ LG K 3 12 k
7" +7 k B= & & .*, G 3
7"76 . G 5R . , 7" .A;.
. #> .$ 1> k , 1> ! .% +-.% & . %
.Q 3%7 1> 5H @> 7" 12 3 +7
o '+ "$p (qP)
1 2l> f # $` jI &D, &kc l _ )$9 " #
, 71 ,,m,, "1,,! 7 0 , 6 7H n )$9 " # 71 :&, 6 l c
5h " ?3 B/% &E0 &* )6 71&6 &D ! &-i
" HL" f&E0,0 &* ! " 1 IX'[ 9 >
! 5/! + B%C7$ f * L,
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
11/50
" IF % "% 3 ! x
1> 3 - D ., 3
. ! .$ 1 ! . L 1 .% " [ .%"
Q 2# D ! " ?DK 7 ] 7" . %$
.% " o 1 k + . w 1G
x D HI L.D C $
r-U/, !", " #0, s :
{! .@" x % "> 52% < L .1>
! '-'D ULF .5D MOM( - & .L/ 12 > MOM(-MO(P 5$ 1 " . +7
7"" D o *.D7 K7 L$ 12 1 " .L
+7 . &.D .@" %1 w 1 A . + $
1 % & .F o *D %7$ '>
% 6- ` . w *+ 12 *% B%C7
D$ 1G 1> 'R 7G7
.F
(ðo')
'
(&o'el)-1 +7 .D7 B !$ .F-1 K 1> #> + B%C78 1>
% "AC[ " " 5n , " K 1 "AC[ ! .F$
^ '-1 K - 5L + B%C7 1 D D ` % B%C7 .6
D$ .F (ðo')5 "G L %> + B%C78 !
* $(qO) , 1[, ,` -1 '8 @" - 5L
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
12/50
% ` ! *$ 2 1G - '-8
'& #> 7G7 . ,^ " '"% .F'&
+ B%C G@ " 9 '&$ + 5L ?+ E ">
+ B%C7 *$ 'D> ! A!" %% ; 12 k> !"%
. 0$ f % K 'L& +7 .7 c." (si!"le
$o!!o'it# "ro'u$tion) D HI 'D .@" c." ($a"italist
enter"rise)! A! .@" % (lare s$ale in'ustr#)B ! 1> Y %
K *$(zs). % K% D R A! % % ! 1>
1> "C Y$3 l )9 m! :% F$!- , *`, t9
&/, * 71 )- U u )Q "# &v &S 5!
H .@" 'D ."K. L8 ! . LD # *>G> !`%
c."%8 W>% " -.% ?DF 7 C *$(zM) kf, L! % % 'D .L .@" / 5+ 'L& L& 5R
1> . ! &*, # 'L& 5 * 12 L Q%
6. 7 A! .@ 1/ ' * $ (1G m"% % . ?+
A 5`S * L " .@ 1> *>G> ."
c." x " .) 1 .@ 7 " 7" /0 *
! . !$ ^ 1 ! L . 12 MOM(- 'D ULF *> + 56
. .@. # 7 7" /0 D 2# HI L MOM(-
MO(P .L/ 1 1> % B%C7$ 1 2#-2] ^ " ? & +7 F *$ G ( 3 ! 5D
% L !) X D 7 7" /0 + "#6
2] % . $, "#"0 I ! )6 7 )0 Q6 ,
0 -I &* 7w* =, x( 1C ! &E0 WL !C6
F0 &D 0 7, F*b Y 0 &E0, 0
"0! 7H(y]) 0, " 8 F !: U/, 0-
II 5H U U*6 h & t9 & h "0:" /5H "",, "#" 1 t9/, =, 1! -
&J, K F, 5H )6 1!@! =, &S # 0
& &* 0 U* &/ / &J F, 5H )0 h Y
N" t9 & / 5 0 U*: 10 F0
h &E0, 0 " *5 & 0 H&-
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
13/50
! " #0 0 m! ) &2 !!6 )- &E0 &8 &2
F*b 7171 0 *!6 , &D & Q 0
7_ 6H 3 , 0 &. "7 C ) $,
, F- &E0 WL "K 0 !C6 $!H 0 !:
7_ " # h :% &. &E0 " ,! *5, )9 0
&E0, 0 " H " 3 ' 7 % *S "% 'L% 'L .y . X !* 12 1 "% .@" % K
8IS.= = G*$(zz) ^ y ] . W> 3
./ ! L$
? *D B%C7 * L8 " 1 % +
% 7 "$ ]zz 5 N" & / I) ! {q 1C
q5!, 76 {q )0 &! 0, 8 :% |, } 5!H
0, )6 / |, 8 "#" F / N"-N"
0 ! F 0~ &-1q &7 5!H! 1% 577 "%8 2
"K "%=! 9 1 * $MO(O-1 .= : 7"
"% .% 5 12 : " k 0 *+-/0 +-
-.% 5 < *$ h ,9 * G * $ 57"
"%8 ?+ 5 2% %$ 1> "% &9 2]"% ,9 L & = D 27 .@" u +7 " ~ L$
. ` "% " " 27 .@" 'D u ! w ^ *
c 27 ,9 12 1 ,9 : %
1D 5?L$ 1> {! ` .@. W>% 7"
IF LF *Q % L& "*$ )6 l& G9 ! * n7L
", & t9 &E "H ) >! )0 7 5 :% , "#" -
U/, "7 , 0, 5 F0 0 F&E0, _0 &* &' P" " U/, "5H2 1 ` %S D
G " R% ~ !$ 1 "G L % 'D .
.@"" L.D$
r n7L "R : * &v &!
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
14/50
MN)s .= *"%" 6. * % > " " '
%"7& * $ "% .@ ! . 'D -% 6. 12 1> *
% 6. 'D '$ft9 m! F& "&, * " #" V"
5! )- " 0!! 0 F& 5!X (z)) ^ 5*"
"7& W>% !L& 6. 1 % 7. X7 $ &A!LF
LG =7AF 7 . m L,G . . . X> .@ $
. 1 . 5D% & R % 5] ! 9$ % %
1* X 7 D 12 XX@. 9 7 L
.@ & #>*, D$(z|)
2 1 . " 'L&= "#.D L 3
7 7"" [ 7 +7 1 > 5 'D-.@
&Q X$ 1 .@ !L7 'D 'D A! % 6. !$ 5D
A! %6. .=< Y D " A! % 6. !$ 1
1 3 7. 5 .@ . 'i . ^ ?2
.@ ] A G *,
1 X, +!, 1> + cR 'R *$ 'D, '7K %.@. . !$ I%w 7 K 1> 7, %, 7 c."
I% X 12 " k "% D "A @ X p
2 +L 1 7 +7 5 .@ k %. ! L
. 7 L ! $(zP) %% 1 'D L& % % &
% !*$ " " + W>% X D MNNq "%
. " *Q MNO| . +L ! ^ " { &
D$ MNNq-MNOq +7 G 2G7 |q D MqP ! 12 c." k8 ! L12 MNOs D 'D ULF +7 ' 8 ! L$(zN) 'D 7%
% [ 'L& D . .@" LD; % }C ! L LG 7%
.@" [ 7 % IF 76 $
W>% . " 7 . "$(zO) ^ %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
15/50
W>%" A . % % . % = G3 * "
.'" 7D! L$ > ,
W>% & .7 ! 8IS 1> & ! & . !
% L0. ! 1K G 8IS.= 1 K> ! 1>K LG W>% c." U Q ;S G* 12 MOMz W> +
& .7 ] m L =7 ' 1 D2% 1 K D .
% c." .@"" . . % % 57! D$,
R :% )6 9! I / -u9 !: H 70 ,
R"0 &* ! "#"0 71-&-j 5! 3 )6 !)
R" , R 9 " , R t9 996!
R " ,! 5!H )6 / ,! 71 9! & )% 06 &S 7Q t9 N" & ]zz 5 / 5!H'D ULF
L {! =7 L& % . 9 "@Q$ 'D ULF
"% o= "G . .@" . " ?D+ >
1& &*$ MNO)-O| &" 1 % W> *. L$ 1 2% %HI !-} % W>% "G $ "% ! D
*Q W>% %. 1 '7w " .$((M) 1" [ 'L& 7 MOss
W>% *1* >> } %&9 1& $ >> 'D "% !L7
% D &*$ 1 >> %6. 7
& /'" * D 5D!L7 $((q) 1 #> >> W>%" D
1> 2% ?+ " 12 W>%" 7 % D 1 % `
% 'L> ! . .@ 1 " 12
W>% 7"" 0 5R n .$ MOM| >- c."
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
16/50
)s%2% Q L 12 . } m HI $ ^ 'D ULF 1 .>> W>%
7" ' " D U`4 G 5-X L& *Q "$
'D ULF > W>% .} ?A " MOMO Y
XY1 }C
& ( * L * L L" >> o " H+.> 7
, 1 , .7 12 .= 7 } " K !p ((z)
1 . Q L Z,, W> 'L& "%8 LF
+a 9 } c." ' k8 ,^ W>% }% G + @*$
2 1 'L& 56 > * W>% 1 & 12 1 X >>
W>%" D ? "% + " $ W>% "% MOq(
"% } . z)*) ! 12 >- " HI !$MOqP 1 *. ! >> "% % % + G$ 1 .}
' >> [ -.% 2# !$G
"P / 6 t9 & 99 0, 8 &71 15H )- 99
&& &-j 5C6 B/% 0, 6 0Q! - t9 & FT &M
h &E0, _ &* 0-II n- 1 " >!5H>>
" /" D !L7 'i " G ' f -1
7G7
/0 D Q > ]! " D "
#; L&L& *$p ((()
2 / .6 + 2# 1Q : 7" %> % !* L % + % 52%$
!-} .%.% >>- "7 c." HI $ 1 .@.
!,J, 7" % &Q $ L" 8 2G7 ? *, 18
%% = $ %" 57 G +$ ^ = D ! L 1.1 . %6. G *$ 577
2&9 K L .>,, 7" W>% .@ '+7 & *$ .
1 . 7 !-} % .@." % `> +$
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
17/50
'D ULF HI " 18 * D- 56 = &.D$ ^ 57" "%
d 'K.> "%& .9 " R%f %%
-.% IF .6 $ 1@" +7 / ` X D 1>
+7 1 *, ! W>% -.%" ! : .D = +$ @" '>
G .@" *. * }C 12I% -.= @" 7"
+ * G 'G$ % D +I
" '+ ^ o" 5 J , L .y * "% *
" .6 ! 1> %C +$ 1G 1> ] "% > "% IF 9
"@Q* p (())
"" .rain Theor# G }C W>% -.% " =
! 4 12 1 W>%" IF " w ';
!$ . %h "w 1 % #>$((|) MOs( /
2] "" }C ,
?w% +7 +> *$ W>%" D o
G . ^ G 1 " !7 p
1 +7 52%]! 1 K +
K. ((P)
2 5Dd d K ? " G D " ! ' *$ 'D
'D
?"%
+ . .@" 1 " "$1 X?. B ! 3. A! % &9 = G$ L" 1
` %"7&8 % ] 7" . % *$
. " +7 1 " " "%&
' * 57/ &$ ` W>% % D G,L!,A! % 'A &9
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
18/50
'D "% .@ LDC 5 *$ 1G 1 56 1" "% .@ ]
G L 57" % 7 . " 0 L -1 " * '-
?+ . = 'i$&6 Y 4 006 )- , 0 F 16
0 0 5!, )9 , & 1q Z Q, R@! , "
, H # &! )9 URP, {, " #0$5! 7 0,
@5 Q9 & 0((N) 1 [ ]! .9
"G . )s * . 7 ?+ 8$ 1> 57< !
L 7 ?+ 'D" D 8 @" +8 1>5""
.% $)96 5! , " )6 0 0 1 H
2 2% L L, 1 '-ULF " % 5Dd "%&
w B ! 9*$ 1 % + w . "@Q A .@" % L HI
!$
R +, "7 :, :! !"
MOM(-MO(P- +7 U > .>. " "% o=
"G K % + 56 1 "$ "-"> ULF 12 zs-1 > 5Dd
-.% % 7 *8 . "$ 1G 1 . 5D
8IS.= .8 $
M) 1 .L> / 7 K 52%]!1 > = .#>,D D " & 7 . ]$ W>% 'D " * W>%
%-] 1 8IS.= $ ^ 1 . +7 " G ++ % & &7.7
c." ?2o= ! 9$((O) 1 ?2o= % &> * "% .@ 0+$()s)
'D . =f , .>,,Q," 7" m $ MOzs-1 "%
18 X 5D 1> K]` ! L MOz| 1 H+ Q X 7
> D$ 'D " " v 8 *
,,,J,}, , "% 7"$ MOqs .L/ " 1 D MOzs-1 7. +a G 12 " . K *. $
MOq)-q| &" " )( %2% * &7.7
(G"7,,,&,,L!), M)*| %2% @
(, %,,9,9, , ,e."D) 12 qz*q%2% .@7 ($a"ital
oo's) (LDB"7 L0., %)$ MOzM-zq 18 LDR )M*| %2%, qz*(
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
19/50
%2% qM*P %2% *; MOzN-zO ! LDR zz %2%, qN*N %2% q|*O %2%$
()M)2 % 1 .1" '+ '+ &7.7 " 7. 5D . 57"
~ * &7.7 .@7 " : % L , !-
},,,J,e."D,&,@,X 1Y 'A AF .$
1 D & > " . R& * 12 [ m c."
. Q*$ 1 D X @ . 12 " %.7 @
. Q L$ 2 LF 12 MOzs-1 5D 5> . " 12 MO()-
1 1 .AD "% A!w c." ! 9$()q) 1 5D> 1> L
G 'L 12 %: "% ! 9*$ 1 MO(P .L/ D.*c." *
% M/( & 12 M/Ms &$()z)3 )6 *"5 * 0 , 0 0,
" 8 96 "" 7 H , 0, )6 !" /"
1 )- "?0"0 &M 9 )- "! &-Q
&'0 !1 "#0, 00 : F H 3 "#
7_ Q / / &E0, _ "6 ,! 5!H )@!6 T
I "#0, IZ " G L 5D 5
%,B7,[," 18 .@" 1> + K$()() 5D
1 5 % D " 3 , % + A .@"
% X 1 B7 " B !*$ K! !,6" "* ,
71 / 0 "#0, 5 )$9 "# !Hq) > % B%C7 ! 1 .%8 5/G B ! 5D =f "%
!" 5L c." HI $ 1 .* "> *$ 'Df .> m
%8 5Dd 6 &*$ kf 577 "% %8 7 h
6. !t L8 =f "% 7 c." $ "! ! L, L LG
'D " B ! %8 "= '7 m *,G "7 6.
"",., w G8 # 7 c." *$())) 1 .
57/ 7 7. . AF .t$ MOqs-zO-1 +7 1 7 7' z 8 12 }, 12 J q 8 AF .$()|)
&, [
5 &., : &"* t9 0
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
20/50
&., )
[\]z-
][
[\]-
]^ [\]p-]\
[\y]-
yy
[\y-
y [\z-[
[\-
^
]
. !
Y
(&) M,)Ms M,Nqz M,OzP M,qq) P|( ((P )
K > Nz,PN |O,(q )z,NM qM,q| Mz,zP N,sN zq
!
} > (sss) PMq N|O M,MPs zq| z|z MNz NP
K > zM,qO MN,Oz qs,q( ),zs ),O( |,Nz z,|s
> (sss) z(( PqN OzP (sq qz MO 0
K > MN,)s qs,|P M|,sO (,qz q( z| 0
J>
(sss) zMz z|M (s| qO| (N q) z
K > M,(M M,zq M,)N Nz qP MN q
"%
>
(sss) Mq,zOO P,q|) M,)zq )P )) M,Oqs 0
K > M,|P NO MP M 0 z| 0
J > (sss) MzM MM( MqP Nz )M ) 0
K > M,zO |O |N qO MO ) M
e (-
D)
.*
(sss) Ms,|zs MN,PMq MO,)OM Mq ,O)P M|,O(O Mz,zzs N,NMM
K > z,zP q,)| q,qN q,MP q,|M (,)) |,(M
K > M,qq |P OO )O O( M,sq M,qs
" &7 (sss) ),P() ),zqs |,POs ),(M) ),s|O z,O|) M,ss)
K > (,Os z,qN z,)P q,q| q,(s M,OO M,(P
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
21/50
% K > qq ,zN M(,P( MN,z| Ms,)( M(,M( MM,M) M),M)
&7 (sss) )P,MOq PM,ONs M,s(,||s )O,(O( |q,qsO M,PM,NNz O|,qqz
K > (,zM (,PN ),P| q,)( M,O| P,OP |,(O
&
.Y
J >
(sss) D7 M,|OO q ,zMz q ,|(s z,qsz q ,Msz |PM
K > P,zs z,sz z,zs q,N| q,Nq z,O( q,|M
@ > (sss) O qs qO N) |) NO Os
K > M,|O (,q) z,Os P,q| ),N) O,(z q(,sM
.
57 . (sss)(P,zzz)),OsP (,zP,|||(),Msz qN,)qs MO,zz) MOq
K > Mz,)N O,|| |,qO z,PO q,)) q,MN (
> &Q > M),(zq O,zNs MO,)|P |,qsM Mq ,OqO ),s)N Mz
K > P,Nq q,qs (,qM M,qO q,(z M,M) M
&, ]
5 &., : &"* t9 *
)
[\]z-
][
[\]-
]^ [\]p-]\
[\y]-
yy
[\y-
y
[\z-
[
[\-
^
.> `
> (
!) )z( (q) (ON (M) )|P |PN zNP
K > qz,OM qz,qM q(,Oz MM,M| Mq ,sO qs,zM q(,)s
.Q & () Mz)z M()| M,)|N MsMq MPsN M)(| Mzs(
K > qN,)( qN,qN zM,|( Ms,q( M),(P q(,M| z(,()
> (sss) MNN zPM M)P Pq qO| qzN Oq
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
22/50
K > |,M( O,P( z,zM OM (,z| z,|O q,P(
@ Q1 > (sss) zs () |s qP (z qP Mq
K > ),q( |,Pz O,(P q,P| (,z) z,sN z,O)
7[
> (sss) PNs |zO |NM MON |PP )Ms M)P
K > M,PN M,|q M,OP (N M,zM M,(P )z
5
J>
(sss) PM Nq O| (s MNs MzO PP
K > M,sM M,sz Os zq O( M,(P )z
.* qN) z(s z|s zPO zsq z(O (M)
K > Mq,M) zz,zO q|,|s MP,M) qs,s( qP,PO zN,Mq
K
J>
zsO (qP P(z (MN Nz( )O( (zN
K > P,)N P,)) N,|( M,q( q,z( q,q) (,zq
&, y
5 @WZ"K "&., (t0 ,), *
7 MOqs-qM
MOzz-
z(
MOz)-
z|
MOzP-
zN
MOzO-
(s MO(M-(q MO(
& z(,Oqz MO,Psq qq ,MOq zq ,)|q qP,)sq qOOs) q(O
(8Q 7) ),M)O MP,M)s MN,szM qz,M(O M),|)q q(,OsP MP,s
J D7 MqzMM MPP|N qq,P(q q)|zN zzOzq qqqO
. ! ),O)z O,((M Ms,Mzq MM,MOs MM,qO( MM,((( MM,s
12
z,Pz,Ms
s z()O|( zN|POq (|(qN| (O|)Mz (O(q(( ((s
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
23/50
! } , ., &Y 12
577 7 .7 qM,M|( zs,zOq (s,)s( zN,|)) (MONP zNs)M qNN
@ Q M,|MP q|OM q)s| qOPs zzNz z|zP zsO
'R Q MMz |PN |Mq |Ms N|O N|( )z
1 1 2G7 '% MOqq n ! 12 . MOzz-1 HI !$
&,
:t9 (t0 ,) (!: 9 &)
MOz)-
z| MOzP-zNMOzO-(sMO(M-(q MO(z-(( MO((
.77 " zP,|q (M,|q z(,() qP,N| (M,MP ON,q
m zN,Ps (M,qO z(,N| qO,() (P,zM M,sq
"% .77 " (,NM ),Nz ),q) ),zM |,zz MM,s
m |,(s P,|P P,M| P,)z Ms,Nq Mq ,(
> ("% 12 ) " (q,(( (P,() zO,Ps zz,MP (P,)s M,sO
m (),Ms (N,O| (q ,sq z|,ON )N,Mz M,M)sour$e-+*+u2ra!anian an' 3*4*5 6o!ra#, 75e$ent +o$ial an' E$ono!i$
Tren's In In'ia8(ne9 'elhi, "% % 7. % L& "$ 2 / 12 ! &9 %
& $ >> K L & ! & * 9 5
1 .D .D !$ ()P)
() "% .@ & 5 " 5 {! Q $ 1
5> G G % * 12 % K ` &7 * 5/ 1 . 7$ L"
H+.@ K "G ! "G L MOqs- AF . 1 " HI 12 MOzs-
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
24/50
1 +7 "% .@ !f& HI ! L$()N) 5Dd ! 8IS.= G
" D,
MOzM 5Dd > . "% .@ *Q HI $q ULF
57! ., "C *Q . MO(| 7> % 7` L . D 12 % MO(P J7> 7-1 +7 .L ?"%
'7 . Q*$ MO(q & D MO(N +7 W>%
.@ Mz)s > > ! .Q "*$ 1 +7 Pqs > > % .
* 7 & X " " >p()O)
H+D K , G .> "% % " "G L$ "
& "% 0 K8 k ULFw .L/ 12
K .@ "% +7& .L/ = " . ; ^ 1 0 > =Q/ * $
%!" . X " ?S L ' ` ./ !*
o= 5? $ X?., YT" 5. MOqs D MO)s +7
8IS.= "% > 8 ) %2% D Q )M %2% . !*; 8IS.= "%
o ) %2% Q D )( %2% 9*; "% + & 5 1>
% MOqs D MO)) +7 ) %2% D Q zq %2% 9*$p (|s)
1> * %K . "% "G" ` , 1 W>%" .*
%8$
k ULF D W> MO(| ' MPss > 2 -1 .*$
MOz(-1 2 > (z %2% !, MO()-1 ( %2% * 5D O|
%2% "% D %+ !*$ (|M)
&, ^
, F*P :& (t9 )
D * % h '"%1
(K >)
> (K
>)
> (K 7/ (K "% .
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
25/50
>) >) (sss)
MOqP-qN N,Ps,OP (,M,MPP z((zO| M|,zP N,NP,z(
MOqN-qO O,s),s| (,zz,NN z,)z,zNq M|,z| O,qM,(q
MOqO-zs O,)),MN (,Ps,z| z|z|Mq M|,z( O,PM,)q
MOzs-zM O,O),PM (,PN,)M z,NP,Oss M|,zq Ms,Mq,sz
MOzM-zq Ms,z(,P| ),qO,zN zPOsz) M|,qO Ms,)M,s)
MOzq-zz Ms,Mq,|q ),sN,(| zPNMM| M(,Ns Ms,qP,(q
MOzz-z( Ms,s),() (,O(,|P z,Nz,sN) M|,M| Ms,qM,|M
MOz(-z) Ms,s(,qz (,Oq,|) zNz|NN M|,Mq Ms,qs,z)
MOz)-z| O,)O,O| (,)N,zM z,P|,qzz |,PN O,||,P(
MOz|-zP O,(q,Nz (,||,(q z,)P,zsP N,Pq O,)M,))
MOzP-zN O,((,Pq (,P|,Nz z)sOqs Mq ,|( O,)P,z|
MOzN-zO O,(O,PP (,N(,Nz z,(N,PMq M|,)P O,||,z(
MOzO-(s O,((,|q ),s),)M zqOzqN qM,(M O,||,sz
MO(s-(M Ms,sz,zP |,|q,q| q,)),Nzz qz,N) Ms,qP,qq
MO(M-(q O,)N,PO P,)M,N| M,)),qss q(,s( O,Nq,Nz
MO(q-(z MM,s(,)N Ms,M|,Ps |),OMq zq ,sP MM,z|,|)
MO(z-(( MM,Os,)P MM,qq,qO )M,qMs |O,s( Mq ,)O,|M
1 G !
1 2 kAw 12 D D . ?+ G% ?&*$ 1 5] .@" '
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
26/50
1 k ULF . + 5L . 1 1>
' D 7 * $(|q)
)) " > + * K% ` AF$ L" A!-% 7. AF
!* 1 MO(M 5 K% > * %$ % % D =& .D7 * L G K% 0 * ] .
." ! ^ K > "% .@ ! *$ 1> " K *
L *>G> ~ 1Q K " " +7 % "
d 5Dd ?+> 5K G$(|z)
2 MOM(-MO(P 5 5D % 1 2% L) MOqs-
. 1 * %K E (,J,&,}) #> L8 o= "%-.@
0 * 12 ' & !*;(|() G) 'D ULF & .L/ o= W>% 5+D *% (.>, G,72,) +7 .@"" 5'%$(|)) 1> "
! M) ULF 12 MOzs- W>% 7" R-"; q) 7"
"%8 7/ 2# "% % *Q 5Dd L&+ 'm$ W>
'L&" * G " % Q "*$
.,,, 'L&" IG },, "%,
%8 % K " !*$(||)
&-1q :, "#" b $ 1'> 2&9 % "AC[ ; .$ 2 -
"AC[ ! " " 2&9 : .@.)D 3 " ( Q .@.) 1 57/ 2#= o ';
" ' *$ ^ #> ! L Q " AS X- * + .6 *$ Q .@." "K AS
X, L Q + + *Q X- 1> 1 {7F 2&9 +
G .*$ " ?D #> L"= *>-~ " ?DK
C !*$ MO(( 12 MO(|1 " * 9 LG *> 7
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
27/50
XY% IF 5L& L XY% %." ?D "G* 12 " ?DK
* $ f # G +7 " %
. *, + B%C7 * $ (|P) 1 W>% LG " w
7 ?D L G X + $ L" W>% 12
& 'C " 1> " 2&9 &9 !, ?+ 5 > X
D 2L< *$ 2 MOqP " ?D! 1 2&9
X*$ L" 'v."#" + *$ + & 12 +& :
1 {7F % . = ! ! 1
.@." D L L" +7 ,W>%, ., 7" : .6$
(|N) ] 1 {7 G 8IS.=$ .% +-.%
! 1> " #>$ 7" . 1 2&9 % % ! " {7
? 5`S G .$ 1 % {! ` .@"A % 7 "$&E0 " ,! )$9 " #0 71 6
l / "0, "#0, * 5!H-.% [ 1
2&9 2. . .@" % .D '%` (L 5%7 A *)$ 1> *
.@" % %S L MOq) ` 12 MOqN & J G
577 G *$
X H+ 2% 5Dd " " 1 * , * " +
d 5D 1 !$ 1 K7 = + * W>% %$X- k X . .Iw " 1 "> + 1
" 5D D t: . . 7 12 %
[ Q 12 1 5t"7 52%- L 1 %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
28/50
2] "% . " " ?D= . "
L$ . K7 X D$ &&6 U/, 0
0,jP, !: ! jI ! : &/ ! &E0,0 &* !H )6
59Q9 >-"I@! !: 5! 1!@! 0 0 8 Q
!@! ) "
9 LG & % H+3" 2 L 1> ] "
$ .^ & & K !$ 1 7"" D
' +L& " $ 2 . . +! -.% + 12 K
+ 7 W>%" D ! % +7 K
! " 1& D$ ^ 1 'R G U-7" [ " n "
"$ 1G "-1> "! "G$
MOzM &n- D 12 2+ 7 !$ ^
h 0" ! o= 5Dd K " 7 " D$(PM) 1 *
. 2+ 2 2R/ 2L< 2" > .>- '7G7
AICCI 1 '`,) n"% G * , =,X(Pq) 4
L!1 2 " D-d ?D+ *$ MOzq W>%
7% +D > "! D
~ L L &8 " ?DF &*$
*Q 9 " & ) &, MO(q-1 G 1 9 .Iw
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
29/50
",%" >>,*Y*Q G L w & " & W>%
,k ULF ~ .= ?+ "$(P() 0w 7 )6 $q
/ 0 0 U/, &E0,0 WL =, !C6
: 5H 3 j9 ! 7 , 7* &$ 5! )- & &
7 Q , N" &0 &2 > &E0 &2
,! j96H
1 ." 8 ' " LDC . #>* &
$ MOs(-s) ?"% R > D 'D ULF .
'A "AC[ L " 8 D 1 +7
" . "@Q .* " 2&9 .*$ ^ L "
7"" D L&% * 18 " ?D .K ' *$ 2
" 1 Bk f f -1 k= "AC[ " "G !, 1
"G G " 'A =7 -" D G ! J-1 k
2] f 8IS.= ~ B !* L X
% & K .Q "% D 12
IF 7" " [ 1D Q $p (P))
. "!> "G 'A . ! . L$ 7u > MOqN W>% K 1> k W>%
5 K " . $ 3%7 1 ! 1 +
. 1 L 1 '"w K "" . 'L< ! .
5!$ { 1 5 !L7 G %" 2
$ *Y*Q }C ,
! L 1> HF .@" 2&9 7 IF LDD2]
L 5/ %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
30/50
. 5Dd % > 7 > +-= ! $
,
&8 ! 7 7 ! )- &S" )- 0Q 7 0K "7 &8 0,@!
"#0 @! &" 7X
1 7 7-1 1 ` 8 2% + ! *> *>
+7$(PP) 1 "% %" D o= 57 "
+.7 ! 7 7 IF " % 5
$
1 L 5/ '[>/0 ' $ L" 'D .L "
!L7 * . ^ " ?DF 7 /0
$ 'i " 5 * 1" }C$ MOzM 5+
2] F/ ,
" , L " . @ D " 5m !
LDL&7 . " +7= 5+]! +7p(PN)
w'"% A-> MOzM q) X 1 . G L L
"= k "" !L7 * > G% $(PO) MOz( *Y*Q
. 1 -7 6. $(Ns) ?+ ! . = 2 = 3%7 * ] "" K $ L" =2
" %& 2 5o= D &* 1 1> L
/0 k -. !t$ /0 IF L 7 Q
f -1 D .
/0 IF 2] t " D " Q n
*$p
,L . 1 " * ," * D 1Q-1 % > $&-; / &8 0! F6 )- &-; >! /-
&8 &' "1 @1 0! 1 "#0 0 /", _
" " , 1
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
31/50
1> ` L '% , G .L/ 1> +-/0 , *, 5D .> !
` K, , 1> + . L 00 5 *Q > . $ '%
5%7 9 ! L 0 " /0 52G7 5% "=
. $ 1> ? ! LD . 12 " +&
" ' & L" * , 12 .AD %/ D, 12
LDC AF ! .Q, 1> "G 7 @ D . LMOss &"
'% 77 ` /0 '; .7& %.L /
.*, MPOq Z LG "@Q *$p (NM)
L . L%f .%8, 1 1> .@ L& -&0
= 7 1> ?^ G ' L .@" ! L 1+ /0
K 12 57" G 8& ." . " #> $ K
/0 d " C !$ "!?. MOz) '`
5L 2+ 'i " >" 5+ X$ 1 D L L
/ ' 7! * " ?D 7
/0 1+ K K "> D$ MO(P-1 W>% -.% 5 .
7" . % "% " AS / ! ?+
% L$
"&-:
1D 5.K G L " G > % * 12 5%7
& 1&$ 1 & 5 % {! D7 w
.6 ' *$ 1 'n = L .y ." A .@" %
#>*,7" . % +> 3 ! 4 L ,
" 'D ~.Q .6 *$ 3" L '7" "% D :
+ 3%7 D . 1D f " %G*$ {! D7
' * L G ?+ 7" IF 2]
52% 5Dd " . % *$ U-! > 7" . % D {7F .@. . 2] 7
W>%" D " ? ?D 2! .*$ -.% IF &-
" 7" -% .@" % 2. "%
&*$ 12 1 % A .@" 12 A .@" %
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
32/50
!$ 7".@" .L ] f 1 + * G
}C "G*,
.& 1> :+ 5Dd =>d D d ?+ .6
"G L$ .& ?+ , ! } LF (MPsM-M()-1 . D W>%"1> ,$ Z 12 } 'k" IF W> K
7 .& 12 .%8 K 1*$ W> .* .& 12
.%=! *5Dd +,7] 12 .@ " K % *Q; , k. 12
>]X 7" +$C )- 59 :% )6 / &' &&6 *5, 3 "#0,
&E0 71 )9 )9 &/ P 15 7Q "*, 19 &'
199 )9 F- )- n !"# u ! )9 71&K% q5Hp
(Nq)
2 1 + 5l * $ ^ G 1 + 7
.& " 3 .& 1 % + --.% "%
; .& d ?+ S .K *,L"
* L ] .& 7" . %$ 2 { . D
% D " 3 +--.%"% 4
" L $
*&K$,:
M) The International ne9sletter o 76istori$al stu'ies on $o!intern,
$o!!unis! an' +talinis!8 (-), >-D, ">-D
q) Cite' in +hoonlal .utta Fu"tas B Co!intern an' the .estin# o
Co!!unis! in In'ia; -
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
33/50
|) &inutes o the n' $onress o the $o!!unist international, -, "art , 3ura2i 5o# (e'*) "@-
http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/http://www.marxist.org/ -
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
34/50
MN) +ele$te' 9orHs o +talin, ol-> &os$o9,< "-@D, " >
qO) This sa!e t#"e o aru!ent 9as ien 2# Utsa 3atnaiH, see %Nrarian
5elations an' N$$u!ulation8, e'ite' 2# U* 3atnaiH, or' uniersit# "ress,
@, " D-D=
zs) Karl &ar B7Ca"ital8 ol-, $ha"ter , =* Genin $olle$te' 9orHs, ol-,
%.eelo"!ent o $a"italis! in 5ussia, " -
zM) Iran 6a2i2, 7Colonization o In'ian E$ono!#, >>-@@8, +o$ial
+$ientist, &ar$h, >
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
35/50
zq) Pust re!e!2er the s"e$iQ$ $hara$ters o Jational an' Co!"ra'or
Loureoisie enu!erate' 2# Co!*&ao 'es$ri'e' in "reious "oints
zz) %The &iration o Lritish $a"ital to D>-2# G*6*PenHs, =,s"e$iall# see
$ha"ter-i -%Cos!o"olitan enter"rise
z() see %The Lrenner .e2ate e'ite' 2# N"ton an' 3hili"in, Ca!2ri'e D
z)) .*.*Kosha!2i, 7Intro'u$tion to the +tu'# o In'ian 6istor#8, Lo!2a#,
reise' n' e'ition, >, "-
z|) 7The In'ian Li Loureoisie- Its enesis, ro9th an' $hara$ter8- +uniti
Hu!ar Fhosh, "-
zP) In his 2ooH 7 The In'ian Li Loureoisie- Its enesis, ro9th an'
$hara$ter8-Co!* +*K* Fhosh trie' to sho9 the Co!"ra'or nature o the
In'ian Tra'ers* +ee $ha"ter - o his 2ooH** Nn' later he arue' a2out the
$hara$ter o this !er$hant $a"ital earne' throuh su$h $o!"ra'orshi" 9hen
the# 9ere ineste' in the in'ustries set u" 2# In'ians* Nn' !oreoer 2#
$itin the ea!"le o the GEJIJ+ !o'el o 'eelo"!ent o $a"italist
in'ustr# he trie' to question the nature o in'ian 2i in'ustr#* +ee $ha"ter ->
o his 2ooH**
+o I reer &ar in this $on$e"t* Karl &ar, Ca"ital, ol-, $ha"ter-@, "-
D,internet "' ersionhtt"://999*!arist*or*,
zN) +*.* &eheta, 7The Cotton &ills o In'ia D=, re"rint, "-
D, &i$hael Larratt Lro9n 7The E$ono!i$s o I!"erialis!8 "-=
http://www.marxist.org./http://www.marxist.org./ -
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
36/50
(q) A*5*6arris, 7Pa!setOi Jusser9anOi Tata- N Chroni$le o his lie8, Lo!2a#,
D, e'i,"->@-@
(z) i2i', "->
(() +ele$te' 9orHs o &ao Tse Tun, ol-, " D, Aorein Ganuaes 3ress,
3eHin,>>
()) 74ritins an' +"ee$hes o F*V* Poshi8, 3una 3-DD
(|) .a'a2hai JaoroOi-83oert# an' Un-Lritish 5ule in In'ia8, Gon'on, @;
5*C*.utta- E$ono!i$ 6istor# o In'ia- Earl# Lritish 5ule8=,
(P) Lenali translation o Li"an Chan'ras 7The 5ise an' Fro9th o E$ono!i$
Jationalis! in In'ia8, K*3*La$hi an' $o!"an#, D, "-
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
37/50
urther Feore Joa$h 7Un'erstan'in 6istor#8 s"e$iall# $ha"ter- *
.is"ro"ortions N!eri$an .eelo"!ent
))) N*K*La$hi, 73riate Inest!ent in In'ia, @@-8, Ca!2ri'e, >,
Cha"ter , >, s"e$iall# "-D an' ,
see $ha"ter , =** +"e$iall# "ae D, *
|))&i$hael Ki'ron- 7Aorein Inest!ents In In'ia8, oor' uniersit# "ress,
Gon'on,=, $ha"ter-
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
38/50
||) N'it#a &uHherOee, 7I!"erialis!, Jationalis!, an' the &aHin o In'ian
Ca"italist Class,@-8 Cha"ter-=
|P) The In'ian 2i 2oureoisie8 2# +uniti Hr* Fhosh, see the %"rea$e to the
n' e'ition, "-III
|N) N'it#a &uHherOee, 7I!"erialis!, Jationalis!, an' the &aHin o In'ian
Ca"italist Class,@-8 "-D
|O) AICCI, Nnnual 5e"ort-D, "- 1-.7 X/ +, 1 w- + '" A% '%
#>* 5 + $ - L- '+ 52% !t - =G 2A,,, {! + 1 .7 '+ .7 $> +7L& .G #>* X / !, .y & @
. "G* $ 8IS.= !t,X/ 1- .7 " '7K" (positivism) "% "AC D + .y7 u #>* - * -G7$
7 D % % 5/ .L/ ' .y 7 ! "% 'K.> .6. * $ K7 , 5, ?
. =8 "% $ .7> % X/ 1 1 .AD n ",L G L .AD (new world) ! $ 1 .AD .AD 7 &
http://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=pinteresthttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=pinteresthttp://shilpo-shahitto.blogspot.in/search/label/%E0%A6%A4%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%AC%20%E0%A6%93%20%E0%A6%A6%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%A8http://shilpo-shahitto.blogspot.in/search/label/%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%95%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6http://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=3253347759341168309&target=pinteresthttp://shilpo-shahitto.blogspot.in/search/label/%E0%A6%A4%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%AC%20%E0%A6%93%20%E0%A6%A6%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%A8http://shilpo-shahitto.blogspot.in/search/label/%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%95%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6 -
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
40/50
"% + .y7 G- " ' L h ! 9*$- #> Y J 2 . " .AD 7 .
&* ! ( , > "7 Y>5X "7 ! X1 5 57 >Y Y>)$
X/ > ! &Q * ! "% "AC[ D $ 1 "% h !t "$ '7K" *@ &*$ ","5 L, 5Dd % 7G7 " L {! + [ L* 1-.D $ > 1 "
'K.>> % }C; % 9 & 1 .y , W * X/$
!, X/ , 5Dd % [ o $ X, > .7 7> 9> " - d " .
&Q !* $ " = & < :" 7" , "'D, / .@" $ 9 1 .y ! ! + .@" 1 .** X/ $ >
.7 ! .>= 1$
" 7" '7K '; .6 > $ ^ + G 7 >. = + 1 ` D . L$ % , L- = D ! 7 1 !
1 .AD 5+ ! , - .D + 1 D *X/ $ X/ "G*, ! &* -, 5 L G; 5D !
9@ * A,?& A *Q L 1G * 5%C $. -57 ! 1- > 57 1 < .AD 7 !& 5R * $ "7" ' #>* 1 . #$ .AD K> G >.
?_, G 0 h - ' !* > $ 1- .7 > L- 2 D , -
L7 G@ . L " 7" [$ L 'D! * A, > * X/ $ "
7" D> > G }C G !$ , 1- '[> 1-.7 '+ .7 ,2 > = !t . ';
2A, , 5D 12 5[ .@" ' C ! &, + w- +" 1 $ .=, " L& * ", ^ . - X/ "G*, < ! .Q$
E #> "'D /" .@" $ 7 +7L& !} h 1 #>*$ X/ , 1 " 7 1 + "AC[
. '; ,^ " 5Dd w * 1 .+, .AD$
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
41/50
> G R 1> . 7 "S ! 9* $ 1-.7 .6 1 L, - !t %
$ * @ 5`S " 5`S $ , $ 7 1- .7 R GL&7 "$
L 1 1" /" D .@" ./ !*,> - D % }C !* $ / '% "7" +7
5Dd &@>*Q "A !, " +7 K o > !D, G * > 7> $ X/ "G*, /" 5D
"G 76. . % * $ !} 1> #>*$5\ " " X. Y ! 8 +7 } 1
+7L& 'D L !*, * . > $
0 . +.> '" $ X/ "G*, 1. u #> % & 7 $ 0 ! K h= !$ 1 * /" 5D
w$ ^ 1 1 5D 76 k '6. !, . % L D $ 5D = D 1 ! .Q$ =" -L"
* ], 7& .Q %!, &Q %!h &; " $ 8 . 1 ! " 5Dd w$ !} /
1 . #>$ K, X/ 1 {! k @ .7 = .7 * $ 7G7 5 w 5+9 - 1 " ` $ +7L& .y = D LG 7h8 [ L< !, G 1 5Dd w = " & $ Aw
5 5D 7 5D ./ !$ 7 .7 7 1.' "G " , 1 +! E #> .%$
= 1 u #>* U- .%" 7" $ + % #>* 1 .D$
X/ > 7> .@" > " D % 8IS [ G* $ 5D 'D m #> & =. ! 76$ 1 =+ o" #> .e .@ - .@" 5D % 1 76
8IS.= = . * > ! G * X/ $ .@ 1 . D ! 9 ! +.7 w$ X/ @ 7>
"G*, !7& h &Q 9 !} .@" } .%" U [ L< ! .Q $ L< ! .Q [$ ^ 1
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
42/50
} 7 X , 2 1 5 .% 6. . }" ! .Q$ X/ + * 1$
7G7 5 =7 + ! 7 '#> D, 7 % .D G L $ .@" + ' 1 x" "G "
* X/$ 5%7 : #>$+ 76 X/ W R *, > 7> 1
'X #>* $ = % % .@" 76 9 *$ 'i * .@" - B $
1 > '& .K * $ ',.,7> +7 "1 '&- '% #>* > $ 1 7> ! .@" [
0 0 .K * $ "G*,0 "7 {7 ] = .} [ o D$
'A [ " o D &$ [ 1 L o, 2!,'A-2, 1 X/ .7 =D $ L& 1> ?_ * @, 1!t - L& D $ X/ ]! * ! o $
, 1 ! 7 " " 2 "* $ * D, 'A * D ! .Q* t: $ 1> #>*,X/ ,
- AC 5# 9 $ 7 *"A%7 = [ o ! , ! 2 = $ ^
[ 1 + + > C !&*$ m ! &* . ">$ X f[ ! .Q*$ 1- '[ > ` &> G L$
` & " ` 7> * X/ : . 5n Bf[7 +7 " $ /" .@" " '/ 56$ `
B%% > $ &2% . L .D $ 1. X/ L" 6$ 57" 6. ! %!$ 1G GG
! 1 < $ Aw, 7, 5 , 1 1 + C 1G , ~ L, .+ $ ` L ! 9* + "f%, '$ / .@" "f! * 1G }C$
> 7> 57! .y 8 - d .6 57/ 8IS [ .6. !* $ " 'K.> 1 W
* X/$ ! ! 9* 1 .7 " 7G7- $ ! 7G7 , " k = ! ]! X/
.y 7 .G *$ H+ " , > .} ..=! '7K" " 'X K L $ +
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
43/50
7 *> f! > GL&7 "$ 1 . ' #>*L 1 'X * $ ^ X / ?_ "G* + . '; 1>
,$ , > K *, ! @ * "'D," B?% $ . 2A 5 L- ' %" . *,@ > * 5D!$
> '7K" .K- K= .6 K $ 1 = . "G* X/$ *, + .@" = L !*, Bl +7 " [ 9 $ "
W .@" ,^ '7K" + "G "AC $ > X/ "AC[ L , 1 2 . .9 G " "G "* $ > 8IS " G *, @
l+ +.7" ! =. #> $ L L $ 8IS! X Bl lA ! .Q, +7 X/ 1- 'X K $ !}U
1 !* "AC, &* * L . 'i! , 5]!7 $ !t, X/ , & . IF ! &* $ '7K" l .@" . 5[+ "CR1G $ ` 1 .7 "G, L
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
44/50
$ A U 2A & G @ * '7K" DD 7+ 2A$ 1 .6 '7K" D 5D!$
'7K" G " '}+ ! . , ..= $ 5D 1 '7K" k ' ! ! 5n . L $ X > 1
.7 5 * X/$
> 1> 8IS.= '[ !t , X/ , '&" l/ 5,5D!$ .@" &7.7 1G 7 76 5t"7 52% ! 9*$ 1
w *, 1 &7.7 '! & "t$ ^ 1 X . #>* +7w$.> 7 L. & 5 & " !
Lt$ X/ 1 > U7. L !%, .,B7 = #>*, "
" "AC *$ + "* DD '& D$ - .Q .AD* G }C @ G$
X/ * 'A.K 'x G, L@ G = !9* !} !, {!7 ?07 D $ 1 !"% # * 1
1 U76 " D,L" E #>* ' " 7" L&,^ % LDLD #> $ 1 , ! .@" .D 5] !*$
? > .@" W * X/$ 1 +-.7 ! 1 "% .K- K= .6.
"G*, " LDLD,2&.= .AD 2 ! & $ E #> .AD$ H+ 1 .AD , ?_ 7 .AD 7xG * $ @ G ?_, >. & D * $ *
- Q ' * $ 1 ',X/ 5 B " 1 1 {7 5=.=K, 5
$
?_ 1 .AD 7 L& - 1 " &Q 9* > G7.> $ 1 k ' ! [, '% [, 'A [
L. 2&.= 1 $ 1 '% .7 8IS 5?L,^ .7
[ Q * , ." 5[ $ > 7>> " D $ , &- 5 > &Q !* 1 G72%$ 1 '/ K "G L,! 1 *, 2&.= 1 G @ .*; ^ 'A.K " = , G, t: $ 1G .- ." 56 : :
Aw $ .7 % 5+7 1 ' L&, 5D . X ` #> 9,^ 1 ` .* L .= ! t:,Bf[7 1S R $ X/
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
45/50
1 ! 2 '7K *$ L ! D *, 1- 56 D L L "= $ X/ B +"
k ' *, + " 'K.> 1 .I0 5? * $ > .7> " D $
X/ 8IS.= " !t, "% 6 l.* $ " ! ., X/ , + B
"% w $ " B d .F 1 " " &Q I$ " #> . ' . $ G L 5 -/, D7
5o= X@ & * $ ^ " [ . ! & 1> }C
/ +7 !$p
7.+7 .78 "% Y L 1 "> " D %
*$ d 5Dd /+ 1 % R%$ @
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
46/50
G 1* 5D , , ; ' $ L @
*$ 7. $
, K ! @: G?Y[ ] L! > * 5 !"
+7 + .D7 D, . " ~ 1 +$ &%, % [ D
7 @+ $
1> L G ' 5g> 5 * G + %$ 1 2 !7 ">
+ ! G @ . L $
"AC[ G 7.+7 %! .7>$ 1 .7 '+ `
L%" 2 !7 $ ! %-K, ?_ 1 '% .*$
L%" D "G : 7@: L%" $ 1" L"
. . ! ? 7 ' L Q 5D 7 L?**** 1 '7" [ " I L%" " 1"
$p
L%" 1 x& ? $ ! !" ' S+ 1 W$
"% w #>* ". .7 $ < 2] A!w .>= + " K
* 1$
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
47/50
%". .7 "G " L , "% 5"7 < 2] 7" %"
.'K. ]! *$ ". %. IF 2] * @ *$ 1 .7
2] " *$
%" 7 o !* : 8 , Q.fQ!
1 1 > 52%$ . D .7 %% +7 " J `
1 "> " > * G$ d %% [ 7 *$
5%7 & .= . D '% .$
5!2 .7 -, +n L E> ! v.K "AC[
!*$ "% .AD L 5& ! ! * L +aA, ,
5. !" ?D . ! 7.+7$
1> I1> & I!Twitter-1 & I Facebook-1 & I Pinterest 1 & I
0 &0, Q,
: z )!, ]z[
-!7-G ' "% 5? G AC "% .
" .9 !? > >1 1> ' + 2 7!7 5'% D -Y '%7 k .K !$ -!7 ?AC 2 . "%
! .Q$ 1 2 AC.D / +$ "% !7 1 +
. = $% . ' 7+ . &" 5 *$ X
" w x "G L$ 2 !7 1 .K
" % " & L&* 1D F+ L$ 1 .
" 57J-J G7 " h"% 7& B%7" + '/ C
$ k !LF . X7+ = "F 'i " 1 .D % !, 1 +
R% B% 56 }C ! 9$ 2 !7 !I! hL % K$ @ D &"
1 . K " '" C D* "
http://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=pinteresthttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=pinteresthttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=emailhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=bloghttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=twitterhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=facebookhttp://www.blogger.com/share-post.g?blogID=7046539449371614524&postID=8027066110228457182&target=pinterest -
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
48/50
$ L U!7 0 ` ! ?A$ "%Q ! "
" '; $ "% l % #>*$
L * & * 5 ',/ A7 G & 9 &$/ ! n, L G "%-"% d + $
7 2& 7 & "" [ "% 2# Q .Q
"% D 7 !$ B -X L D A7! '/"=
D &/ ~ , H+/G A/ += % " %/
Q %$***/ 5/ 5 '/ " ! / G A$
` .o .-o ! 7 = + 1 5L
%X ! 4$ 'D " . 12 % > ] X '" ' % K$ L >1 1> [ o L-1 .o! ` 7 L
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
49/50
12 1> .< 7 ' 1 D 5[ ! $ "% ]! .
+ + ?"% kF ! 7+ $ " 7"% D .
d 2A & ' D * ! K7 "$
"% !7 . .9 " .%$ X 1> 1 . 7
77 2! 7& 7. '$ "% 12 % 7! 1
+ "A "K .9 >$ "% .9 += !7 &
L, B%7" , ^ " > $ " 7 '+ B%C7 ! ?
L + !7 ! $ ` . 12 v"B7 +$ U!7 [ 7. 't: ! 12 1 ' "D " .%.%
" > "> K7$
k ULF . D- 56 .'K " & G.
$ "F kF 7 /$ &9 && 7D$ "
'+ " 12 ; 7 '% . 2] "%$
X . & &" L0 +* L . &
' &$ - +7 5" Aw 12 !-
{7 2] +-
x " A H ` }
A .@* $
L " 9 .9 G@" % !
K AD G %$***
1" Q !
' %$" D !, A ` }
% + &$
> 5/7 A ` .@" % [ *$ 1*Q
% `> 5" % .%.% {7F '+ . ! '; *$
L A- 5[ > ! 9* 2] '7$
-
7/21/2019 Marxbad.docx
50/50
!" % " "[ '+- * X> 9$ !
G @+ 5h ! .